Adding Air to Nitrogen filled tires
#21
Race Director
Member Since: Aug 2019
Location: Central Illinois
Posts: 10,079
Received 11,610 Likes
on
4,640 Posts
Please Ray, you're making assumptions on knowledge, I too have worked on cars for over 45 years. So show me ONE tire that has oxidized belts from air, just one. For all your experience you thought the TR9080 C8 DCT has a dry clutch, then you said the LT2 has a 5,600 rpm redline. You're not shining real bright on here so far.
#22
Drifting
Sheesh... urban legend... tires decade from UV, and just plain age... if you drive a car on 10 YO tires, you can put gold dust into them... good luck... Professional racers do use Nitrogen, because 1/2 LB of pressure can impact handling, but to go to BJs... or sit in 5 hours of traffic on the LIE... I doubt it will make a difference...
In theory nitrogen filled tires do not gain as much pressure. For a street car, I really don't see any benefit. On a hot day, tires do get hot on the highway, and may increase 3 or 4 psi. With nitrogen, it may be less, only 2 or 3.
You would not be able to detect that when driving.
The following 2 users liked this post by C5racecar:
JRYELLOWCORVETTE (12-27-2021),
Phil1098 (12-24-2021)
#23
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Jul 2000
Location: North Dallas 40 TX
Posts: 6,468
Received 4,383 Likes
on
2,070 Posts
Please Ray, you're making assumptions on knowledge, I too have worked on cars for over 45 years. So show me ONE tire that has oxidized belts from air, just one. For all your experience you thought the TR9080 C8 DCT has a dry clutch, then you said the LT2 has a 5,600 rpm redline. You're not shining real bright on here so far.
it was many years ago.
The following users liked this post:
Phil1098 (12-25-2021)
#24
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Dec 2004
Location: AZ
Posts: 5,754
Received 536 Likes
on
279 Posts
St. Jude Donor '06-'08-'10-'11-'12-'13 '14-'15-'16-'17-'18-'19
In a road racing car, you go onto the track with 25 psi, and after 20 minutes of racing, the tires are at 30 psi due to the extreme heat. The tires get hot from spinning and sliding sideways, and the heat from brakes puts a lot of heat into the tires and wheels.
In theory nitrogen filled tires do not gain as much pressure. For a street car, I really don't see any benefit. On a hot day, tires do get hot on the highway, and may increase 3 or 4 psi. With nitrogen, it may be less, only 2 or 3.
You would not be able to detect that when driving.
In theory nitrogen filled tires do not gain as much pressure. For a street car, I really don't see any benefit. On a hot day, tires do get hot on the highway, and may increase 3 or 4 psi. With nitrogen, it may be less, only 2 or 3.
You would not be able to detect that when driving.
The following 6 users liked this post by ByByBMW:
Edwardz (12-26-2021),
Grey (12-25-2021),
Racer86 (12-25-2021),
Red Mist Rulz (12-27-2021),
rjsmith169 (12-25-2021),
and 1 others liked this post.
The following users liked this post:
JRYELLOWCORVETTE (12-27-2021)
The following 3 users liked this post by RxCritical:
#30
I only fill my tires with non-binary vegan farts. So all of you guys are behind the curve here...
The following users liked this post:
speedlink (12-27-2021)
#31
It will not do any harm to add air to a nitrogen filled tire, other than to negate the alleged advantages of the Nitrogen fill. As for those advantages, here is a consumer reports article about that.
I believe it covers most (but not all) of the touted advantages of a Nitro fill. Missing is whether or not there is better pressure stability with temperature changes, and the impact of moisture content on that relationship. Here is an another article about that, that seem credible.
The consumer reports article concludes that the Nitrogen fill is not worth it, but the context of the consumer report article is street use and it does not discuss tire pressure stability with temperature:
https://www.consumerreports.org/tire...s-a6260003694/
That context of discussion at the following link is for racing and track events, and it concludes that a dry fill, whether Air, or Nitrogen, will provide the main advantage of tire pressure stability with temperature change. And, adding regular air to a dry fill, whether its Nitrogen or dried air, would negate the advantage for track use.
https://www.longacreracing.com/techn...ot%20too%20bad.
I believe it covers most (but not all) of the touted advantages of a Nitro fill. Missing is whether or not there is better pressure stability with temperature changes, and the impact of moisture content on that relationship. Here is an another article about that, that seem credible.
The consumer reports article concludes that the Nitrogen fill is not worth it, but the context of the consumer report article is street use and it does not discuss tire pressure stability with temperature:
https://www.consumerreports.org/tire...s-a6260003694/
That context of discussion at the following link is for racing and track events, and it concludes that a dry fill, whether Air, or Nitrogen, will provide the main advantage of tire pressure stability with temperature change. And, adding regular air to a dry fill, whether its Nitrogen or dried air, would negate the advantage for track use.
https://www.longacreracing.com/techn...ot%20too%20bad.
Last edited by Andybump; 12-27-2021 at 02:50 PM. Reason: added a note that adding air to a dry fill would negate the advantage for track use.
#33
The oxidation on the inside attacks the steel belts from the inside. And they do get the tire to 99% after five purges per tire, and they do that with a dozen tires when the Michelin crew isn't there. The Michelin crew fills new tires they mount on a team's wheels with nitrogen.
Ray
Ray
And even 1% oxygen will cause oxidation inside the tire. One molecule of oxygen can start oxidation, and once it starts it's self sustaining. The race team doesn't use nitrogen to prevent oxidation. That's a non issue when the tires don't even last one full race. Just like street tires, they wear out long before oxidation is a problem. If you're tires have been on the car long enough that oxygen has weakened the steel belts, the tread is as hard as a hockey puck anyway.
#34
This reads like a bunch of regurgitators with no real world experience. Not a scam for factory fill. Personal Mercedes went 3years from factory delivery before tpms light reminded us to fill, and with temps from 10*-100* + F. Also, those original TPMS’ are working at 12yrs, go figure.
After initial fill lifespan, air conversion for every car due to availability.
My understanding is that factory inflators have a vac down and fill port on the same machine, resulting in the highest possible nitrogen level.
After initial fill lifespan, air conversion for every car due to availability.
My understanding is that factory inflators have a vac down and fill port on the same machine, resulting in the highest possible nitrogen level.
#35
In a road racing car, you go onto the track with 25 psi, and after 20 minutes of racing, the tires are at 30 psi due to the extreme heat. The tires get hot from spinning and sliding sideways, and the heat from brakes puts a lot of heat into the tires and wheels.
In theory nitrogen filled tires do not gain as much pressure. For a street car, I really don't see any benefit. On a hot day, tires do get hot on the highway, and may increase 3 or 4 psi. With nitrogen, it may be less, only 2 or 3.
You would not be able to detect that when driving.
In theory nitrogen filled tires do not gain as much pressure. For a street car, I really don't see any benefit. On a hot day, tires do get hot on the highway, and may increase 3 or 4 psi. With nitrogen, it may be less, only 2 or 3.
You would not be able to detect that when driving.
#36
Advanced
My first boss out of engineering school once told me about his first invention, the Mary Jo Kopechne life saving system. It was a hose attached to the spare tire that extends into the car's interior, allowing an occupant to breathe air from the spare tire if the car should accidentally venture under water. He said only after he applied for the patent did he learn that there is no oxygen left in a spare tire after a few months, since the oxygen molecules are able to penetrate the rubber, but the nitrogen is not.
The following users liked this post:
Bird67 (12-28-2021)
#37
Le Mans Master
My daily driver SUV came from the dealer with Nitrogen filled tires and green caps. I drove the car for more than three years and 20,000 miles in the North East before the tires needed more air, which I thought was pretty good. I topped them off with regular air from my home compressor.
#38
E-Ray, 3LZ, ZER, LIFT
Member Since: Sep 2007
Location: NE South Carolina
Posts: 29,580
Received 9,648 Likes
on
6,647 Posts
The oxidation on the inside attacks the steel belts from the inside. And they do get the tire to 99% after five purges per tire, and they do that with a dozen tires when the Michelin crew isn't there. The Michelin crew fills new tires they mount on a team's wheels with nitrogen.
Ray
Ray
That oxidation issue "is a factor to some degree" IF you have a truck fleet and recap tires where the casing can last 300,000+ miles! Silly for cars. I was Director of Market Development for the largest Industrial gas company. My groups focus was, by far, our most profitable product, Argon. Although only 0.9% of the air we had over 50% of the US capacitary and controller prices. Welding was the largest use (it's also used to fill double pane widows etc.) My counterpart, with a 35 person group, was Director of Market Development for the other two gases Oxygen and Nitrogen. Have to liquify all air to get all 3. Our biggest market was Oxygen for steel mills etc. We built huge plants to deliver Oxygen to steel mills (when we had steel mills making steel not just melting old cars!) All large plants had the extra distillation trays and two more columns, and chemical reactors to get Argon (about 20% more costly when building a ~100 million dollar gas plant.)
We had excess liquid Nitrogen and would vent it (what a waste of the massive energy needed to compress and liquify air.) Recall when my counterpart deviled the marketing program to replace air compressors in large manufacturing plants. Filling tires was another Marketing effort BUT they focused on large truck fleets where there was some technical benefit. Cars have very little!
Yep sponsored Richard Petty's Race Team for >15 years. they used Nitrogen at the track because a 2500 psi cylinder (with regulator) was easier to carry than an quality air compressor with dryer required to deliver low moisture air for tires! Many race teams use it for that reason!
#39
Le Mans Master
My first boss out of engineering school once told me about his first invention, the Mary Jo Kopechne life saving system. It was a hose attached to the spare tire that extends into the car's interior, allowing an occupant to breathe air from the spare tire if the car should accidentally venture under water. He said only after he applied for the patent did he learn that there is no oxygen left in a spare tire after a few months, since the oxygen molecules are able to penetrate the rubber, but the nitrogen is not.
#40
Le Mans Master
We had excess liquid Nitrogen and would vent it (what a waste of the massive energy needed to compress and liquify air.) Recall when my counterpart deviled the marketing program to replace air compressors in large manufacturing plants. Filling tires was another Marketing effort BUT they focused on large truck fleets where there was some technical benefit. Cars have very little!
Yep sponsored Richard Petty's Race Team for >15 years. they used Nitrogen at the track because a 2500 psi cylinder (with regulator) was easier to carry than an quality air compressor with dryer required to deliver low moisture air for tires! Many race teams use it for that reason!
Yep sponsored Richard Petty's Race Team for >15 years. they used Nitrogen at the track because a 2500 psi cylinder (with regulator) was easier to carry than an quality air compressor with dryer required to deliver low moisture air for tires! Many race teams use it for that reason!
The following users liked this post:
Inviktus (12-27-2021)