Tire question on a C7
#21
Please bare with me all, can some tell me if you can put the z51 rims on a 2Lt. I asked the question to my salesman and he said GM said you couldn't, but they didn't give him an explanation.
#23
#24
Instructor
Member Since: Dec 2013
Location: Austin TX
Posts: 112
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
isn't 2lt an interior option? Regardless, z51 rims bolt directly to non-z51 cars without a problem.
#25
OK. My GM dealer fills all tires with nitrogen, not just Corvette tires. The justification in the literature for the nitrogen tire filler is that nitrogen gas has a larger molecule than the oxygen molecule that composes 20% of air. The rest of air is about 80% nitrogen plus other trace molecules. This is all true. You should have learned this in your high school chemistry and physics classes.
The larger molecule of nitrogen is supposed to be much less likely than the smaller oxygen molecule to leak through the rubber of the tires. My experience does not bear this out. When filled with nitrogen, my tire appear to lose pressure faster than they do when filled with air. For this, I have neither an explanation nor even a hypothesis.
Even if there is an unaccounted mechanism that is facilitating the leaking of nitrogen, it still has theoretical advantages over compressed air. Nitrogen gas has a lower effective molecular weight than air--28 grams (N2) vs. 28.8 grams (air). Thus nitrogen-filled tires have a slight unsprung weight advantage over air-filled tires.
Another of the advertised advantages of nitrogen over air is that nitrogen gas is naturally dry. Compressed air is measurably humid. If you don't need water, then you don't want water. Another tiny advantage of nitrogen gas.
Compressed air is 20% oxygen. Oxygen oxidizes the rubber and other carbon compounds in the interior of your tires. This a very slight effect, but it has no upside. Nitrogen gas is effectively oxygen-free and, thus, cannot oxidize anything. Nitrogen is not chemically inert, but nitrogen gas is effectively inert for most practical purposes. It does not react.
The bottomline is that you should follow your Operators Manual. The Manual is mute on your tire fill gas. For racing, nitrogen has definite advantages. Otherwise, accept nitrogen if it is offered. If it is not offered, then don't worry about it.
The larger molecule of nitrogen is supposed to be much less likely than the smaller oxygen molecule to leak through the rubber of the tires. My experience does not bear this out. When filled with nitrogen, my tire appear to lose pressure faster than they do when filled with air. For this, I have neither an explanation nor even a hypothesis.
Even if there is an unaccounted mechanism that is facilitating the leaking of nitrogen, it still has theoretical advantages over compressed air. Nitrogen gas has a lower effective molecular weight than air--28 grams (N2) vs. 28.8 grams (air). Thus nitrogen-filled tires have a slight unsprung weight advantage over air-filled tires.
Another of the advertised advantages of nitrogen over air is that nitrogen gas is naturally dry. Compressed air is measurably humid. If you don't need water, then you don't want water. Another tiny advantage of nitrogen gas.
Compressed air is 20% oxygen. Oxygen oxidizes the rubber and other carbon compounds in the interior of your tires. This a very slight effect, but it has no upside. Nitrogen gas is effectively oxygen-free and, thus, cannot oxidize anything. Nitrogen is not chemically inert, but nitrogen gas is effectively inert for most practical purposes. It does not react.
The bottomline is that you should follow your Operators Manual. The Manual is mute on your tire fill gas. For racing, nitrogen has definite advantages. Otherwise, accept nitrogen if it is offered. If it is not offered, then don't worry about it.
#26
Advanced
Boyle's Law
Sorry…but correct info is important.
PS: My new Z51 C7 has green caps for whatever that's worth.
#27
#28
Instructor
Member Since: Apr 2006
Location: National City California
Posts: 150
Likes: 0
Received 12 Likes
on
8 Posts
Nitrogen
Nitrogen does NOT expand and contract, It is also used in automatic altitude compensators to adjust the fuel air mixtures in aircraft carbs. The reason this works is the air is thinner at altitude and changes the position of the needle valve in the AATC.. Trust me Nitrogen done NOT expand and contract.. I am a retired Master Chief Aircraft Mechanic, I worked on these engines for 20 years and know how they work.
My LMR C-7 just made 844 RWHP today, can't wait to get my hande on this beast......
My LMR C-7 just made 844 RWHP today, can't wait to get my hande on this beast......
Nitrogen expands and contracts
every other gas according to the universal gas law:
PV=nRT
If T goes up, then so does either P or V or the combination of P & V. In a tire, since the volume can't change much, it is the pressure P that goes up. The only difference with pure nitrogen vs non-dried air is that there can be a small moisture content in air with air droplets at cold temps that might vaporize at high temps and thus very slightly increase the total tire pressure of moist air vs nitrogen filled tires. Basically its all a massive marketing scam, promoted by the industry that sells nitrogen tire filling machines.
Now if you are flying a Boeing or other aircraft, things are different:
http://www.boeing.com/commercial/aer...m03/index.html
"In addition, Boeing has received reports of three confirmed cases and other suspected cases in which a wheel/tire assembly exploded when the oxygen in air-filled tires combined with volatile gases given off by a severely overheated tire. In one case, the tire became overheated as a result of a dragging brake, and the wheel/tire assembly exploded when it reached the auto-ignition temperature. In another case, a wheel/tire assembly explosion in the wheel well during flight was suspected in the catastrophic loss of one airplane. A similar explosion caused severe damage to two others.
As a result, the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration issued Airworthiness Directive 87-08-09 requiring that only nitrogen be used to inflate airplane tires on braked wheels. However, tires may be topped off with air in remote locations where nitrogen may not be available if the oxygen content in the tire does not exceed 5 percent by volume."
Per the FAA directive:
http://www.airweb.faa.gov/Regulatory...light=87-08-09
People just figured they could make some cash adapting an aviation requirement for preventing a couple incidents caused by very high overtemperature condition occurring during high speed brake failure/overheating causing combustion for tires infalted cold to pressures in the range of 200 psi.
And to really get the air out, you first have to fully purge the tire by sucking the air out, and then filling it with actually dried nitrogen, from a high pressure bottle. At a race event, it is required to carry nitrogen bottles for things like air guns, and thus obviate the need for a compressor, and then you can also use the nitogen to fill tires, having a very slightly better control of pressure rise as tire temperature rises.
Just breathe the air, fill your tires with air (or nitrogen), and have fun.
every other gas according to the universal gas law:
PV=nRT
If T goes up, then so does either P or V or the combination of P & V. In a tire, since the volume can't change much, it is the pressure P that goes up. The only difference with pure nitrogen vs non-dried air is that there can be a small moisture content in air with air droplets at cold temps that might vaporize at high temps and thus very slightly increase the total tire pressure of moist air vs nitrogen filled tires. Basically its all a massive marketing scam, promoted by the industry that sells nitrogen tire filling machines.
Now if you are flying a Boeing or other aircraft, things are different:
http://www.boeing.com/commercial/aer...m03/index.html
"In addition, Boeing has received reports of three confirmed cases and other suspected cases in which a wheel/tire assembly exploded when the oxygen in air-filled tires combined with volatile gases given off by a severely overheated tire. In one case, the tire became overheated as a result of a dragging brake, and the wheel/tire assembly exploded when it reached the auto-ignition temperature. In another case, a wheel/tire assembly explosion in the wheel well during flight was suspected in the catastrophic loss of one airplane. A similar explosion caused severe damage to two others.
As a result, the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration issued Airworthiness Directive 87-08-09 requiring that only nitrogen be used to inflate airplane tires on braked wheels. However, tires may be topped off with air in remote locations where nitrogen may not be available if the oxygen content in the tire does not exceed 5 percent by volume."
Per the FAA directive:
http://www.airweb.faa.gov/Regulatory...light=87-08-09
People just figured they could make some cash adapting an aviation requirement for preventing a couple incidents caused by very high overtemperature condition occurring during high speed brake failure/overheating causing combustion for tires infalted cold to pressures in the range of 200 psi.
And to really get the air out, you first have to fully purge the tire by sucking the air out, and then filling it with actually dried nitrogen, from a high pressure bottle. At a race event, it is required to carry nitrogen bottles for things like air guns, and thus obviate the need for a compressor, and then you can also use the nitogen to fill tires, having a very slightly better control of pressure rise as tire temperature rises.
