CorvetteForum - Chevrolet Corvette Forum Discussion

CorvetteForum - Chevrolet Corvette Forum Discussion (https://www.corvetteforum.com/forums/)
-   C7 General Discussion (https://www.corvetteforum.com/forums/c7-general-discussion-142/)
-   -   Car and Driver Test C7 vs 911 (https://www.corvetteforum.com/forums/c7-general-discussion/3350981-car-and-driver-test-c7-vs-911-a.html)

TTRotary 10-08-2013 02:35 PM


Originally Posted by Snorman (Post 1585122426)
A base 911 is ugly IMO.

Now that's funny, coming from a GT-R dude. :lol: Just sayin'. Gotta give them respect tho, so it's all good.

TTRotary 10-08-2013 02:43 PM


Originally Posted by jimb100 (Post 1585119994)
If the C7 goes around Laguna Seca 2 seconds faster than 911, what does that tell me about my drive from Tampa to Miami? I'll give you the answer: Nothing!

LOl, nothing indeed, because you picked the flattest, straightest road in the southeast. An 18-wheel Peterbilt would be the preferred vehicle for this trip because it can run over the alligators at least. If it is economy you like and throw safety to the winds, then I recommend a Prius.

But to answer your original question - what a Corvette does on a racetrack relative to other cars actually says a lot about the car: how balanced it is, how it makes the driver feel (confidence), how agile the vehicle is, and a ton of other things you probably don't care about but I do. That in turn will tell you how YOU will feel hustling it over an unfamilar twisty country road. If that is not your thing, then why purchase a sportscar in the first place?

335i 10-08-2013 03:02 PM


Originally Posted by TTRotary (Post 1585124202)
LOl, nothing indeed, because you picked the flattest, straightest road in the southeast. An 18-wheel Peterbilt would be the preferred vehicle for this trip because it can run over the alligators at least. If it is economy you like and throw safety to the winds, then I recommend a Prius.

But to answer your original question - what a Corvette does on a racetrack relative to other cars actually says a lot about the car: how balanced it is, how it makes the driver feel (confidence), how agile the vehicle is, and a ton of other things you probably don't care about but I do. That in turn will tell you how YOU will feel hustling it over an unfamilar twisty country road. If that is not your thing, then why purchase a sportscar in the first place?

:iagree: Excellent post

Snorman 10-08-2013 04:12 PM


Originally Posted by TTRotary (Post 1585124140)
Now that's funny, coming from a GT-R dude. :lol: Just sayin'. Gotta give them respect tho, so it's all good.

Perhaps to some, but it's certainly not "boring" and "bland" like a 911 Beetle. And from a performance standpoint, which is of relative importance to me when I'm spending ~$100k, the GT-R will dropkick the 911 into next week.
S.

450hp mike9 10-08-2013 04:15 PM


Originally Posted by 335i (Post 1585081433)
Anyone know if I'll be able to find this issue in stores yet? I normally just read their articles online, but I don't want to wait for this one :)

Yes it in the stores.

450hp mike9 10-08-2013 04:21 PM


Originally Posted by Michael A (Post 1585081600)
"Not everyone can drive a pre-stability-control 911 to its limit, and that is the whole point. The 911 wants to teach us something about ourselves every time we drive it. That's the "why.""

I never understand statements like this. So they want a car that is hard to drive at the limits? Masochism is still alive.

Michael

I had a Porsche 911SC back in the 80's and I loss it on a curve and went ass back into the weeds . I made the mistake of lifting off the gas. Very scary car on the curves if you come in too hot.

punky 10-08-2013 04:36 PM


Originally Posted by 450hp mike9 (Post 1585125068)
I had a Porsche 911SC back in the 80's and I loss it on a curve and went ass back into the weeds . I made the mistake of lifting off the gas. Very scary car on the curves if you come in too hot.

Not half as scary as a service appointment!

heavychevy 10-08-2013 04:58 PM


Originally Posted by drmustang (Post 1585122658)
True. This is going to be quite difficult for the Porsche defenders of the faith. Some of these diehards have been posting 10 or 20 times per day here for a year about the superiority of the Porsche nameplate.

This C7 is the Porsche boys worst dream come to life.

No, it most certainly is not. Porshe's doing record numbers in sales while increasing prices across the board. The 991 is selling better than the 997, which sold better than the 996 in spite of a depression mid life cycle.

All while the the Z06 beat up on 5 variations of GT3 and you had to spend 200k on a GT2RS to be mentioned in the same sentence as a ZR1. They couldn't keep one on the lot. In fact the 997's (RS) are worth MORE than new now. Especially the 4.0 which is selling for 300k, which sticker was 185k and markups 215k.

Porsche guys are Porsche guys and Porsche will make money regardless, lots of it. Hence their selling out and GTR'ing the new GT3. 90% probably more could care less if they get lapped by a Corvette at 1/2 the price they won't be switching.

Just stating the facts.


