vibration question
#1
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Member Since: Jul 2004
Location: NJ
Posts: 24,652
Received 297 Likes
on
94 Posts
St. Jude Donor '05-'08
vibration question
So after VIR this year I got a vibration when I apply the brakes. I thought maybe a warpped rotor so I replaced pads and rotors. I went out again and still had the vibration, but I also now had vibration in turns. That turned out to be the hub so I replaced that. I also replaced the front pads thinking that the hub might have caused uneven pad wear.
So now the vibration in the turns is gone, but now on medium braking the vibration is still there. On hard braking I can get the vibration to be almost nothing. I really am running out of thoughts and wondered what you guys think. Maybe the rotor is warpped after the hub being bad? Maybe I need to buy 18inch wheels and go wtih 14in stoptech over my 13 inch Wilwood setup
I am just frustrated because the car at VIR had no problems until the last 2 laps and since then I cannot get rid of the vibration.
thanks
Bob
So now the vibration in the turns is gone, but now on medium braking the vibration is still there. On hard braking I can get the vibration to be almost nothing. I really am running out of thoughts and wondered what you guys think. Maybe the rotor is warpped after the hub being bad? Maybe I need to buy 18inch wheels and go wtih 14in stoptech over my 13 inch Wilwood setup
I am just frustrated because the car at VIR had no problems until the last 2 laps and since then I cannot get rid of the vibration.
thanks
Bob
#3
Team Owner
Member Since: Apr 2001
Location: Overwhelmed as one would be, placed in my position.... DFW, TX
Posts: 36,451
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
St. Jude Donor '05
So after VIR this year I got a vibration when I apply the brakes. I thought maybe a warpped rotor so I replaced pads and rotors. I went out again and still had the vibration, but I also now had vibration in turns. That turned out to be the hub so I replaced that. I also replaced the front pads thinking that the hub might have caused uneven pad wear.
So now the vibration in the turns is gone, but now on medium braking the vibration is still there. On hard braking I can get the vibration to be almost nothing. I really am running out of thoughts and wondered what you guys think. Maybe the rotor is warpped after the hub being bad? Maybe I need to buy 18inch wheels and go wtih 14in stoptech over my 13 inch Wilwood setup
I am just frustrated because the car at VIR had no problems until the last 2 laps and since then I cannot get rid of the vibration.
thanks
Bob
So now the vibration in the turns is gone, but now on medium braking the vibration is still there. On hard braking I can get the vibration to be almost nothing. I really am running out of thoughts and wondered what you guys think. Maybe the rotor is warpped after the hub being bad? Maybe I need to buy 18inch wheels and go wtih 14in stoptech over my 13 inch Wilwood setup
I am just frustrated because the car at VIR had no problems until the last 2 laps and since then I cannot get rid of the vibration.
thanks
Bob
#4
Race Director
usual suspects are play in tie rod ends, play in bearings, or LOOSE bearings.
Can you feel it in the steering (front vibration), or do you feel it in the entire car (possibly rear, or drivetrain). If you can link it to ANYTHING (ie right vs left, front vs rear, rpm dependent vs speed dependent) we can help find it.
Can you feel it in the steering (front vibration), or do you feel it in the entire car (possibly rear, or drivetrain). If you can link it to ANYTHING (ie right vs left, front vs rear, rpm dependent vs speed dependent) we can help find it.
#5
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Member Since: Jul 2004
Location: NJ
Posts: 24,652
Received 297 Likes
on
94 Posts
St. Jude Donor '05-'08
It is coming from the front and it feels more dominant on the left side.
I replaced both left and right side hubs, but did not replace the bearings or tie rod ends.
The reason I replaced the driver's side hub is because when I pulled on the tire when it was in the air I was getting movement (in and out). After I replaced the hub there was no movement.
I thought this was the problem and as I somewhat stated above after the replacement of the hub the car tracked fine under acceleration where before I was getting some vibration as the speeds increased.
