Emails with Tony Mamo at AFR
#101
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
It looks like the clean portion is on top. But remember this pump has been on there for a while. When I first got the car the antifreeze looked like vomit. I've only had the current antifreeze in there since like February or March, so I don't think that the corrosion happened recently. And I think the pump was replaced before, but not recently.
#104
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
#105
Drifting
The water will look clean. But if you actually filter it, you will see the true story. The sludge MAY be lodged in the bottom of the water jackets, where a few flushes will not dislodge it. It is reducing the coolant capacity and flow around the cylinders. Rule it out by checking. Pull the knock sensor. Water should come out.
Last edited by powerpigz-51; 04-24-2014 at 04:18 PM.
#106
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
The water will look clean. But if you actually filter it, you will see the true story. The sludge MAY be lodged in the bottom of the water jackets, where a few flushes will not dislodge it. It is reducing the coolant capacity and flow around the cylinders. Rule it out by checking. Pull the knock sensor. Water should come out.
#107
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Sep 2008
Location: Cherokee National Forest TN
Posts: 2,376
Likes: 0
Received 102 Likes
on
92 Posts
Hose water flow test indicates the intake gaskets are installed properly.
@ 4K rpm your sheet metal vane pump impeller is in cavitation mode + IIRC the pump is overdriven. Measure crank pulley diameter & water pump pulley diameter & figure the drive ratio or post the sizes I'll figure the ratio for you. Track motor water pumps require a vane pump, a 30% reduction in pump vs ENGINE rpm + a 5/8 id restrictor in the stat housing. Moving the water through the system to fast = poor cooling.
You need a pump with a vane impeller like the pictured cavitation pump.
@ 4K rpm your sheet metal vane pump impeller is in cavitation mode + IIRC the pump is overdriven. Measure crank pulley diameter & water pump pulley diameter & figure the drive ratio or post the sizes I'll figure the ratio for you. Track motor water pumps require a vane pump, a 30% reduction in pump vs ENGINE rpm + a 5/8 id restrictor in the stat housing. Moving the water through the system to fast = poor cooling.
You need a pump with a vane impeller like the pictured cavitation pump.
#108
over 100 replies in this and still going, really?
Dont blame the heads, there's nothing wrong with them.
Why wont you test the coolant for exhaust gases, it takes you like 5 minutes to rule out your head gaskets.
If it's not your head gaskets, then change the new pump and lower hose.
My personal guess is that you have bad waterpump, probably one with slipping impeller.
And I would love to see video of it overheating, I just cant see why would anyone keep their revs over 4000
Dont blame the heads, there's nothing wrong with them.
Why wont you test the coolant for exhaust gases, it takes you like 5 minutes to rule out your head gaskets.
If it's not your head gaskets, then change the new pump and lower hose.
My personal guess is that you have bad waterpump, probably one with slipping impeller.
And I would love to see video of it overheating, I just cant see why would anyone keep their revs over 4000
#109
over 100 replies in this and still going, really?
Dont blame the heads, there's nothing wrong with them.
Why wont you test the coolant for exhaust gases, it takes you like 5 minutes to rule out your head gaskets.
If it's not your head gaskets, then change the new pump and lower hose.
My personal guess is that you have bad waterpump, probably one with slipping impeller.
And I would love to see video of it overheating, I just cant see why would anyone keep their revs over 4000
Dont blame the heads, there's nothing wrong with them.
Why wont you test the coolant for exhaust gases, it takes you like 5 minutes to rule out your head gaskets.
If it's not your head gaskets, then change the new pump and lower hose.
My personal guess is that you have bad waterpump, probably one with slipping impeller.
And I would love to see video of it overheating, I just cant see why would anyone keep their revs over 4000
#110
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
Totally.....Where are you located, I would bet we can find someone in your area that will love to check out this phantom motor for you. There have been many on this forum that have told you what to do, you have had really good advice from some really sharp individuals, advice that is free, wake up buddy ask for help.....Then take it when it is given...
