More Z06 Woes....
Well after having spent all that money upgrading heads, mods and a tune, now the car is making a whining noise :( (almost like a car where power steering is going or is low on fluid, but I checked and fluid is not low and no leakage)
It just started last night, got louder this morning when driving to work so I turned around went home a dropped the car off, picked up my beater to drive to work. What bothers me is that my C5 made a similar noise just before the balancer bolt just about shot through the radiator and I know the C6's have the same issue. :crazy: :toetap: I will say the noise is not present when the Car is in Neutral, and I slightly rev the engine...it happens once I start driving the car in 1st, and going through the gears,, so it could be tranny related I don't know. Again, my C5 had very similar symptoms , slight rev not under load , no noise , start driving and it would whine. If this is another big dollar repair...I am done with the car. I had moved on from the head issue, was not happy about being proactive , but accepted and moved on now this...... it's hard because the car just keeps giving me reasons to get rid of it and get another toy... SRT Challenger or Mustang or something else. What's even more aggravating is that I purposely did not do a cam or any big mods persay because I wanted to stay close to stock and avoid any problems and enjoy the car. Car has stock cam in it, so the motor has never even been opened. Not a happy camper., and those that know me locally, this is on par wtih my luck with cars etc.. |
Originally Posted by FrankTank
(Post 1583895904)
Well after having spent all that money upgrading heads, mods and a tune, now the car is making a whining noise :( (almost like a car where power steering is going or is low on fluid, but I checked and fluid is not low and no leakage)
It just started last night, got louder this morning when driving to work so I turned around went home a dropped the car off, picked up my beater to drive to work. What bothers me is that my C5 made a similar noise just before the balancer bolt just about shot through the radiator and I know the C6's have the same issue. :crazy: :toetap: I will say the noise is not present when the Car is in Neutral, and I slightly rev the engine...it happens once I start driving the car in 1st, and going through the gears,, so it could be tranny related I don't know. Again, my C5 had very similar symptoms , slight rev not under load , no noise , start driving and it would whine. If this is another big dollar repair...I am done with the car. I had moved on from the head issue, was not happy about being proactive , but accepted and moved on now this...... it's hard because the car just keeps giving me reasons to get rid of it and get another toy... SRT Challenger or Mustang or something else. What's even more aggravating is that I purposely did not do a cam or any big mods persay because I wanted to stay close to stock and avoid any problems and enjoy the car. Car has stock cam in it, so the motor has never even been opened. Not a happy camper., and those that know me locally, this is on par wtih my luck with cars etc.. Was the AC on? |
Sorry to hear about that. Good luck. It's for sure frustrating.
|
Originally Posted by propain
(Post 1583895975)
Sorry to hear this.
Was the AC on? Nope, I have been emailing the tech that works on my car this morning, he told me to unplug the alternator while car is running and see if that has any effect, I am at work now so can't look more into it yet. I looked at the crank bolt and pulley while the car was running, maybe its just m e being paranoid but it seem to be moving quite a bit, but again hard to tell, I was in a hurry and needed to get to work :ack:
Originally Posted by 04_Z06_CE
(Post 1583895980)
Sorry to hear about that. Good luck. It's for sure frustrating.
|
Nothing is more frustrating and saps the fun out of car ownership then mechanical troubles, hope its nothing serious. Looking back I think the timing was right in many ways when I decided to sell the Z06, if you reach that point don't worry.....plenty of choices out there for a fun car.
|
Could it be a belt whine like maybe some coolant got on the belt during the head replacement?
|
Originally Posted by Silver05GTO
(Post 1583896041)
Nothing is more frustrating and saps the fun out of car ownership then mechanical troubles, hope its nothing serious. Looking back I think the timing was right in many ways when I decided to sell the Z06, if you reach that point don't worry.....plenty of choices out there for a fun car.
Originally Posted by Buddy A
(Post 1583896144)
Could it be a belt whine like maybe some coolant got on the belt during the head replacement?
|
Well, if you say it makes noise when it is in gear only, maybe your engine mounts could be going bad? Maybe the engine could be shifting and causing a misalignment?
|
Weren't you having some transmission issues Frank?
|
We had a whining sound last year coming from our '08, sounded like a faint version of what you hear from square-cut racing gears. Was quite loud in 1st, 2nd and 3rd, faded out with 4th. Ended up with all of the gears and counter-gears for everything except 4th being replaced due to excessive wear. All covered under power train. Between that and the new LS7 after our original popped, Bryner Chevy billed out a lot to GM for our car last summer!
|
Originally Posted by '06 Quicksilver Z06
(Post 1583896822)
Weren't you having some transmission issues Frank?
Not sure if that is tied to this noise, I did not try listening for the noise if I back up if it did it too... if I am rolling in 1st gear very light in the gas moving forward , there is no noise, it's only when I start getting faster and the RPM start to rise above about 1,200 |
Originally Posted by TheKomoman
(Post 1583896887)
We had a whining sound last year coming from our '08, sounded like a faint version of what you hear from square-cut racing gears. Was quite loud in 1st, 2nd and 3rd, faded out with 4th. Ended up with all of the gears and counter-gears for everything except 4th being replaced due to excessive wear. All covered under power train. Between that and the new LS7 after our original popped, Bryner Chevy billed out a lot to GM for our car last summer!
I am pessamistic due to my luck with cars in the past, so I prepare for the worst (as is the case here) and if its not, its a surprise and blessing. :(:crazy: |
Originally Posted by FrankTank
(Post 1583896891)
Yeap, well, they were isolated to going in R only, and I discovered if I put the clutch in, move the shifter to 1st, then back center and to R, no issues. My mechanic thinks the Synchros are bad in the Reverse gear.. but no other issues, 1, 2,3 all gears work and engage great, clutch is fine no pedal issues or slippage..
Not sure if that is tied to this noise, I did not try listening for the noise if I back up if it did it too... if I am rolling in 1st gear very light in the gas moving forward , there is no noise, it's only when I start getting faster and the RPM start to rise above about 1,200 Would you consider it a load problem or an RPM problem? If you are steady on the pedal does the noise start at a certain RPM every time? The noise did not happen while in neutral and revving? Were you still rolling when in neutral and revving? |
Originally Posted by FrankTank
(Post 1583896891)
Yeap, well, they were isolated to going in R only, and I discovered if I put the clutch in, move the shifter to 1st, then back center and to R, no issues. My mechanic thinks the Synchros are bad in the Reverse gear.. but no other issues, 1, 2,3 all gears work and engage great, clutch is fine no pedal issues or slippage..