So I was extremely happy that the acceleration vibration was gone, but then I when I hit the brakes the decel vibration was still there not making me a happy camper.
As I also noted the vibration is the worse when I am medium on the brakes. If I brake late and hard the vibration is almost not there. Maybe this is my cars way of saying use your brakes less
I probably should have swapped out the bearings when I did the hubs
I replaced both left and right side hubs, but did not replace the bearings or tie rod ends.
The reason I replaced the driver's side hub is because when I pulled on the tire when it was in the air I was getting movement (in and out). After I replaced the hub there was no movement.
I thought this was the problem and as I somewhat stated above after the replacement of the hub the car tracked fine under acceleration where before I was getting some vibration as the speeds increased.
So I was extremely happy that the acceleration vibration was gone, but then I when I hit the brakes the decel vibration was still there not making me a happy camper.
As I also noted the vibration is the worse when I am medium on the brakes. If I brake late and hard the vibration is almost not there. Maybe this is my cars way of saying use your brakes less
I probably should have swapped out the bearings when I did the hubs
#6
Team Owner
Member Since: Mar 2001
Location: Virginia Beach
Posts: 25,889
Likes: 0
Received 5 Likes
on
5 Posts
CI 3-5-6-7-8 Veteran
My last trip out at VIR I had some bad vibration when braking... I thought it was simply the pads/rotors being worn oddly.
David how do you actually check for tie rod and hub play? I have VB&P HD tie rod ends... I'd doubt those have worn out as they're all metal.
The front hubs are fresh from early '06 w/ 4 or 5 events on them... rear hubs were replaced this summer.
David how do you actually check for tie rod and hub play? I have VB&P HD tie rod ends... I'd doubt those have worn out as they're all metal.
The front hubs are fresh from early '06 w/ 4 or 5 events on them... rear hubs were replaced this summer.
#8
Melting Slicks
Bob
My check would be:
1-Tire spun on wheel (I mark mine, worst spin was approx 4 inch before my dry mounting)
2-Balance weight falling off (I mark mine, glue or tape them too but lost one once)
3-Make sure clean surface between wheel/rotor hat and rotor hat/hub.
4-Hub run-out (although my worst worn hub never created a vib)
5-Rotor run-out
You mentioned bearing replacement. What bearing?
My check would be:
1-Tire spun on wheel (I mark mine, worst spin was approx 4 inch before my dry mounting)
2-Balance weight falling off (I mark mine, glue or tape them too but lost one once)
3-Make sure clean surface between wheel/rotor hat and rotor hat/hub.
4-Hub run-out (although my worst worn hub never created a vib)
5-Rotor run-out
You mentioned bearing replacement. What bearing?
#10
Team Owner
It is coming from the front and it feels more dominant on the left side.
I replaced both left and right side hubs, but did not replace the bearings or tie rod ends.
The reason I replaced the driver's side hub is because when I pulled on the tire when it was in the air I was getting movement (in and out). After I replaced the hub there was no movement.
I thought this was the problem and as I somewhat stated above after the replacement of the hub the car tracked fine under acceleration where before I was getting some vibration as the speeds increased.
So I was extremely happy that the acceleration vibration was gone, but then I when I hit the brakes the decel vibration was still there not making me a happy camper.
As I also noted the vibration is the worse when I am medium on the brakes. If I brake late and hard the vibration is almost not there. Maybe this is my cars way of saying use your brakes less
I probably should have swapped out the bearings when I did the hubs
I replaced both left and right side hubs, but did not replace the bearings or tie rod ends.
The reason I replaced the driver's side hub is because when I pulled on the tire when it was in the air I was getting movement (in and out). After I replaced the hub there was no movement.
I thought this was the problem and as I somewhat stated above after the replacement of the hub the car tracked fine under acceleration where before I was getting some vibration as the speeds increased.
So I was extremely happy that the acceleration vibration was gone, but then I when I hit the brakes the decel vibration was still there not making me a happy camper.
