V8 vs V4 - any long term impact to cylinder health?
#1
V8 vs V4 - any long term impact to cylinder health?
I'm not a mechanic - so I assume GM experts did their homework and this is surely a non-long term issue. Hopefully the climate control folks did not get their way to 'this is how it must be done'. But any thoughts on impact to cylinder degrading differently if v4 is used around 50% of the time? I assume anyone doing a long trip would be running on V4, and also going around town at speed limits. Just wondering. I did see the note from GM about this as non-issue but wondering what the experts in this forum can share as well. I fully understand that one can run 100% of the time in Track mode and V8, but this is not the question. I assume a lot of folks would not drive in track mode 100% of the time. Cheers.
#2
Administrator
Member Since: Mar 2001
Location: In a parallel universe. Currently own 2014 Stingray Coupe.
Posts: 343,893
Received 19,561 Likes
on
14,116 Posts
C7 of the Year - Modified Finalist 2021
MO Events Coordinator
St. Jude Co-Organizer
St. Jude Donor '03-'04-'05-'06-'07-'08-'09-'10-'11-'12-'13-'14-'15-'16-'17-'18-'19-
'20-'21-'22-'23-'24
NCM Sinkhole Donor
CI 5, 8 & 11 Veteran
That is a good question. I would hope that the engineers that designed the AFM system took that into account, but I may never know as I installed a Range AFM Eliminator to keep the car from going into 4-cylinder mode.
#3
Le Mans Master
There isn't any evidence that LT engines have long term detrimental effects from AFM.
The cylinders that are shut down due to AFM have pressurized exhaust in them (the exhaust valve doesn't open trapping the exhaust from the ignition in it). So the cylinders are seeing operating conditions similar to what they would normally see.
AFM is only active during lightly loaded conditions. A small application of throttle deactivates AFM. On a long trip the AFM is only active for 10 minutes straight and then returns to normal operation for 1 minute (or a cycle something like that).
The cylinders that are shut down due to AFM have pressurized exhaust in them (the exhaust valve doesn't open trapping the exhaust from the ignition in it). So the cylinders are seeing operating conditions similar to what they would normally see.
AFM is only active during lightly loaded conditions. A small application of throttle deactivates AFM. On a long trip the AFM is only active for 10 minutes straight and then returns to normal operation for 1 minute (or a cycle something like that).
The following users liked this post:
Andybump (10-23-2022)
#4
There are multiple threads about this. Here's a current one:
https://www.corvetteforum.com/forums...sue-on-c8.html
Some people are convinced AFM is the devil incarnate, and your engine is bound to self destruct if you let it operate. They tend to blame any engine failure on AFM, in the total absence of any evidence supporting that. There WERE some reliability issues in the first generation of this technology, and the same people will point to failures from 20 years ago as proof the system is flawed.
GM uses this system in small block V8s across their entire line. There are literally millions of engines in use with this technology, and billions of miles on those engines. If there were major problems with it, there would be dozens of class action lawsuits, and GM car forums would have so many complaints about it there wouldn't be room to post anything else. GM sold more than 150,000 C7s with this system, and engine failures of ANY sort are rare.
https://www.corvetteforum.com/forums...sue-on-c8.html
Some people are convinced AFM is the devil incarnate, and your engine is bound to self destruct if you let it operate. They tend to blame any engine failure on AFM, in the total absence of any evidence supporting that. There WERE some reliability issues in the first generation of this technology, and the same people will point to failures from 20 years ago as proof the system is flawed.
GM uses this system in small block V8s across their entire line. There are literally millions of engines in use with this technology, and billions of miles on those engines. If there were major problems with it, there would be dozens of class action lawsuits, and GM car forums would have so many complaints about it there wouldn't be room to post anything else. GM sold more than 150,000 C7s with this system, and engine failures of ANY sort are rare.
Last edited by Red Mist Rulz; 10-23-2022 at 12:21 PM.
The following 3 users liked this post by Red Mist Rulz:
#5
If you installed the range device in a C8 it doesn't nothing at all.
#6
The Service Manual lists several conditions that inhibit V4 mode. Among them are time limits. It looks like after a period of time in V4, it transitions to V8 mode. And, once there, it looks like it must spend a minimum time in V8 mode before it can return to V4 mode. So, it really does not spend a long, uninterrupted period in V4 mode. I did not see what those times - although I think I have seen them.
As for the reason - its not stated. But it may have something to do heat. The deactivated cylinders are not firing, so the they probably tend to cool more than the ones that are firing. Switching back to V8 mode would reduce that effect.
Found the times- 10 minutes V4 mode, 1 minute V8 mode.
As for the reason - its not stated. But it may have something to do heat. The deactivated cylinders are not firing, so the they probably tend to cool more than the ones that are firing. Switching back to V8 mode would reduce that effect.
Found the times- 10 minutes V4 mode, 1 minute V8 mode.
Last edited by Andybump; 10-23-2022 at 12:23 PM.
#7
Administrator
Member Since: Jun 2007
Location: Bel Air (by way of Fort Worth, TX) Maryland
Posts: 64,924
Received 1,665 Likes
on
850 Posts
St. Jude Donor '12-'13-'14-'15-'16-'17-'18-'19-'20-'21
I have a 2009 Avalanche with AFM. Never had a problem. Ever.