Not sure if that is tied to this noise, I did not try listening for the noise if I back up if it did it too... if I am rolling in 1st gear very light in the gas moving forward , there is no noise, it's only when I start getting faster and the RPM start to rise above about 1,200 I hope this isn't the case with your car, but it's a possibility. And if you find out that your current problem is the crank bolt/pulley, the transmission more than likely next, so fix it and get rid of it. IMO |
Originally Posted by FrankTank
(Post 1583896922)
and this is my Worst nightmare come true if the case, and could very well be , Money-wise it would be stupid for me sell the car if I have to get a new trans, but at this point I am so frustrated with this POS that someone may end up buying a used Z06 07 with the head issue addressed, and a brand new Trans!! No more GM anything for me after this and bye bye Z06
I am pessamistic due to my luck with cars in the past, so I prepare for the worst (as is the case here) and if its not, its a surprise and blessing. :(:crazy: |
Originally Posted by propain
(Post 1583896935)
Would you consider it a load problem or an RPM problem? If you are steady on the pedal does the noise start at a certain RPM every time? The noise did not happen while in neutral and revving? Were you still rolling when in neutral and revving?
I can roll in Neutral and rev and there is no noise, but again I did not rev it that high. When in 1st grear moving forward steady on the Gas I would say the noise starts just above 1500 RPM or a tad less. It's present in 2nd and 3rd gear, I never made it up into 4, by that point I was doing the speed limit and decided to turn around and go home.
Originally Posted by NachosZO6
(Post 1583897040)
I am not saying it's your transmission, but I had this same very issue. Every gear went in fine except for R. After a while, putting in 1st wouldn't do it, it still wouldn't go in R. It never whined though, but when I had the dealer look into it, they found every gear busted. I'm not sure how that happened so they practically had to replace the entire transmission, under warranty.
I hope this isn't the case with your car, but it's a possibility. And if you find out that your current problem is the crank bolt/pulley, the transmission more than likely next, so fix it and get rid of it. IMO I have a buddy here local that had the same thing you describe a couple years ago on his 06 , he was still under warranty too. My power-train warranty went out last May so I am SOL big time. Car has 27,000 miles on it , no track time ... I am the 2nd owner, car was/is in great shape. Anyone who has worked on it comments how clean it is undercarriage, engine parts etc.. it's clearly not been abused or if it had they hid it well. I've owned the car since 2010 and bought it with 13k miles on it. |
Originally Posted by FrankTank
(Post 1583897335)
At this point, I am thinking load problem, when in "N" I did not really Rev it above 2500 and in doing so there is no noise , I am a little scared to do so honestly above 2500.
I can roll in Neutral and rev and there is no noise, but again I did not rev it that high. When in 1st grear moving forward steady on the Gas I would say the noise starts just above 1500 RPM or a tad less. It's present in 2nd and 3rd gear, I never made it up into 4, by that point I was doing the speed limit and decided to turn around and go home. Yeap either one , Tranny will be huge bucks :ack: ....crank bolt ./pulley if it just has come loose or backed out , Labor will suck and be costly (I replaced the one on the C5 myself in the garage not doing that again) , but won't be as bad as Trans assuming no other damage is found on the snout or anything else, the parts will be a lot cheaper, just maybe new dampner or ARP bolt, or whatever. I have a buddy here local that had the same thing you describe a couple years ago on his 06 , he was still under warranty too. My power-train warranty went out last May so I am SOL big time. Car has 27,000 miles on it , no track time ... I am the 2nd owner, car was/is in great shape. Anyone who has worked on it comments how clean it is undercarriage, engine parts etc.. it's clearly not been abused or if it had they hid it well. I've owned the car since 2010 and bought it with 13k miles on it. What about an '11+ Mustang GT? Slap a supercharger on it and call it a day? Or a GT500 and just drive it stock? Plenty fast...or change the pulley slightly ;). Or back into a C5Z, add a supercharger and call it a day? Any of those options would give you a ridiculously fast car... |
Wow Frank....really sorry to hear this. I know you were pumped with the head work that you just did and quite honestly, I took your lead and am considering doing the same to mine after the GMPP runs out in September. Another guy on here had a valve guide inspection done, was found out of tolerance and his extended warranty picked up the bill for new heads. I can do the same but I'm thinking that nothing will be fixed but just delayed, so I'd rather just have WCCH do it on my dime.
Is the whine possibly a throwout bearing? Is it at all clutch engagement/disengagement related? I knew you were having problems going into R but I don't believe synchros will whine like that. When I look at my crank pulley, I see a very slight wobble but the pulley actually runs true. It's the bolt head/washer that looks like it's wobbling very slightly. I'm hoping for a power steering pump in your case, hopefully not the trans. Good luck man..:cheers: |
Originally Posted by Black96WS6
(Post 1583897506)
Sorry to hear about that Frank, that sucks.
What about an '11+ Mustang GT? Slap a supercharger on it and call it a day? Or a GT500 and just drive it stock? Plenty fast...or change the pulley slightly ;). Or back into a C5Z, add a supercharger and call it a day? Any of those options would give you a ridiculously fast car... Yea lots of stuff out there, so would be interesting to see what happens. I would probably go Ford or Dodge this time around, just can't see myself giving GM any more money. I am going to take a good hit if I sell the Vette, I don't owe that much, but to offset the cost of labor and a new trans, or fixing a crank bolt with labor, I will have to take some of the equity to pay for these repairs, but again I would rather do that and be rid of the car if thats what happens.
Originally Posted by JJC5
(Post 1583897510)
Wow Frank....really sorry to hear this. I know you were pumped with the head work that you just did and quite honestly, I took your lead and am considering doing the same to mine after the GMPP runs out in September. Another guy on here had a valve guide inspection done, was found out of tolerance and his extended warranty picked up the bill for new heads. I can do the same but I'm thinking that nothing will be fixed but just delayed, so I'd rather just have WCCH do it on my dime.