As I also noted the vibration is the worse when I am medium on the brakes. If I brake late and hard the vibration is almost not there. Maybe this is my cars way of saying use your brakes less
I probably should have swapped out the bearings when I did the hubs
#12
Team Owner
#14
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Member Since: Jul 2004
Location: NJ
Posts: 24,652
Received 297 Likes
on
94 Posts
St. Jude Donor '05-'08
John when I took apart the hub I also had the ball joints apart (part of doing the work). They seemed to be ok. When I put them back together the fit was fine.
I think tie rod ends and 2 piece rotors is where I am going to look now.
#15
Instructor
So after VIR this year I got a vibration when I apply the brakes. I thought maybe a warpped rotor so I replaced pads and rotors. I went out again and still had the vibration, but I also now had vibration in turns. That turned out to be the hub so I replaced that. I also replaced the front pads thinking that the hub might have caused uneven pad wear.
So now the vibration in the turns is gone, but now on medium braking the vibration is still there. On hard braking I can get the vibration to be almost nothing. I really am running out of thoughts and wondered what you guys think. Maybe the rotor is warpped after the hub being bad? Maybe I need to buy 18inch wheels and go wtih 14in stoptech over my 13 inch Wilwood setup
I am just frustrated because the car at VIR had no problems until the last 2 laps and since then I cannot get rid of the vibration.
thanks
Bob
So now the vibration in the turns is gone, but now on medium braking the vibration is still there. On hard braking I can get the vibration to be almost nothing. I really am running out of thoughts and wondered what you guys think. Maybe the rotor is warpped after the hub being bad? Maybe I need to buy 18inch wheels and go wtih 14in stoptech over my 13 inch Wilwood setup
I am just frustrated because the car at VIR had no problems until the last 2 laps and since then I cannot get rid of the vibration.
thanks
Bob
I curious to see what your out come is on this.
Richy
#16
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Member Since: Jul 2004
Location: NJ
Posts: 24,652
Received 297 Likes
on
94 Posts
St. Jude Donor '05-'08
Bob, I having the a very familiar problem. It's driving me crazy I feel vibration from the left front when making right turns (not 90 degree, highway turns). I don't get the vibration when braking only when I put a load on the front left, usually around 40 mph and up.
I curious to see what your out come is on this.
Richy
I curious to see what your out come is on this.
Richy
well slowly I will pull every piece of suspension and brake part off until I find the cause. At open track day at WGI Friday I was getting close then I had a mechanical issue with the engine and that ended that.
#17
Team Owner
You could have two problems at once and solved one with the hub.
Last edited by John Shiels; 10-19-2007 at 05:34 PM.
#18
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Member Since: Jul 2004
Location: NJ
Posts: 24,652
Received 297 Likes
on
94 Posts
St. Jude Donor '05-'08
tie rod end should be able to spot easy if it was bad. Can't see it making vibration if was not real bad. Swap tires and rims to see if it made a difference? What happen with motor? I am going Monday for open track wonder if I will survive after not running all year
You could have two problems at once and solved one with the hub.
You could have two problems at once and solved one with the hub.
Hub was a good find so I am wondering if that caliper is screwed because of the bad hub.
what happened?? 50+ 1/4 mile passes and 3+ years of road racing happened
#20
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Member Since: Jul 2004
Location: NJ
Posts: 24,652
Received 297 Likes
on
94 Posts
St. Jude Donor '05-'08
I had it on the trailer and saw fluid on the driver side and though it was a rod, but the fluid turned out to be power steering fluid because the rack and pump went. The only cooler the car didnt have was one for the power steering
Anyway I dropped it off at the shop Tuesday and really we just took a quick look at it. No holes or anything else dripping. I figured I had a 402 built for me last year because I thought the engine would not last another year so this would be a good time to put it in and to make other changes.
WGI was my last track day of this season. I got in 17 track days this year.