GS pulls to the left
#1
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
GS pulls to the left
I have had a problem with my 2010 GS AG pulling to the left for some time and can't figure it out. Looking for ideas. So far, we've tried:
1. new alignment - worked initially but one day on track and alignment was shot
2. rear sub-frame - while doing 2nd alignment, noticed rear sub-frame was loose and pointing to the left relative to the frame. Thought this was it, it wasn't. Lock-tited the bolts and even welded sub-frame to frame - no go even with anothor alignment
3. brakes - used infrared thermometer on the rotors to see if one was sticking. No appreciable difference left to right. If anything, right temps were slightly higher
Also, tires are new as well as sways and shocks (JOC Stage 1). Pulling occurred before and after tires + JOC.
Any ideas?
Thanks
1. new alignment - worked initially but one day on track and alignment was shot
2. rear sub-frame - while doing 2nd alignment, noticed rear sub-frame was loose and pointing to the left relative to the frame. Thought this was it, it wasn't. Lock-tited the bolts and even welded sub-frame to frame - no go even with anothor alignment
3. brakes - used infrared thermometer on the rotors to see if one was sticking. No appreciable difference left to right. If anything, right temps were slightly higher
Also, tires are new as well as sways and shocks (JOC Stage 1). Pulling occurred before and after tires + JOC.
Any ideas?
Thanks
Last edited by TKOGTO; 12-12-2012 at 01:25 PM.
#3
Tech Contributor
Member Since: Oct 1999
Location: Charlotte, NC (formerly Endicott, NY)
Posts: 40,078
Received 8,918 Likes
on
5,327 Posts
Caster can cause a pulling in one direction or the other since the steering will pull in the direction of the front wheel that has less positive caster.
Camber can cause pulling with the car pulling in the direction of the wheel with the most positive camber.
Since caster and camber are interrelated I usually find if I set my camber it is very hard to get exactly equal settings from side to side and the side with the most negative camber usually has less positive caster.
I wouldn't get too upset by small differences in the alignment from side to side. The alignment specs have wide tolerances and small differences from side to side are usually something that you need to live with as it can take hours to equalize them if it is even possible to make them equal. Some mechanics will adjust caster differently from one side to the other to compensate for the pulling you get when driving on a crowned road.
You could also have issues with tire pull, tire pressure, or brake drag.
Bill
#4
Race Director
Member Since: Oct 2000
Location: Deal's Gap 2004 NCM Motorsports track supporter
Posts: 13,913
Received 1,101 Likes
on
715 Posts
Pulling while floating throttle? accelerating? decelerating? Last time I had a problem was getting alignment on same equipment three times. Tried another shop and problem was fixed. Time before that was bad shock in one rear corner, under acceleration pulled to left.
#6
Race Director
I have had a problem with my 2010 GS AG pulling to the left for some time and can't figure it out. Looking for ideas. So far, we've tried:
1. new alignment - worked initially but one day on track and alignment was shot
Why was alignment shot after one track day?
2. rear sub-frame - while doing 2nd alignment, noticed rear sub-frame was loose and pointing to the left relative to the frame. Thought this was it, it wasn't. Lock-tited the bolts and even welded sub-frame to frame - no go even with anothor alignment
Same alignment shop?
Was any work ever done to the car that necessitated loosening of sub frame?
3. brakes - used infrared thermometer on the rotors to see if one was sticking. No appreciable difference left to right. If anything, right temps were slightly higher
Also, tires are new as well as sways and shocks (JOC Stage 1). Pulling occurred before and after tires + JOC.
Any ideas?
Thanks
1. new alignment - worked initially but one day on track and alignment was shot
Why was alignment shot after one track day?
2. rear sub-frame - while doing 2nd alignment, noticed rear sub-frame was loose and pointing to the left relative to the frame. Thought this was it, it wasn't. Lock-tited the bolts and even welded sub-frame to frame - no go even with anothor alignment
Same alignment shop?
Was any work ever done to the car that necessitated loosening of sub frame?
3. brakes - used infrared thermometer on the rotors to see if one was sticking. No appreciable difference left to right. If anything, right temps were slightly higher
Also, tires are new as well as sways and shocks (JOC Stage 1). Pulling occurred before and after tires + JOC.
Any ideas?