Is the whine possibly a throwout bearing? Is it at all clutch engagement/disengagement related? I knew you were having problems going into R but I don't believe synchros will whine like that. When I look at my crank pulley, I see a very slight wobble but the pulley actually runs true. It's the bolt head/washer that looks like it's wobbling very slightly. I'm hoping for a power steering pump in your case, hopefully not the trans. Good luck man..:cheers: |
:eek::ack:
|
I've heard that the Mustang Boss 302 is supposed to be built tough. If I hadn't fallen in love with the looks of the Vette I might have gone with a low miles used Boss and supercharged it.
|
Originally Posted by '06 Quicksilver Z06
(Post 1583896822)
Weren't you having some transmission issues Frank?
|
On the other hand, it would be a shame if you got the whine fixed and then sold it when that was the last remaining issue. In other words, you would be selling a reliable (?) fun car w/o any issues.
Tough decision either way, hope the whine is something minor/cheap. |
Didn't read the whole post the first time so I'm changing my post. I hope it ends up not being anything too serious.
|
I'm thinking it has something to do with your transmission Frank.
And that time on the dyno, dialing the tune in, probably didn't help it. |
Originally Posted by Adam_W
(Post 1583900145)
I've heard that the Mustang Boss 302 is supposed to be built tough. If I hadn't fallen in love with the looks of the Vette I might have gone with a low miles used Boss and supercharged it.
|
I have nothing useful to add but would like to keep informed of what the cause turns out to be. Im hugely paranoid about my crank bolt since I don't really know how tight I got mine when I put it back in.
|
Just take it to a shop an diagnos it professionally. have yourself a beer while you wait. I used to get all worked up and freak out over things that pop up and surprise you but when it comes down to it 99% of the time people tend to sweat the small stuff. Stay calm and be happy that you own the most beautiful and one of the most powerful all around vehicles ever made. It's a car. Things break. But.... Not all car break and look this good:) go get it checked out first and make a game plan from there. I'm sure if its major there are plenty of local people that would love to help you out. Good luck.
|
Originally Posted by Dallasb84
(Post 1583901004)
Just take it to a shop an diagnos it professionally. have yourself a beer while you wait. I used to get all worked up and freak out over things that pop up and surprise you but when it comes down to it 99% of the time people tend to sweat the small stuff. Stay calm and be happy that you own the most beautiful and one of the most powerful all around vehicles ever made. It's a car. Things break. But.... Not all car break and look this good:) go get it checked out first and make a game plan from there. I'm sure if its major there are plenty of local people that would love to help you out. Good luck.
|
You -can- get a wrench on the balancer bolt if you just take off the intake tube (the filter to throttle body plastic thingy).
that would tell you if its moderately loose or not anyway. |
Thanks everyone for the replies. I checked the crank bolt earlier after work today and its tight, and I took a look at the pulley etc.. while the car was running and it appears normal, no leakage or anything. When my C5 crank bolt went it was leaking prior obviously the seal
The car is at the Vette shop where I have the work done by trusted mechanic and friend. When I drove it over there, as I was shifting gears , I could hear the pitch of the whine change from gear to gear as they engaged, by change I mean it would stop for a split second as I shifted to the next gear, so I can't see how it is not the trans, unless its something in the rear end or axles or something:crazy: I reved the engine a bit higher in neutral (3500 RPM) and no whine or noise or anything Again gears engage fine (except for R) , clutch and pedal feel are normal no slippage at all. I am hoping to hear something in the next few days
Originally Posted by Dallasb84
(Post 1583901004)
Just take it to a shop an diagnos it professionally. have yourself a beer while you wait. I used to get all worked up and freak out over things that pop up and surprise you but when it comes down to it 99% of the time people tend to sweat the small stuff. Stay calm and be happy that you own the most beautiful and one of the most powerful all around vehicles ever made. It's a car. Things break. But.... Not all car break and look this good:) go get it checked out first and make a game plan from there. I'm sure if its major there are plenty of local people that would love to help you out. Good luck.
|
Yeah it goes that way sometimes. I hope it's something minor. Wouldn't it be great to service the tranny and diff and the noise goes away?
|
I have a bit of the grinding in first gear at low speed and clunk in the rear end. Gonna change the fluids and hope it goes away.
|
Originally Posted by FrankTank
(Post 1583902281)
Thanks everyone for the replies. I checked the crank bolt earlier after work today and its tight, and I took a look at the pulley etc.. while the car was running and it appears normal, no leakage or anything. When my C5 crank bolt went it was leaking prior obviously the seal
The car is at the Vette shop where I have the work done by trusted mechanic and friend. When I drove it over there, as I was shifting gears , I could hear the pitch of the whine change from gear to gear as they engaged, by change I mean it would stop for a split second as I shifted to the next gear, so I can't see how it is not the trans, unless its something in the rear end or axles or something:crazy: I reved the engine a bit higher in neutral (3500 RPM) and no whine or noise or anything Again gears engage fine (except for R) , clutch and pedal feel are normal no slippage at all. I am hoping to hear something in the next few days I hope you are right and I am wrong, I could be overreacting, but we will see. The bigger issue here is that I just spent a couple grand (actually more) on heads, tune, headers and install not even a month ago.,. had this happened before that I would have just addressed the problem and maybe have sold the car then...but now this comes right on the heals of that. Not to mention I was unlucky enough to also have to purchase all new TI intake valves , so even the heads were about 700 more than most are paying. Thats not my cars fault, but just very shtty luck on my part timing-wise. :ack: I've had at least on person tell me that the ported FAST intake manifold is a bit noisier than stock. But when I first had the work done on the car, I could hear it. Very faint though and can still hear it. What of the above mods do you have? |
Frank
I got my fingers crossed for you :thumbs: :cheers: DH |
Frank, you're in the last lap of a 100 lap race. Don't throw in the towel yet. I know it's easy for me to say...
You've been had one of the coolest heads through all this insanity. Don't reverse plans now. I'll say an automotive prayer for you. This board needs members like you! |
I hope that it all turns out alright.