Oh, and the new GT3, as much as I can't stand it, will be pretty darn fast. 11.2 @ 126 per Car and Driver. Will set you back 150k though. But not bad for a 6 cylinder RWD car.

gofobroke 10-08-2013 05:05 PM


Originally Posted by 450hp mike9 (Post 1585125068)
I had a Porsche 911SC back in the 80's and I loss it on a curve and went ass back into the weeds . I made the mistake of lifting off the gas. Very scary car on the curves if you come in too hot.

As an SC owner (1980) and any Porsche driver can't disagree. But when I turn the nannies off my 2008 Z06 things can get very hairy too.

gthal 10-08-2013 05:22 PM


Originally Posted by jimb100 (Post 1585123665)
My point is this: If you can drive a C7 at 52% of its potential on the street and a 911 at 53% it doesn't matter. If I can drive a 458 at 49% of its potential and an Aston Martin at 56% of its potential, so what?

The potential of all these cars is so great they can only come close to realizing it at the track with a very experienced driver under racing conditions.

So all the talk about the minutia of performance at racing levels doesn't do much more than provide bragging rights for those who enjoy barroom discussion about things that don't really matter.

This forum revels in it, while practical information about actual handling, ergonomics and useable acceleration on the street isn't to be found. Likewise, quality gets little consideration while the nuances of "steering feel" between 911 and C7 gets dissected to a fine point. I agree, steering feel is important but my C6 is excellent and so is the 911. And the complaint about the C6 was that it is a handful at the limit. That limit is so far from what I'll ever experience on the street as to be no negative at all.

Numbers are great but if movie reviews only reported the number of killings, explosions and words of dialogue they wouldn't be of much use. It seems thats about all track tests do.

I get what you are saying. For me, the ultimate performance is an important part of the equation... not the only part but a very important part. I spend a lot of time at the track and how the car performs is meaningful to me. However, the ultra high level testing done does, IMO, indicate the cars ability at the limit but that also translates in many respects to its ability, confidence level and feel at 60% of its maximum performance levels.

If performance didn't matter, there are better cars than the Corvette to own IMO. A BMW 550i has a ton of power but is a more comfortable, practical luxury car. If performance didn't matter, I think many people would buy a car like that... otherwise, why buy a Corvette? I say that somewhat sarcastically because I do understand many people buy a Corvette just to putter around town in and have the odd more spirited drive and that's fine ... although you could do that just as well or better in a BMW 550i too :D I don't personally understand that side (if that's what I wanted to do I wouldn't buy a C7) but I do understand that's all some want.

Notch 10-08-2013 05:30 PM


Originally Posted by gthal (Post 1585122039)
Really? Not sure if you are serious with your comment or if you are just missing the point of a comparison test on a track.

I'm serious, and I haven't missed the point.


Originally Posted by gthal (Post 1585122039)
It isn't the actual "time" they recorded that matters... it is the time relative to the other car they also tested that matters.

Why? That relative time means absolutely nothing on public roads.

Notch 10-08-2013 05:40 PM


Originally Posted by heavychevy (Post 1585125395)

Oh, and the new GT3, as much as I can't stand it, will be pretty darn fast. 11.2 @ 126 per Car and Driver. Will set you back 150k though. But not bad for a 6 cylinder RWD car.

And 0-60 in 3.0 sec.

Notch 10-08-2013 05:43 PM


Originally Posted by B747VET (Post 1585123316)
There is simply no basis of logic in the above argument.

There is not one thing wrong with the logic.

MKDFW 10-08-2013 06:09 PM

2014 GT3 Test Results
 
1 Attachment(s)
New GT3.

DREAMERAK 10-08-2013 06:17 PM


Originally Posted by Notch (Post 1585125756)
And 0-60 in 3.0 sec.

That time means absolutely nothing on public roads.

sam90lx 10-08-2013 06:30 PM


Originally Posted by DREAMERAK (Post 1585126096)
That time means absolutely nothing on public roads.

:crazy2::crazy2:

Tony C7 10-08-2013 06:42 PM

Vette beat the 991 S around Willow....that's good enough for me.

gthal 10-08-2013 06:47 PM


Originally Posted by DREAMERAK (Post 1585126096)
That time means absolutely nothing on public roads.

:rofl: :cheers:

gthal 10-08-2013 06:47 PM


Originally Posted by sam90lx (Post 1585126222)
:crazy2::crazy2:

He's being sarcastic for Notch's benefit :D

gthal 10-08-2013 06:50 PM


Originally Posted by Notch (Post 1585125663)
I'm serious, and I haven't missed the point.

Why? That relative time means absolutely nothing on public roads.

Well why buy a C7, 911, GT-R or any high performance car? Better to get a BMW 5 series or MB E Class for public road use... better than either the 911 or Corvette for that purpose based on your reasoning.

It does mean something... yes, even on public roads... but let's not bother debating it. I bet $1,000 that your opinion would be different if the 911 was surpassing the C7 in performance tests... then it would matter :cheers:


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 03:55 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands