[Z06] Should I Replace the Valves now? 20K on the clock
#22
7th Gear
Member Since: Feb 2010
Location: Herriman Utah
Posts: 7
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
With some cars having valve failures resulting in exploded engines, I'm wondering if it is a good idea to replace my valves and springs as preventitive maintence.
My car is a 06 with 20,000 miles. The engine is stock except for the big Lingefelted Oil tank and an Aviad oil pan baffle.
It has Never been over reved, but it has seen thousands of red line shifts and done more track laps and drag strip passes than I can count.
If I were to replace the valves and springs, what are the the best parts to use?
Who would be the best Company to send my heads to?
Thanx in advance for any and all opinions.
My car is a 06 with 20,000 miles. The engine is stock except for the big Lingefelted Oil tank and an Aviad oil pan baffle.
It has Never been over reved, but it has seen thousands of red line shifts and done more track laps and drag strip passes than I can count.
If I were to replace the valves and springs, what are the the best parts to use?
Who would be the best Company to send my heads to?
Thanx in advance for any and all opinions.
My car is out of warranty and I want to keep it around for many more miles and years, so I figure the relatively little money now was worth the peace of mind that I want with this car.
#24
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Jan 2003
Location: Portland Oregon
Posts: 8,596
Likes: 0
Received 16 Likes
on
15 Posts
I guess they're not the hollow stem. They're listed under "Super Alloy".
CHEVROLET SMALL BLOCK - LS7
Part # / Type / Head Dia. / Stem Dia. / Overall Length / Tip Length / References
F1598P / E / 1.615 / 0.313 / 5.227 /.180 / 15º Flo.Rad.Grov.Sup.Alloy.Turbo Application
F1597P / E / 1.615 / 0.313 / 5.227 / .180 / 24º Flo.Rad.Grov.Sup.Alloy.Turbo Application
CHEVROLET SMALL BLOCK - LS7
Part # / Type / Head Dia. / Stem Dia. / Overall Length / Tip Length / References
F1598P / E / 1.615 / 0.313 / 5.227 /.180 / 15º Flo.Rad.Grov.Sup.Alloy.Turbo Application
F1597P / E / 1.615 / 0.313 / 5.227 / .180 / 24º Flo.Rad.Grov.Sup.Alloy.Turbo Application
#25
7th Gear
Member Since: Feb 2010
Location: Herriman Utah
Posts: 7
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I don't know the answer to your question. I'm not a mechanic and I won't pretend to be an expert on the exhaust valve issue. I talked to 3-4 knowledgable people about the issue and decided to have the heads shipped to Charlie and Keith at RPM Motors. The work I had done was what they recommended.
#26
Safety Car
I don't know the answer to your question. I'm not a mechanic and I won't pretend to be an expert on the exhaust valve issue. I talked to 3-4 knowledgable people about the issue and decided to have the heads shipped to Charlie and Keith at RPM Motors. The work I had done was what they recommended.
#27
Le Mans Master
I thought the current working theory was that the guides were not the problem, but excess heat transfer from the sodium filled valves was causing excessive premature wear in some cases.
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/c6-z...-begins-3.html
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/c6-z...-begins-3.html
#28
Drifting
Is this really necessary?
Is the problem really any deeper than the valve spring itself? Have we seen failures where the spring is intact and the valve stem brakes?
I am very interested, thinking of going from a C5Z which I love to a C6Z next year. We have had issues with valve springs breaking (to be expected with an aggressive camshaft), but I belive that is the extent of the problem in the C5.
I am very interested, thinking of going from a C5Z which I love to a C6Z next year. We have had issues with valve springs breaking (to be expected with an aggressive camshaft), but I belive that is the extent of the problem in the C5.
#29
Le Mans Master
Is the problem really any deeper than the valve spring itself? Have we seen failures where the spring is intact and the valve stem brakes?
I am very interested, thinking of going from a C5Z which I love to a C6Z next year. We have had issues with valve springs breaking (to be expected with an aggressive camshaft), but I belive that is the extent of the problem in the C5.