Did your mechanic not diagnose this a while ago when you car is being serviced? Maybe this was new, but it seems as though from your posts that he knew about it, so I am not sure why he would release the car to you if he knew there were problems (If this is the case). |
Sorry to hear about the woes Frank. I know first hand about problems with the Z06. Let me just say that I bought my 07 with a lot of miles, 67k to be exact. And man did I go through some pain. I think it cost me about 15k to fix the issues, but when you buy AS-IS that's what happens. It was very dis-hearting as I also had to make payments while fixing.
All I can say Frank is whatever the problem was for me I just really didn't like anything else on the market. I sold my Pro-Street car for factory horsepower and I couldn't afford a ZR1. Even now I'm buying parts to make the car look the way I want. Even if you bought another car the money it would take to make it handle and run like the Z would cost as much or more than fixing your car. I guess what I'm trying to say is you may buy another car with more problems, that may not make you feel as good as your Z06. |
Originally Posted by '06 Quicksilver Z06
(Post 1583902465)
I have a slight whine also, but my heads are ported, as is my intake manifold, I have a Callaway Honker as well, so I know now that mine is due to the increased airflow.
I've had at least on person tell me that the ported FAST intake manifold is a bit noisier than stock. But when I first had the work done on the car, I could hear it. Very faint though and can still hear it. What of the above mods do you have?
Originally Posted by Dirty Howie
(Post 1583903336)
Frank
I got my fingers crossed for you :thumbs: :cheers: DH
Originally Posted by Undy
(Post 1583904060)
Frank, you're in the last lap of a 100 lap race. Don't throw in the towel yet. I know it's easy for me to say...
You've been had one of the coolest heads through all this insanity. Don't reverse plans now. I'll say an automotive prayer for you. This board needs members like you!
Originally Posted by JG853
(Post 1583904192)
I hope that it all turns out alright.
Did your mechanic not diagnose this a while ago when you car is being serviced? Maybe this was new, but it seems as though from your posts that he knew about it, so I am not sure why he would release the car to you if he knew there were problems (If this is the case).
Originally Posted by JwT
(Post 1583904290)
Sorry to hear about the woes Frank. I know first hand about problems with the Z06. Let me just say that I bought my 07 with a lot of miles, 67k to be exact. And man did I go through some pain. I think it cost me about 15k to fix the issues, but when you buy AS-IS that's what happens. It was very dis-hearting as I also had to make payments while fixing.
All I can say Frank is whatever the problem was for me I just really didn't like anything else on the market. I sold my Pro-Street car for factory horsepower and I couldn't afford a ZR1. Even now I'm buying parts to make the car look the way I want. Even if you bought another car the money it would take to make it handle and run like the Z would cost as much or more than fixing your car. I guess what I'm trying to say is you may buy another car with more problems, that may not make you feel as good as your Z06. ...I know that sounds stupid :lol: but I would be willing to sacrifice performance for long term reliability at this point , and have a factory warranty on a new toy and put this behind me. thanks again everyone for the kind words and support :cheers: |
Best of luck Frank. So sorry to hear of the ongoing problems.
|
Just remember guys we are driving a 505hp supercar that can beat many of the best cars in the world. You are not driving a Honda daily driver built to last 300k miles. Sports cars, especially high powered models, are ALWAYS going to be less reliable than the average car and will require higher maintenance. Imagine what P and F car owners pay when their car breaks down (which I guarantee is more often). I know my car can outrun an F430, GT3, Viper, and doesn't cost 1/3rd as much to fix. Heck a GT3 Motor easily costs $25k-30K. I have a friend with a F430 and his headlight got smashed by a rock and it was $2k for the headlight assembly.
|
Originally Posted by 95jersey
(Post 1583904722)
Just remember guys we are driving a 505hp supercar that can beat many of the best cars in the world. You are not driving a Honda daily driver built to last 300k miles. Sports cars, especially high powered models, are ALWAYS going to be less reliable than the average car and will require higher maintenance. Imagine what P and F car owners pay when their car breaks down (which I guarantee is more often). I know my car can outrun an F430, GT3, Viper, and doesn't cost 1/3rd as much to fix. Heck a GT3 Motor easily costs $25k-30K. I have a friend with a F430 and his headlight got smashed by a rock and it was $2k for the headlight assembly.
This is the 2nd T56 Tranny I will have fail on me (assuming this time it is in fact the trans) in 2 different corvettes. :crazy: both that are just over 50HP of stock power levels. I guess this is why Rodney at RPM is doing so well (beefing up unreliable Transmissions) and keeps upgrading to larger facilities LOL |
It's all in the engineering. You can see it in the head design down to the windows that will not index properly. I think you would be well served to sell the car and get something with a little better build quality. I was in the same situation a few months ago with my Z and got the car out of my life.
|
Originally Posted by CFLZ
(Post 1583905659)
It's all in the engineering. You can see it in the head design down to the windows that will not index properly. I think you would be well served to sell the car and get something with a little better build quality. I was in the same situation a few months ago with my Z and got the car out of my life.
Some of the folks in here don't like for people to say that, and they will swoop down on you like those flying monkeys in Oz. :D |
Originally Posted by FrankTank
(Post 1583905526)
Makes sense and I agree to a certain extent, however my car having no track time, and if the Trans has failed with less than 30k miles that is pretty poor IMO. Sure, I modded it now, but it's 474 RWHP, not like I am pushing 550 or 600RWHP and expecting the stock tranny and clutch to last 100k. In fact, this is exactly why (despite a lot of ball busting) I did NOT do a cam or any big power mods. I wanted to stay as close to stock as possible.
This is the 2nd T56 Tranny I will have fail on me (assuming this time it is in fact the trans) in 2 different corvettes. :crazy: both that are just over 50HP of stock power levels. I guess this is why Rodney at RPM is doing so well (beefing up unreliable Transmissions) and keeps upgrading to larger facilities LOL http://forums.corvetteforum.com/c6-p...nsmission.html |
Originally Posted by CFLZ
(Post 1583905659)
It's all in the engineering. You can see it in the head design down to the windows that will not index properly. I think you would be well served to sell the car and get something with a little better build quality. I was in the same situation a few months ago with my Z and got the car out of my life.