Thanks
I don't know any alignment shop or other shop that would weld a sub frame to the frame as a fix for anything, you may just need a new shop. Do they do race alignments on many vettes? Or any alignments on vettes?
Last edited by froggy47; 12-13-2012 at 12:10 AM.
#7
Race Director
I agree with all above...plus you can't weld the subframe to the frame!??
Anyway, unless there is damage or excessive wear, it is mostly likely a bad tire or bad castor. Swap/rotate tires and see if it changes. If that doesn't help, I'd make absolutely certainty that the castor is even side-to-side. If that doesn't help, you have a mechanical problem somewhere.....
Anyway, unless there is damage or excessive wear, it is mostly likely a bad tire or bad castor. Swap/rotate tires and see if it changes. If that doesn't help, I'd make absolutely certainty that the castor is even side-to-side. If that doesn't help, you have a mechanical problem somewhere.....
#8
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
. Is the car pulling or is it dog walking? Dog walking is an issue with improper thrust angle and usually means you have to have the steering wheel turned in a certain direction to to go straight. Although the wheel is turned it isn't pulling. You can center the steering wheel position by adjusting front toe and drive down the road without much pull even though the car is actually going down the road sideways. The rear sub frame on my Z is off to the left by about a tenth of an inch but it doesn't cause any pulling. A good alignment guy should be able to make rear toe adjustments that set the thrust angle close to zero and thus pretty much eliminate and tendency to dog walk.
...
You could also have issues with tire pull, tire pressure, or brake drag.
Bill
...
You could also have issues with tire pull, tire pressure, or brake drag.
Bill
I have had this condition on 3 different sets of tires with no difference so we have eliminated that so far.
#9
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Pulling while floating throttle? accelerating? decelerating? Last time I had a problem was getting alignment on same equipment three times. Tried another shop and problem was fixed. Time before that was bad shock in one rear corner, under acceleration pulled to left.
I notice it most when driving on the highway. I tend to lighten my grip, sometimes steering with 1 hand. It's @ these times it is very noticeable. I don't notice it at all accelerating or braking.
#10
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Condition is the same on 3 different sets of tires, one old, one ready for the scrap heap and the run flats I use after the track season is over. these last tires have < 3k miles on them. Thanks though.
#11
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Froggy
1. re: "alignment shot", by this I mean, the car started crabbing again. It was aligned to the Pfadt track use with street tires specs in April. Car felt perfect after this alignment. One day @ Lime Rock and it was crabbing again. Same thing happened @ the end of the season. Aligned, it's fine, one day @ LRP it's crabbing again. It was after this 2nd "failed" alignment, the shop welded an L bracket off the chassis rail to keep the sub-frame from moving. What I stated in the OP re: welding the frame to the sub-frame was not correct as noted above.
2. Yes, same alignment shop. My confidence level is high with the shop. I watched the last alignment so I know it was done to the Pfadt specs.
3. The tranny had work to fix a leaking seal in June but I don't know if that required loosening the sub-frame. Either way the problem existed before then and no other work was done on the rear.
1. re: "alignment shot", by this I mean, the car started crabbing again. It was aligned to the Pfadt track use with street tires specs in April. Car felt perfect after this alignment. One day @ Lime Rock and it was crabbing again. Same thing happened @ the end of the season. Aligned, it's fine, one day @ LRP it's crabbing again. It was after this 2nd "failed" alignment, the shop welded an L bracket off the chassis rail to keep the sub-frame from moving. What I stated in the OP re: welding the frame to the sub-frame was not correct as noted above.
2. Yes, same alignment shop. My confidence level is high with the shop. I watched the last alignment so I know it was done to the Pfadt specs.
3. The tranny had work to fix a leaking seal in June but I don't know if that required loosening the sub-frame. Either way the problem existed before then and no other work was done on the rear.
#12
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
I agree with all above...plus you can't weld the subframe to the frame!??
Anyway, unless there is damage or excessive wear, it is mostly likely a bad tire or bad castor. Swap/rotate tires and see if it changes. If that doesn't help, I'd make absolutely certainty that the castor is even side-to-side. If that doesn't help, you have a mechanical problem somewhere.....