I am very interested, thinking of going from a C5Z which I love to a C6Z next year. We have had issues with valve springs breaking (to be expected with an aggressive camshaft), but I belive that is the extent of the problem in the C5.
#30
Safety Car
I thought the current working theory was that the guides were not the problem, but excess heat transfer from the sodium filled valves was causing excessive premature wear in some cases.
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/c6-z...-begins-3.html
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/c6-z...-begins-3.html
Even then, if the guides are fine, then there isn't a problem of heat transfer, or at least it isn't related to mileage or daily usage. Which then, if it is related with racing, there's a whole lot more questions that needs to be answered, such as if the correct grade of oil was used, if it is related to oil starvation issues, was it tuned to lean etc etc...
then reading your link, and seing a set of head being worked yet no guides are changed begs to wornder...because in your link he said the valves were fine, the guides were not...might as well be flindfolded and start shooting in hope to hit a target...
Last edited by mirage2991; 05-28-2010 at 10:52 AM.
#31
Former Vendor
#32
Le Mans Master
there is one (maybe more) builder on this forum that uses those sodium filled valve in his race car with no problem.
Even then, if the guides are fine, then there isn't a problem of heat transfer, or at least it isn't related to mileage or daily usage. Which then, if it is related with racing, there's a whole lot more questions that needs to be answered, such as if the correct grade of oil was used, if it is related to oil starvation issues, was it tuned to lean etc etc...
then reading your link, and seing a set of head being worked yet no guides are changed begs to wornder...because in your link he said the valves were fine, the guides were not...might as well be flindfolded and start shooting in hope to hit a target...
Even then, if the guides are fine, then there isn't a problem of heat transfer, or at least it isn't related to mileage or daily usage. Which then, if it is related with racing, there's a whole lot more questions that needs to be answered, such as if the correct grade of oil was used, if it is related to oil starvation issues, was it tuned to lean etc etc...
then reading your link, and seing a set of head being worked yet no guides are changed begs to wornder...because in your link he said the valves were fine, the guides were not...might as well be flindfolded and start shooting in hope to hit a target...
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/1574098856-post94.html
Originally Posted by Richard@WCCH
Given the same conditions, the bronze guides will wear as well. The size of the small heat path must be increased. With a solid stem valve heat is allowed to travel further up the length of the stem. It provides a larger flow path for heat dissipation.
The primary heat path is through the valve seat. The secondary heat path is through the valve guide. Lean stoic. conditions at cruising speeds generate lots of heat on the exhaust valves with unleaded fuels. The heat bakes the small amounts of oil that makes it to the lower portion of the exhaust guide. Once the lubrication is gone there is metal to metal contact and on a molecular level electron sharing occurs. The steel molecules of the exhaust valve stem have a greater resistance to wear. The powdered metal guides have mixture of wear resisting alloys along with lubricious properties pressed into the matrix. You don't have to beat on the engine to experience valve guide wear.
The primary reason we use bronze valve guides is because GM will not sell the guides separately. Rather they will sell you an entire replacement head. The aftermarket parts supply only furnishes bronze alloy valve guides. I personally like the powdered metal valve guides the factory uses but the supplier does not sell piece meal to the public. Additionally we have no long term wear issues with the bronze guides and solid stem stainless steel valves.
In the last decade GM has done a masterful job improving both metallurgy and rocker arm geometry to reduce overall valve guide wear. Rocker arm designs are also superbly executed. The issues seem to only be related to the sodium valves.
Hope this helps.
Richard
Last edited by VetteVinnie; 05-28-2010 at 02:39 PM.
#33
Drifting
Interesting... Sodium filled exhaust valves have been around in the Z06 since '01 (I think, possibly '02). This is the first I have heard of this type of issue, but I am by no means 'in the know'.
#34
Safety Car
They are also used on most Turbo applications.
#35
Burning Brakes
I've seen many cases where some guides are just plain beat up. In the case of my ride, two of my guides were looking very iffy
I do drive hard so
On the flip side, I've seen less than 5K miles "grocery-getters" drop a valve. It's 50/50 amigos, it really is. You can get lucky and drive for 100k miles and not have any issues. Or, hope for the best but if not, then let’s hope the damage is minimal.