Just breathe the air, fill your tires with air (or nitrogen), and have fun.
#29
Nitrogen does NOT expand and contract, It is also used in automatic altitude compensators to adjust the fuel air mixtures in aircraft carbs. The reason this works is the air is thinner at altitude and changes the position of the needle valve in the AATC.. Trust me Nitrogen done NOT expand and contract.. I am a retired Master Chief Aircraft Mechanic, I worked on these engines for 20 years and know how they work.
My LMR C-7 just made 844 RWHP today, can't wait to get my hande on this beast......
My LMR C-7 just made 844 RWHP today, can't wait to get my hande on this beast......
Secondly, you have this one all wrong Sarge. In fact, your example illustrates that nitrogen does indeed expand. With the air pressure lower at altitude, the constant number of nitrogen molecules within the compensator EXPANDS until it's pressure equals that of the outside air. That's what is moving the needle.
The most likely reason nitrogen is used in the compensator is it is dry, and hence there is no water vapor to freeze in the cold, high altitude environment.
#30
Instructor
Member Since: Apr 2006
Location: National City California
Posts: 150
Likes: 0
Received 12 Likes
on
8 Posts
Nitrogen
Sorry to disagree, Its the atmosphere that makes the needle go up and down pushing on a bellows filled w/ an inert gas (Nitrogen) So let me give you another example. I flew Helicopters and the Oleo strut on the side w/ the engine exhaust would be 6 inches higher after a flight when the hot exhaust gas blew on it for an hour or two, but when we started using Nitrogen they never moved a inch. so how would you explain
that ?
that ?
Firstly, thank you for your service.
Secondly, you have this one all wrong Sarge. In fact, your example illustrates that nitrogen does indeed expand. With the air pressure lower at altitude, the constant number of nitrogen molecules within the compensator EXPANDS until it's pressure equals that of the outside air. That's what is moving the needle.
The most likely reason nitrogen is used in the compensator is it is dry, and hence there is no water vapor to freeze in the cold, high altitude environment.
Secondly, you have this one all wrong Sarge. In fact, your example illustrates that nitrogen does indeed expand. With the air pressure lower at altitude, the constant number of nitrogen molecules within the compensator EXPANDS until it's pressure equals that of the outside air. That's what is moving the needle.
The most likely reason nitrogen is used in the compensator is it is dry, and hence there is no water vapor to freeze in the cold, high altitude environment.
#31
Sorry to disagree, Its the atmosphere that makes the needle go up and down pushing on a bellows filled w/ an inert gas (Nitrogen) So let me give you another example. I flew Helicopters and the Oleo strut on the side w/ the engine exhaust would be 6 inches higher after a flight when the hot exhaust gas blew on it for an hour or two, but when we started using Nitrogen they never moved a inch. so how would you explain
that ?
that ?
To keep things simple and friendly, let's agree to disagree.
We both have a passion the plastic fantastic, so what else could possible matter?
#32
Instructor
Member Since: Apr 2006
Location: National City California
Posts: 150
Likes: 0
Received 12 Likes
on
8 Posts
#33
At the temperatures and pressures inside automobile tires and aircraft compensators, nitrogen obeys the ideal gas law. First, an explanation of terms:
P. This is the absolute pressure. The absolute pressure in a tire is Pg, the pressure as measured by a tire gauge, plus Pa, the atmospheric pressure as measured by a barometer. Atmospheric pressure is also known as barometric pressure. Barometric pressure is about 14.7 psi or 101.3 kPa.
A flat tire has pressure 14.7 psi inside. It is flat because the ambient pressure outside is also 14.7 psi. A tire [or anything else] can be inflated only if it can support higher pressure inside than outside.
Each tire supports an amount of weight equal to the tire's gauge pressure Pg times the area of its contact patch.
V. This the capacity of the sealed container. The fill gas completely occupies this capacity. In the case of a highly elastic container like a toy balloon, the container expands in almost direct proportion to the amount of gas in the balloon. In the case of a less elastic container like an automobile tire, the container will expand as fill gas is added but it will not expand much. The behavior is essentially the same whether you use nitrogen or air.
n. This is the number of moles of fill gas. In the case of nitrogen, a mole is 28 grams. Because air is a mixture of gases, the term does not apply. However, 28.8 grams of air are effectively one mole of the mixture. One of the trace gases in air is water vapor. In my experience, compressed air has a larger fraction of water vapor than ambient air. In fact, I often get a small amount of liquid water in my stream of compressed air.