I just bought my '08 Z06 (my first corvette), which I love, but I'm coming into this with my eyes wide open and I like to be realistic about what the Z06 is and is not. |
Originally Posted by '06 Quicksilver Z06
(Post 1583905687)
Better watch that part in bold.
Some of the folks in here don't like for people to say that, and they will swoop down on you like those flying monkeys in Oz. :D This scene came to mind: |
I would like to know what this turns out to be.
z51vett Doug |
Originally Posted by propain
(Post 1583905741)
|
Originally Posted by LFZ
(Post 1583905971)
I laffed my ass off when Flash, Mark Wahlberg, and that damn Teddy bear did coke together....funny as hell!
Go flash go! :rofl: Great cheesy movie... |
Originally Posted by z51vett
(Post 1583905900)
I would like to know what this turns out to be.
z51vett Doug |
Originally Posted by propain
(Post 1583906000)
Go flash go! :rofl:
Great cheesy movie... |
Originally Posted by '06 Quicksilver Z06
(Post 1583905737)
Originally Posted by z51vett
(Post 1583905900)
I would like to know what this turns out to be.
z51vett Doug |
Hey Frank, just a thought and this might be a REALLY stupid question but are you positive that you have a full fluid level in your trans? Have you ever checked it? If the trans has been low on fluid, that road trip you took could have done it in. A clue might have been that tough shift into reverse. Good luck man...I hope this turns out to be really minor.
|
Originally Posted by FrankTank
(Post 1583896922)
and this is my Worst nightmare come true if the case, and could very well be , Money-wise it would be stupid for me sell the car if I have to get a new trans, but at this point I am so frustrated with this POS that someone may end up buying a used Z06 07 with the head issue addressed, and a brand new Trans!! No more GM anything for me after this and bye bye Z06
I am pessamistic due to my luck with cars in the past, so I prepare for the worst (as is the case here) and if its not, its a surprise and blessing. :(:crazy: |
Originally Posted by JJC5
(Post 1583906162)
Hey Frank, just a thought and this might be a REALLY stupid question but are you positive that you have a full fluid level in your trans? Have you ever checked it? If the trans has been low on fluid, that road trip you took could have done it in. A clue might have been that tough shift into reverse. Good luck man...I hope this turns out to be really minor.
Originally Posted by DON T.
(Post 1583906303)
Frank, i could not help but smile reading how this post ended. Blessing!! Hopefully things will work out and your love for your Z will not diminish. But, if something needs fixing, its still a blessing. :yesnod: PS, do i need to duck now....:hide:
|
Originally Posted by 95jersey
(Post 1583904722)
Just remember guys we are driving a 505hp supercar that can beat many of the best cars in the world. You are not driving a Honda daily driver built to last 300k miles. Sports cars, especially high powered models, are ALWAYS going to be less reliable than the average car and will require higher maintenance. Imagine what P and F car owners pay when their car breaks down (which I guarantee is more often). I know my car can outrun an F430, GT3, Viper, and doesn't cost 1/3rd as much to fix. Heck a GT3 Motor easily costs $25k-30K. I have a friend with a F430 and his headlight got smashed by a rock and it was $2k for the headlight assembly.
My buddy went through this same issue with his Z06, He got so sick of fixing back to back issues, he just fixed it and sold it as fast as he could. He now owns a whipped 2011 Mustang GT that has not given him a single problem in the almost 2 years he owned it. |
Originally Posted by bladex10
(Post 1583909734)
A Z06 isn't a supercar. ZR1 maybe but not Z06. Its still a mass produced Chevy at the end of the day that Chevy doesnt seem to want anything to do with anymore. Its sad to see because they are awesome cars, They are just unreliable as hell. I've seen more z06 engine failure threads in the last year than i care to count. Its no Honda but it shouldnt be in the shop getting the motor torn apart for a flawed head design as soon as you buy one and you sure as hell shouldnt worry about a valve dropping using the car what it was intended for.
My buddy went through this same issue with his Z06, He got so sick of fixing back to back issues, he just fixed it and sold it as fast as he could. He now owns a whipped 2011 Mustang GT that has not given him a single problem in the almost 2 years he owned it. I don't know where you are getting your numbers from but a Z06 is not a mass produced Chevy. A Z06 is also considered a supercar. I agree however failures shouldn't happen with such low miles. The Mustang GT reference also does not apply as that is a mass produced Ford and it doesn't come anywhere close to pushing the limits of its platform. I think you need to rethink your position. |
Anyone who thinks the Z06 is not a supercar doesn't know the car.
With just a few mods this car will clip 200 mph. Most expensive supercars don't go much faster and cost thousands more. Just try paying for those parts and you'll love a Z. Frank I wasn't aware that you were running a T56. I was lucky when I picked up my Z. The dealers vette mech lived just 7 miles from my house and he works on the side cheaper. When my T56 went south the mechanic told me that the second and fourth gear have always been very weak in these units. I had two choices from RPM transmission. Buy a 6060 or have my T56 rebuilt to handle 700 hp, which is what I did. It set me back about $2800.00 but I also picked up a torque tube and a scoggin dickey clutch so the cost was much more. This may be the case Frank, but the cost isn't a killer to fix. |
Originally Posted by bladex10
(Post 1583909734)
A Z06 isn't a supercar. ZR1 maybe but not Z06. Its still a mass produced Chevy at the end of the day that Chevy doesnt seem to want anything to do with anymore. Its sad to see because they are awesome cars, They are just unreliable as hell. I've seen more z06 engine failure threads in the last year than i care to count. Its no Honda but it shouldnt be in the shop getting the motor torn apart for a flawed head design as soon as you buy one and you sure as hell shouldnt worry about a valve dropping using the car what it was intended for.
My buddy went through this same issue with his Z06, He got so sick of fixing back to back issues, he just fixed it and sold it as fast as he could. He now owns a whipped 2011 Mustang GT that has not given him a single problem in the almost 2 years he owned it. |
Originally Posted by bladex10
(Post 1583909734)
A Z06 isn't a supercar. ZR1 maybe but not Z06. Its still a mass produced Chevy at the end of the day that Chevy doesnt seem to want anything to do with anymore. Its sad to see because they are awesome cars, They are just unreliable as hell. I've seen more z06 engine failure threads in the last year than i care to count. Its no Honda but it shouldnt be in the shop getting the motor torn apart for a flawed head design as soon as you buy one and you sure as hell shouldnt worry about a valve dropping using the car what it was intended for.