Best/worst case, busted valve and perhaps a guide or two, seats and that's that. Worse/worse case: busted valve, jagged up piston, and cracked sleeve, chewed up CC…bye bye head and perhaps a new short block. No scare tactics, just the plain truth. Look around you!!!!
I replaced my exh valves with one piece SS units, new guides, new springs kit and I'm never looking back
Thanks,
Carlos
I do drive hard so
On the flip side, I've seen less than 5K miles "grocery-getters" drop a valve. It's 50/50 amigos, it really is. You can get lucky and drive for 100k miles and not have any issues. Or, hope for the best but if not, then let’s hope the damage is minimal.
Best/worst case, busted valve and perhaps a guide or two, seats and that's that. Worse/worse case: busted valve, jagged up piston, and cracked sleeve, chewed up CC…bye bye head and perhaps a new short block. No scare tactics, just the plain truth. Look around you!!!!
I replaced my exh valves with one piece SS units, new guides, new springs kit and I'm never looking back
Thanks,
Carlos
Hmmm sounds like FUD to get business to me. GM does have a warrenty on the engine for 100K.
#39
Team Owner
Member Since: Apr 2001
Location: Elmhurst, IL (West Suburb of Chicago) & Home of MEGA Horsepower
Posts: 26,714
Received 584 Likes
on
399 Posts
St. Jude Donor '06
What's the best replacement valve spring to use on a stock LS7 engine, what is the replacment upgrade that most use w/out comprising and overtaxing the nice light weight valve train on our LS7 engines?
I know from past experieince you don't want to use to heavy of a valve spring and want a replacment spring be similar to the charateristics of the stock springs to keep the lightweight valve train in tact, etc.
What valve spring accomplishes this (or do most with stock LS7 engines just replace with stock LS7 springs (or is their a single valve spring that is more durable that still is extremely compatible with the lightweight features of the LS7 valvetrain?
I know from past experieince you don't want to use to heavy of a valve spring and want a replacment spring be similar to the charateristics of the stock springs to keep the lightweight valve train in tact, etc.
What valve spring accomplishes this (or do most with stock LS7 engines just replace with stock LS7 springs (or is their a single valve spring that is more durable that still is extremely compatible with the lightweight features of the LS7 valvetrain?
#40
Le Mans Master
LOL
To OP... Seriously... you have 20k hard miles and you want to rebuild the top end?? To me that seems excessive. I understand that there have been some members that have had issues. But the C6 Z06 has had it's share of batch issues since day one. My car ( late '06 Z) had a bad intake valvespring.... yes it broke at 14k and I was lucky enough to shut the car down before any collateral damage occurred. There was the bad rockers in '07 bad trannies in '08 and I feel the valves could be just that... a few bad ones. I understand the paranoia that can hit when we read the posts of broken valves...
But how is replacing a light weight sodium filled valve with a one piece heavy valve going to wear over time. That could be even worse then the stock valves over time. I am not sure what the answer is, but if it makes you feel better... spend the money for the peice of mind. But IMO if you are seriously worried about it... maybe it is time for a different car!!!
To OP... Seriously... you have 20k hard miles and you want to rebuild the top end?? To me that seems excessive. I understand that there have been some members that have had issues. But the C6 Z06 has had it's share of batch issues since day one. My car ( late '06 Z) had a bad intake valvespring.... yes it broke at 14k and I was lucky enough to shut the car down before any collateral damage occurred. There was the bad rockers in '07 bad trannies in '08 and I feel the valves could be just that... a few bad ones. I understand the paranoia that can hit when we read the posts of broken valves...
But how is replacing a light weight sodium filled valve with a one piece heavy valve going to wear over time. That could be even worse then the stock valves over time. I am not sure what the answer is, but if it makes you feel better... spend the money for the peice of mind. But IMO if you are seriously worried about it... maybe it is time for a different car!!!