R. This is the Ideal Gas Constant. It plays no rule in the fundamental physics. It ensures that all measured values have consistent units.
T. This the absolute temperature of the gas inside the container. As measured by a Celsius thermometer, water freezes at 0 °C. However, the SI absolute temperature is measured in kelvins. As measured by a Kelvin thermometer, water freezes at 273 K. To determine the absolute temperature T, add 273 to the Celsius temperature.
The Ideal Gas Law tells us that absolute pressure is directly proportional to absolute temperature for a fixed-capacity container. This is why tire pressure decreases in cold weather.
In an earlier post in this thread, I discussed the differences between nitrogen and air. One difference that I did not discuss is the liquid water that is often part of the stream of compressed air used to fill tires. Because water undergoes phase changes at the temperatures of interest here, it may not obey the Ideal Gas Law.
When water evaporates, its volume increases by a factor of about 1000. When it freezes, solid ice may form inside your tire. If any of the water in the tire is liquid, then it contains living microorganisms.
We cannot forget that 20% of air is oxygen. The combination of oxygen and water inside your tires in not good. That said, the damage done by this combination may well be negligible for the life of your tires. If this is the case, then filling your tires with nitrogen may not be economic. Economics aside, there is no upside to filling your tires with air instead of nitrogen. If nitrogen refills are free or available at the same price as air, then refill your tires with nitrogen.
#34
For whatever it is worth, I TOTALLY agree the technical information you shared in this post.
#37
Heel & Toe
Member Since: Sep 2013
Location: Colorado Springs CO
Posts: 19
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
There is actually a benefit to nitrogen that was not mentioned here that I could find.
Nitrogen-filled tires leak less over time. That's because nitrogen molecules are more hot-dog shaped than oxygen and about 3 times larger. That means they leak out less over time. Admittedly, there's only 22% oxygen in a tire anyway, but for the masses, keeping tires properly inflated longer is an energy saver and a tire saver.
Most people won't check their pressures every month or so, and this will help. That's probably the biggest reason the industry is going that way.
Nitrogen-filled tires leak less over time. That's because nitrogen molecules are more hot-dog shaped than oxygen and about 3 times larger. That means they leak out less over time. Admittedly, there's only 22% oxygen in a tire anyway, but for the masses, keeping tires properly inflated longer is an energy saver and a tire saver.
Most people won't check their pressures every month or so, and this will help. That's probably the biggest reason the industry is going that way.
#38
There is actually a benefit to nitrogen that was not mentioned here that I could find.
Nitrogen-filled tires leak less over time. That's because nitrogen molecules are more hot-dog shaped than oxygen and about 3 times larger. That means they leak out less over time. Admittedly, there's only 22% oxygen in a tire anyway, but for the masses, keeping tires properly inflated longer is an energy saver and a tire saver.
Most people won't check their pressures every month or so, and this will help. That's probably the biggest reason the industry is going that way.
Nitrogen-filled tires leak less over time. That's because nitrogen molecules are more hot-dog shaped than oxygen and about 3 times larger. That means they leak out less over time. Admittedly, there's only 22% oxygen in a tire anyway, but for the masses, keeping tires properly inflated longer is an energy saver and a tire saver.
Most people won't check their pressures every month or so, and this will help. That's probably the biggest reason the industry is going that way.
I went through the qualities of nitrogen vs. air in Post #25 and Post #33. The point that I was making is that nitrogen has advantages over air, but its advantages are subtle. Subtle advantages may be swamped by other issues that you can't account for. My own experience using a nitrogen fill from my dealer was that my tires lost pressure faster than with compressed air.
My dealer is the only place that I know in town that has a nitrogen fill system. The advantages of nitrogen are not dramatic enough for me to go back to my dealer every time my tire pressure needs to be checked. I refilled with air at a convenience store on the way to work. If I had owned a nitrogen refill system at home, then I would have used it. If the convenience store supplied nitrogen along side air, then I would have chosen nitrogen.