My buddy went through this same issue with his Z06, He got so sick of fixing back to back issues, he just fixed it and sold it as fast as he could. He now owns a whipped 2011 Mustang GT that has not given him a single problem in the almost 2 years he owned it. back on topic, mechanic drove the car yesterday a few times, he says it's definitely the Trans , or possibly in the drive shaft somewhere but he did not have a chance to tear into it yet to see more. |
It saddens me to read this over and over on this board. I have owned sports cars for over 15 years and never have I seen such issues. This will be the first and last Government Motors vehicle that I will own.
|
Originally Posted by JwT
(Post 1583910169)
Anyone who thinks the Z06 is not a supercar doesn't know the car.
With just a few mods this car will clip 200 mph. Most expensive supercars don't go much faster and cost thousands more. Just try paying for those parts and you'll love a Z. Frank I wasn't aware that you were running a T56. I was lucky when I picked up my Z. The dealers vette mech lived just 7 miles from my house and he works on the side cheaper. When my T56 went south the mechanic told me that the second and fourth gear have always been very weak in these units. I had two choices from RPM transmission. Buy a 6060 or have my T56 rebuilt to handle 700 hp, which is what I did. It set me back about $2800.00 but I also picked up a torque tube and a scoggin dickey clutch so the cost was much more. This may be the case Frank, but the cost isn't a killer to fix. Looks like the Level IV T56 for the Z (pre 08 cars) is about 2300 bucks. If this were not happening on the heals of my completing mods, I might not be as aggravated , but the timing could not be worse, and that has what has bittered me to the point of wanting to just dump the car..that and like I posted above this is the second T56 on 2 vettes that has failed. :ack: |
Originally Posted by FrankTank
(Post 1583913773)
[...] mechanic drove the car yesterday a few times, he says it's definitely the Trans , or possibly in the drive shaft somewhere but he did not have a chance to tear into it yet to see more.
Perhaps the trans can be rebuilt cheaper than being replaced; I guess it will depend upon the condition after teardown/inspection. I once replaced one, and only one, clutch pack in an automatic trans (my '79 C3, probably a TH400) . . . funds were tight at the time, and it solved the problem http://i1114.photobucket.com/albums/...in_notooth.gif |
As an ex Z06 owner, I sold mine partly because of the valve issues, my sympathies to you FrankTank. The only recommendation I have for you is try to bring down the emotions and THEN make your decision. And trust me, I know how hard it is to take the emotions down a notch. My Z was the most awesome, powerful car I will ever own. But Chevrolet has let a lot of folks down, including me. It's one of the reasons I am not on the buying a C7 first thing train.
|
Originally Posted by Mark200X
(Post 1583914385)
:(
Perhaps the trans can be rebuilt cheaper than being replaced; I guess it will depend upon the condition after teardown/inspection. I once replaced one, and only one, clutch pack in an automatic trans (my '79 C3, probably a TH400) . . . funds were tight at the time, and it solved the problem http://i1114.photobucket.com/albums/...in_notooth.gif
Originally Posted by ByByBMW
(Post 1583914885)
As an ex Z06 owner, I sold mine partly because of the valve issues, my sympathies to you FrankTank. The only recommendation I have for you is try to bring down the emotions and THEN make your decision. And trust me, I know how hard it is to take the emotions down a notch. My Z was the most awesome, powerful car I will ever own. But Chevrolet has let a lot of folks down, including me. It's one of the reasons I am not on the buying a C7 first thing train.
Actually this morning, I've pretty much decided it is what it is...sht happens , the initial real anger and pizzed off feeling is gone, now its just more I am disappointed in the whole deal.. adding to the frustration is even the fact that I had to buy all new intake valves when I had WCCH do the heads,,so even something simple like that, I got shafted and was way over budget. Its the sum of everything added up that's made me pretty much say..(pending the outcome) it's time to pick up and move on to another car. The whole reason I did not do a CAM or blower, or even Nitrous for big power is this right here...I did not want to have to start building the trans or buy a clutch and start modding the entire power-train...well now regardless the trans took a dump anyway LOL |
Tank,
Sucks to hear.:ack: Kevin figure anything out yet? Tim :cheers: |
Originally Posted by ipmtim
(Post 1583915999)
Tank,
Sucks to hear.:ack: Kevin figure anything out yet? Tim :cheers: |
Originally Posted by ghoust
(Post 1583914122)
It saddens me to read this over and over on this board. I have owned sports cars for over 15 years and never have I seen such issues. This will be the first and last Government Motors vehicle that I will own.
|
Originally Posted by LS7 DREW
(Post 1583916139)
What car has never had issues?? This isn't a GM thing, it's a car thing stuff breaks on every car
I have a C63 AMG. Actually I had one.. sold it and traded for another one because its such a good car. Both cars tuned and tracked pretty hard. Not one problem. People I know with the same car have pushed it to its limits both NA and FI. Some have 1000HP. Not a single engine failure since 2008. The only thing that I have seen go is the rear diff. Mostly because it doesn't come with an LSD. Now once you get above 600WHP the trannys cant hold up and need to be strengthened. But lets keep the argument stock vs stock then. Not 1 single failure on the forums. Head bolts are the biggest issue right now. Every GM car I have ever owned has had problems. Its most certainly a GM thing. Will I still buy them? Sure, they have a rawness you cant get from other cars. Will I tolerate catastrophic failure at 25K miles? No. |
The main issue with the Z06 has a fix out there, do the fix or sell the car simple as that. And it's not that expensive to do
|
Originally Posted by LS7 DREW
(Post 1583916477)
The main issue with the Z06 has a fix out there, do the fix or sell the car simple as that. And it's not that expensive to do
|
Originally Posted by LS7 DREW
(Post 1583916477)
The main issue with the Z06 has a fix out there, do the fix or sell the car simple as that. And it's not that expensive to do
You feel this is acceptable? You set your expectations way to low my friend. |
I have accepted it GM isn't going to do anything about it so I had to. People are so quick to bitch and complain these days but refuse to act
|
Originally Posted by bladex10
(Post 1583916642)
The issue here is that you shouldnt have to rip apart the motor of a new car for it be reliable. Theres alot of Z06 owners who dont know this "fix" or issue and they are out driving their car around that could let go at any given time and cause thousands in damage. GM should have recalled this issue LONG ago but they just ignored the issue and swept it under the rug.