Had 2016 and 2019 C7s with AFM. No issues related or relatable to AFM with either.
Member posts that are critical of AFM usually fall into at least one if not both of the categories listed below:
1. They are incredulous that a V8-powered vehicle should operate as a V4 under any circumstances.
2. The spotlight fallacy that any car with AFM is a ticking time bomb ready to grenade the engine.
Had 2016 and 2019 C7s with AFM. No issues related or relatable to AFM with either.
Member posts that are critical of AFM usually fall into at least one if not both of the categories listed below:
1. They are incredulous that a V8-powered vehicle should operate as a V4 under any circumstances.
2. The spotlight fallacy that any car with AFM is a ticking time bomb ready to grenade the engine.
The following users liked this post:
Fast Dawg (10-24-2022)
#9
Here are the times - 10 minutes V4 mode, 1 minute V8 mode.
The following users liked this post:
C8OnOrder (10-23-2022)
#10
#12
Life Time NCM #2196
I was an unlucky guy with 2015 Silverado that had a lifter issue, GM fixed under warranty and I used the range technology device after that. My 2022 Denali has that chip deleted so always in V8 mode, also how I drive my C8.
#13
But a bad lifter on a car equipped with AFM? Must be because of AFM, right?
#15
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Sep 2017
Location: Rural NW Georgia. GO DAWGS!
Posts: 5,146
Received 2,555 Likes
on
1,626 Posts
There was a class action lawsuit that got filed by C7 owners on this feature. It got thrown out of court because the plaintiffs could not prove their case or refute GM’s answers to their interrogatories. That tells me everything that I need to know about it - it’s not an issue.
The following users liked this post:
Foosh (10-24-2022)
#16
Race Director
If I remember correctly, on the C7 the AFM didn't get along with the 8 speed automatic, introduced in 2015 model year. It was a transmission issue more than an AFM issue. I never heard of issues with the AFM and the 6 speed automatic (2014 only) or the 7 speed manual.
Anyone remember this?
Anyone remember this?
#17
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Sep 2017
Location: Rural NW Georgia. GO DAWGS!
Posts: 5,146
Received 2,555 Likes
on
1,626 Posts
If I remember correctly, on the C7 the AFM didn't get along with the 8 speed automatic, introduced in 2015 model year. It was a transmission issue more than an AFM issue. I never heard of issues with the AFM and the 6 speed automatic (2014 only) or the 7 speed manual.
Anyone remember this?
Anyone remember this?
#18
Race Director
^^^
I'll research it. There was something weird about the torque converter and the AFM interface (on the 8 speed auto) if memory serves.
FWIW, I don't know the answer to the OP's question, but I do know that the AFM operation on the C8 (I have a 2021 HTC) is totally invisible. The only way I know it's gone to V4 (or back to V8) is the light on the dash. I can't feel it or hear it when it cycles. On my C7 (2014 convertible with 7 speed MANUAL), AFM would engage only when you were in "Eco" mode. I tried it once on a trip (in Eco mode) and I could feel a slight shudder when it went to V4 (or back to V8).
I'll research it. There was something weird about the torque converter and the AFM interface (on the 8 speed auto) if memory serves.
FWIW, I don't know the answer to the OP's question, but I do know that the AFM operation on the C8 (I have a 2021 HTC) is totally invisible. The only way I know it's gone to V4 (or back to V8) is the light on the dash. I can't feel it or hear it when it cycles. On my C7 (2014 convertible with 7 speed MANUAL), AFM would engage only when you were in "Eco" mode. I tried it once on a trip (in Eco mode) and I could feel a slight shudder when it went to V4 (or back to V8).
The following users liked this post:
Fast Dawg (10-25-2022)
#19
^^^
I'll research it. There was something weird about the torque converter and the AFM interface (on the 8 speed auto) if memory serves.
FWIW, I don't know the answer to the OP's question, but I do know that the AFM operation on the C8 (I have a 2021 HTC) is totally invisible. The only way I know it's gone to V4 (or back to V8) is the light on the dash. I can't feel it or hear it when it cycles. On my C7 (2014 convertible with 7 speed MANUAL), AFM would engage only when you were in "Eco" mode. I tried it once on a trip (in Eco mode) and I could feel a slight shudder when it went to V4 (or back to V8).
I'll research it. There was something weird about the torque converter and the AFM interface (on the 8 speed auto) if memory serves.
FWIW, I don't know the answer to the OP's question, but I do know that the AFM operation on the C8 (I have a 2021 HTC) is totally invisible. The only way I know it's gone to V4 (or back to V8) is the light on the dash. I can't feel it or hear it when it cycles. On my C7 (2014 convertible with 7 speed MANUAL), AFM would engage only when you were in "Eco" mode. I tried it once on a trip (in Eco mode) and I could feel a slight shudder when it went to V4 (or back to V8).
#20
Thanks all for feedback. No complaints about the system itself - as mentioned above it is virtually transparent. At 35MPH when driving around town, or at 70MHP at highway I don't mind sipping on gas. I know some folks see a major difference and prefer to be on V8 all the time - and this is not an issue - just preference. The car is awesome in every other way. I sent it to the beauty shop this week - getting PPF and ceramic coating. They had a blue Callaway on the shop with carbon accents - so cool.