#111
#112
Race Director
#113
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
New water pump is on, still doing the same thing. Here's a video for everyone asking if it's actually getting too hot. The answer is yes, my thermostat rated temperature is 180* and my fans come on at 210*, therefore it shouldn't travel too far passed 210*. Also, regardless of fan on temp, the same thing happens on the highway.
#114
Team Owner
Looks like the coolant temp never went beyond the low 220's (223?). Given what you are doing in the vid (high RPM with the car not moving), that is not bad at all.
Your car is not moving so the only airflow going thru the radiator is from the fan. I would think that driving the car at highway speeds would create more airflow than what the fan alone could provide.
In stock form, the electric fan may not even be running during typical highway cruising if the temperature range is within the ECM parameters for coolant temps such as below 228 degrees.
I have done track days with my '87 where ambient air temps were above 100 degrees and although I don't see speeds much over 125, engine RPM is just over 5000 and I have never seen coolant temps above 225. The engine is mildly modded; still has the stock heads, a GM ZZ3 cam, bored .030 over, some intake port matching and headers/true duals.
The 'stat is a Stant 180 degree and a 15psi Stant cap. I have removed the A/C condenser but I'm too lazy to pull the original radiator to clean all the crap out from between the tubes and fins. The W/P is original and the radiator hoses are about 9 years old.
Your car is not moving so the only airflow going thru the radiator is from the fan. I would think that driving the car at highway speeds would create more airflow than what the fan alone could provide.
In stock form, the electric fan may not even be running during typical highway cruising if the temperature range is within the ECM parameters for coolant temps such as below 228 degrees.
I have done track days with my '87 where ambient air temps were above 100 degrees and although I don't see speeds much over 125, engine RPM is just over 5000 and I have never seen coolant temps above 225. The engine is mildly modded; still has the stock heads, a GM ZZ3 cam, bored .030 over, some intake port matching and headers/true duals.
The 'stat is a Stant 180 degree and a 15psi Stant cap. I have removed the A/C condenser but I'm too lazy to pull the original radiator to clean all the crap out from between the tubes and fins. The W/P is original and the radiator hoses are about 9 years old.
#115
Race Director
Looks absolutely normal to me. Sitting in the garage at 4500 is not. But what happened to the coolant puking at 240? The thing never got over 223.
#116
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
#117
Team Owner
Pro Mechanic
As I said earlier, I'm not at all convinced that you even have a problem.
You should look at your oil temps when you're holding it at 4k+ RPM. What do you suppose cools the oil?
#118
Melting Slicks
First I have to say you have some ***** I ssat here waiting for that thing to blow apart. In all the yrs Iv had my car it has probleys seen 5500 once or twice. It seldom sees the rpms you were holing it at even driving. Quess Im old and have seen way to many times what rmps can do to a engine. Besides the rpms your temps seem right on. Couple things you have to think about you have a 180 stat there is no way in the world you are going to be close to that at the rpms you had it at with just that little cooling fan trying to bring it down. Did you notice about 15 sec or so after you let off the temps were droping the reason being was the cooleant was moving slower thru the system and the fan and the rad were more capible of brining the temps down. The question you need to answer is what does it do under normal driving conditions. my quess on the open rd you will see right around 180 to 185 or so intraffic In not totaly sure what you will see but a quess is going to be 220 or so. These are all in the normal range. You said something about pucking fluid out at 240 that wis well below the boiling point so if that happened a couple of things could have caused it 1 a bad cap because you should never see 16lbs of pressure under normal driving, A air poucket that cooleant hit all the sudden can cause that to happen (RARE) or you are building up pressure from somewhere. From what I have just seen I dont see a problem. take it out and drive it normaly for a couple of days see what happens. Remember stock fans do not come on intill 228 or that range so you are still in the safe range. Drive it see what happens that is what I would do
#119
Go drive the car my friend, and enjoy....
#120
Burning Brakes
Well, I can understand his concern though, he turns 3K RPM at 70MPH so if he needed to do say a constant 120MPH somewhere he would overheat quickly?
If you plan on doing more high speed cruising maybe you should change your ratio?
If you plan on doing more high speed cruising maybe you should change your ratio?