Kzoo, I don't recall hearing any significant negatives about these tires here on the forum (I recall one person thought they were noisy...) Based on similar criteria and needs to those you've stated, I put a set of Z06 sized Proxes (mounted on Z06 wheels) on my '01 coupe earlier this summer. I have maybe 1000+ miles on them and have no complaints. They are comfortable and quiet and seem to handle well, although I have not pushed them REALLY hard, nor have I driven them much in the rain. I got them through
www.Treadepot.com, which provided a competitive price and EXCELLENT service and packing. I think I tried Online tires and got no response to a phone call message I left with them - I wondered if that operation is just working out of someone's spare bedroom- and so decided to go with a real business. Good luck.