|
Originally Posted by LS7 DREW
(Post 1583916762)
I have accepted it GM isn't going to do anything about it so I had to. People are so quick to bitch and complain these days but refuse to act
Your above statement confirms this is indeed a GM issue. Good for you fixing it, most people don't feel they should have to rip apart a car with 25K miles on to fix an issue they shouldn't have to fix. Sure, anyone out of warranty that sits around and pouts and complains about the issue but doesn't sell the car or do the fix really need to ask themselves who is to blame when it goes boom. |
Yes your right GM is the only manufacture to ever make a car that has issues.....idk why I need to argue about what I said its a fact almost every car out no matter the manufacture has their own issues
|
I agree with you Propain but if GM had admitted ANY sort of liability or negligence, there would be law suits all over the place and beyond the LS7. That would have set a precedent that would never end.
|
Originally Posted by LS7 DREW
(Post 1583916818)
Yes your right GM is the only manufacture to ever make a car that has issues.....idk why I need to argue about what I said its a fact almost every car out no matter the manufacture has their own issues
Sure other cars have issues. This is the only car I own that has an issue on a stock motor that if left unchecked will result in catastrophic engine failure. Do you know of any others that have this issue? |
Originally Posted by JJC5
(Post 1583916848)
I agree with you Propain but if GM had admitted ANY sort of liability or negligence, there would be law suits all over the place and beyond the LS7. That would have set a precedent that would never end.
Thats for sure. The closest we got was in the sticky above. If it made it to a TSB many would sue GM for damages, and rightfully so. |
I've seen Mazda speed 3s fail bone stock and heard about them failing bone stock from locals. That's one I can remember off the top of my head. Others I'm sure you can Google to find.
|
Originally Posted by LS7 DREW
(Post 1583917037)
I've seen Mazda speed 3s fail bone stock and heard about them failing bone stock from locals. That's one I can remember off the top of my head. Others I'm sure you can Google to find.
Either way, its a manufacturer problem not a "cars fail" problem. Good luck Frank. |
Originally Posted by LS7 DREW
(Post 1583917037)
I've seen Mazda speed 3s fail bone stock and heard about them failing bone stock from locals. That's one I can remember off the top of my head. Others I'm sure you can Google to find.
While I would have preferred not to deal with this on my Z06, Drew has a point. Not every car is perfect may have a weak point somewhere in their design. It is unfortunate, but there are lots of good cars that have some issue. The Z06 isn't the only one that has to deal with it, but at least we have a fix. We can hope that the manufacturer fixes it, otherwise, its up to the owners to foot the bill or sell it and buy something else. Another good example are 911 Turbos, GT2s, and GT3s, which are known to have coolant hoses pop off and dump all of its coolant. Results can be extremely catastrophic. These cars are in the 150k range and can get close to $250k. You may be aware of coolant pipe issues on GT1-block equipped models (GT3, GT2, Turbo), where coolant pipes come apart while driving and the rapid loss of engine coolant can cause spins/crashes at race tracks when slippery coolant sprays all over the rear tires. The problem exists on the GT1 motor because there are a couple coolant pipes in these motors that are not a single cast piece: the larger cast pieces have extruded inlet/outlet tubes that are connected using an adhesive. There is no metal-to-metal friction or press-fit to keep these tubes in place, so after enough heat cycles the adhesive will soften/loosen up and the tube will come out of the cast block (with the hose still attached), resulting in a rapid loss of engine coolant. Regardless of how the vehicle is driven, it seems this problem may eventually effect all 996/997 Turbo, GT2 and GT3 models including the 2010+ GT3 and GT3RS. If you are interested in having us repair the car at our facility, the price to remove and re-install the engine with this repair is approximately $2800 USD. http://sharkwerks.com/porsche/techni...urbo-cars.html |
Originally Posted by LS7 DREW
(Post 1583917037)
I've seen Mazda speed 3s fail bone stock and heard about them failing bone stock from locals. That's one I can remember off the top of my head. Others I'm sure you can Google to find.
the thing that is driving me now (no pun) away from GM and the Z06 is the fact that okay so I addressed the potential problem with the heads, turned it around into a positive, modded and gained some power... moved on, it happens but now, to have the Tranny fail on the same car with no track time and under 30k miles, to me I draw the line.. those are 2 major components with this car I forgave GM for the head debacle, fixed it and moved on. I can't be as forgiving with the car this time around having the Tranny fail. and of course I'll be honest, the timing of everything does have an impact on my decision |
I'd be mad too that you had bad luck with the car, but personally I just see that as a risk of owning a performance car. It sucks that you have an issue with the trans I hope it's a cheaper fix than what your expecting and you can enjoy the car after.
Originally Posted by FrankTank
(Post 1583917230)
Drew, I can understand where you are coming from to a degree, and I would also agree.. every manufacturer of course has cars break and QC problems etc... Ford and Dodge have their cars that have issues too...
the thing that is driving me now (no pun) away from GM and the Z06 is the fact that okay so I addressed the potential problem with the heads, turned it around into a positive, modded and gained some power... moved on, it happens but now, to have the Tranny fail on the same car with no track time and under 30k miles, to me I draw the line.. those are 2 major components with this car I forgave GM for the head debacle, fixed it and moved on. I can't be as forgiving with the car this time around having the Tranny fail. and of course I'll be honest, the timing of everything does have an impact on my decision |
Originally Posted by LS7 DREW
(Post 1583917292)
I'd be mad too that you had bad luck with the car, but personally I just see that as a risk of owning a performance car. It sucks that you have an issue with the trans I hope it's a cheaper fix than what your expecting and you can enjoy the car after.