Anyway, unless there is damage or excessive wear, it is mostly likely a bad tire or bad castor. Swap/rotate tires and see if it changes. If that doesn't help, I'd make absolutely certainty that the castor is even side-to-side. If that doesn't help, you have a mechanical problem somewhere.....
Same issue on 3 different sets of tires. I don't have the alignment spec sheet in front of me but I am sure the castor was very close to 8.5 degrees on both sides.
#16
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Camber kit was put in @ time JOC sways and shocks were added. I will hear back later today whether alignment changed again and if so how much. When I spoke to them before I brought it back, tech suggested it was a brake hanging up because he assumed the camber kit and L bracket should have kept alignment in place.
#17
Race Director
My guess is yes. I was watching them work on it when they discovered the loose bolts. Tech went back to the office to check the torque spec before tightening. I will however confirm this.
Camber kit was put in @ time JOC sways and shocks were added. I will hear back later today whether alignment changed again and if so how much. When I spoke to them before I brought it back, tech suggested it was a brake hanging up because he assumed the camber kit and L bracket should have kept alignment in place.
Camber kit was put in @ time JOC sways and shocks were added. I will hear back later today whether alignment changed again and if so how much. When I spoke to them before I brought it back, tech suggested it was a brake hanging up because he assumed the camber kit and L bracket should have kept alignment in place.
I'm running out of ideas.
Sub frame movement loosening is not something I have heard of happening much. My front sub frame was loosened to fix a front engine cover leak & we marked the before/after alignment & it does have locator pins which limit the adjustment/movement to a couple of mm I believe.
Tightened back up to a big torque spec (I forget) and it's never moved/loosened since (couple years).
Last edited by froggy47; 12-14-2012 at 01:46 PM.
#18
Racer
Had similar problem with rear suspension of CTSV.
First thing I would do is put a wrench on every bolt under the car. If you find one loose, replace the nut if it threads on by hand.
The rear lower control arm nut came loose after an alignment. Tech at local dealership put his kick azz Ingersol Rand gazillion ft lb impact gun on high and let it rattle. I had him take the nut off and replace with new. He tightened the lock right out of the locking nut. Tighten with torque wrench only!
Same thing with axle nuts, do not reuse if you can thread on by hand.
First thing I would do is put a wrench on every bolt under the car. If you find one loose, replace the nut if it threads on by hand.
The rear lower control arm nut came loose after an alignment. Tech at local dealership put his kick azz Ingersol Rand gazillion ft lb impact gun on high and let it rattle. I had him take the nut off and replace with new. He tightened the lock right out of the locking nut. Tighten with torque wrench only!
Same thing with axle nuts, do not reuse if you can thread on by hand.
#19
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
[QUOTE=froggy47;1582567927]Well if you already have camber kit/plates that's a whole new kettle of fish.
I'm running out of ideas.
:ack
Understood. Appreciate the effort.
I'm running out of ideas.
:ack
Understood. Appreciate the effort.
#20
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Had similar problem with rear suspension of CTSV.
First thing I would do is put a wrench on every bolt under the car. If you find one loose, replace the nut if it threads on by hand.
The rear lower control arm nut came loose after an alignment. Tech at local dealership put his kick azz Ingersol Rand gazillion ft lb impact gun on high and let it rattle. I had him take the nut off and replace with new. He tightened the lock right out of the locking nut. Tighten with torque wrench only!
Same thing with axle nuts, do not reuse if you can thread on by hand.
First thing I would do is put a wrench on every bolt under the car. If you find one loose, replace the nut if it threads on by hand.
The rear lower control arm nut came loose after an alignment. Tech at local dealership put his kick azz Ingersol Rand gazillion ft lb impact gun on high and let it rattle. I had him take the nut off and replace with new. He tightened the lock right out of the locking nut. Tighten with torque wrench only!
Same thing with axle nuts, do not reuse if you can thread on by hand.
I started marking everything I could easily get to a few months back so I could check periodically if anything loosened. I did not check that each was properly torqued to begin with. That was more trouble than I was willing to take on. I did check the front end after my last track day and nothing had moved. However I only did the rear about 2 weeks ago so I could have marked something that was not torqued to spec.
What is strange is the 1st 2 alignments corrected the issue only to have it return after 1 track day. The last alignment which included the L bracket I mentioned above did not improve the crabbing at all.