This excuse doesn't quite sit as well with me as I own many performance cars without any kinds of issues like this. I would also agree more if the performance car was being used for its performance like at the track and events like you and I both attend. When being used as a DD I feel for the guy who just finished addressing the "one issue" with the Z06 and a few weeks later has a bad tranny on a car with less than 30K. Performance car should mean better built. Not fall apart quicker. But Ive always been a firm believer of pay to play. The problem comes in when people aren't playing yet they still have to pay. |
I heard from people that the cars have had failures with people just cruising around, I can't remember what they said the weak link was it was like 4yrs ago that I heard about it lol.
My aunt had a similar problem on her cayenne turbo s but luckily it was under warranty. And that's a 100+k suv
Originally Posted by Jawnathin
(Post 1583917190)
There was talk about their rods being a little weak and have snapped when at full boost during low RPM, but I've yet to have an issue with mine. It has been pretty reliable and far less of a money pit than the Z06 has been. There has been issues with owners doing mods but not upgrading the fuel system, causing an engine failure, but that is an owner error.
While I would have preferred not to deal with this on my Z06, Drew has a point. Not every car is perfect may have a weak point somewhere in their design. It is unfortunate, but there are lots of good cars that have some issue. The Z06 isn't the only one that has to deal with it, but at least we have a fix. We can hope that the manufacturer fixes it, otherwise, its up to the owners to foot the bill or sell it and buy something else. Another good example are 911 Turbos, GT2s, and GT3s, which are known to have coolant hoses pop off and dump all of its coolant. Results can be extremely catastrophic. These cars are in the 150k range and can get close to $250k. You may be aware of coolant pipe issues on GT1-block equipped models (GT3, GT2, Turbo), where coolant pipes come apart while driving and the rapid loss of engine coolant can cause spins/crashes at race tracks when slippery coolant sprays all over the rear tires. The problem exists on the GT1 motor because there are a couple coolant pipes in these motors that are not a single cast piece: the larger cast pieces have extruded inlet/outlet tubes that are connected using an adhesive. There is no metal-to-metal friction or press-fit to keep these tubes in place, so after enough heat cycles the adhesive will soften/loosen up and the tube will come out of the cast block (with the hose still attached), resulting in a rapid loss of engine coolant. Regardless of how the vehicle is driven, it seems this problem may eventually effect all 996/997 Turbo, GT2 and GT3 models including the 2010+ GT3 and GT3RS. If you are interested in having us repair the car at our facility, the price to remove and re-install the engine with this repair is approximately $2800 USD. http://sharkwerks.com/porsche/techni...urbo-cars.html |
Originally Posted by LS7 DREW
(Post 1583917292)
I'd be mad too that you had bad luck with the car, but personally I just see that as a risk of owning a performance car. It sucks that you have an issue with the trans I hope it's a cheaper fix than what your expecting and you can enjoy the car after.
Originally Posted by propain
(Post 1583917326)
This excuse doesn't quite sit as well with me as I own many performance cars without any kinds of issues like this.
I would also agree more if the performance car was being used for its performance like at the track and events like you and I both attend. When being used as a DD I feel for the guy who just finished addressing the "one issue" with the Z06 and a few weeks later has a bad tranny on a car with less than 30K. Performance car should mean better built. Not fall apart quicker. But Ive always been a firm believer of pay to play. The problem comes in when people aren't playing yet they still have to pay. Oh well... I'll have to see what happens and go from there. It's ashame because there is so much I do love about the car, looks, power etc. light weight. |
Originally Posted by FrankTank
(Post 1583917378)
Thanks man, me too :thumbs:
This is really what has me disappointed and scratching my head...car is not making big power, not tracked (I had actually planned to start tracking it since I fixed the heads) sure the occasional blast on the street or something but thats it. Oh well... I'll have to see what happens and go from there. It's ashame because there is so much I do love about the car, looks, power etc. light weight. My opinion Frank is that you should fix it and keep it. Sorry you have to and honestly its completely unacceptable that you did but your almost there. What give someone else your hard earned money after fixing it. :thumbs: |
Originally Posted by propain
(Post 1583917399)
My opinion Frank is that you should fix it and keep it. Sorry you have to and honestly its completely unacceptable that you did but your almost there. What give someone else your hard earned money after fixing it. :thumbs:
|
Originally Posted by propain
(Post 1583917399)
My opinion Frank is that you should fix it and keep it. Sorry you have to and honestly its completely unacceptable that you did but your almost there. What give someone else your hard earned money after fixing it. :thumbs:
Tough break, your tranny going at a time like this, or really any time. But you've come this far, seems a shame to fix it, sell it, and let someone else reap the benefits of your efforts. |
Originally Posted by FrankTank
(Post 1583917412)
I may have a change of heart and keep it who knows, and believe me...the less emotional part of the brain is telling me the same thing you are....why spend the money and put a brand new trans in the car (or freshly rebuilt one) and then sell it :crazy:
|
Originally Posted by FrankTank
(Post 1583917412)
I may have a change of heart and keep it who knows, and believe me...the less emotional part of the brain is telling me the same thing you are....why spend the money and put a brand new trans in the car (or freshly rebuilt one) and then sell it :crazy:
|
Originally Posted by z0sicktanner
(Post 1583919109)
if you need help on a trans rebuild hit me up.:thumbs:
|
Originally Posted by z0sicktanner
(Post 1583919109)
if you need help on a trans rebuild hit me up.:thumbs:
|
Didn't read all 5 pages but any verdict on the problem?
|
Originally Posted by Mopar Jimmy
(Post 1583919747)
I don't care what anyone else says Chad, your ok in my book, Tin hat and all. :) You know I'm just busting your stones man, all in good fun! - : )
|
Originally Posted by CFLZ
(Post 1583905659)
It's all in the engineering. You can see it in the head design down to the windows that will not index properly. I think you would be well served to sell the car and get something with a little better build quality. I was in the same situation a few months ago with my Z and got the car out of my life.
|
Originally Posted by propain
(Post 1583917399)
My opinion Frank is that you should fix it and keep it. Sorry you have to and honestly its completely unacceptable that you did but your almost there. What give someone else your hard earned money after fixing it. :thumbs:
|
Originally Posted by z0sicktanner
(Post 1583919109)
if you need help on a trans rebuild hit me up.:thumbs:
Originally Posted by ck9887
(Post 1583919925)
Didn't read all 5 pages but any verdict on the problem?
|
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 10:04 AM. |
© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands