[Z06] Katech Titanium/Molybdenum direct replacement LS7 exhaust valves
#61
Team Owner
Member Since: Apr 2001
Location: Elmhurst, IL (West Suburb of Chicago) & Home of MEGA Horsepower
Posts: 26,714
Received 584 Likes
on
399 Posts
St. Jude Donor '06
Good Lord....can this bickering stop ?
People who wanted a one piece stainless steel valve package have had that option available for some time.
Now, there's another valve package beyond the super alloys that offers an alternative to the OEM two piece valve that's not heavier like the stainless steel valve and is of a one piece design.
Can we now move forward ? Choose whatever package/option you want....there's something for everyone now.
People who wanted a one piece stainless steel valve package have had that option available for some time.
Now, there's another valve package beyond the super alloys that offers an alternative to the OEM two piece valve that's not heavier like the stainless steel valve and is of a one piece design.
Can we now move forward ? Choose whatever package/option you want....there's something for everyone now.
#62
Safety Car
I do think that time will show guides/solid valves to be very reliable in the LS7 heads, but it is awfully presumptive to make definitive, I-have-the-fix type statements that many throw around here while nit-picking the logic of others.
Around and `round we go!
#63
Race Director
Well yes actually. It's becoming more and more clear it isn't the valves causing the wear. That and the fact that GM made modifications to them in 2008 to make them stronger. Stock valves are fine. OP agrees with me as do many others, as does most all evidence. So they break under stress. Follow recent revelations to fix what is causing the stress and they will run forever. The valves are not the cause.
But it's your car. Mod how you feel you must. But there's a price to pay for being wrong.
But it's your car. Mod how you feel you must. But there's a price to pay for being wrong.
Forum members have their own opinions on their favorite exhaust valves. Since this is Katech's thread, kudos to them for giving us another choice.
#64
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Jul 2005
Location: winter haven florida
Posts: 2,052
Likes: 0
Received 40 Likes
on
35 Posts
St. Jude Donor '12
Well yes actually. It's becoming more and more clear it isn't the valves causing the wear. That and the fact that GM made modifications to them in 2008 to make them stronger. Stock valves are fine. OP agrees with me as do many others, as does most all evidence. So they break under stress. Follow recent revelations to fix what is causing the stress and they will run forever. The valves are not the cause.
But it's your car. Mod how you feel you must. But there's a price to pay for being wrong.
But it's your car. Mod how you feel you must. But there's a price to pay for being wrong.
#65
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Jul 2005
Location: winter haven florida
Posts: 2,052
Likes: 0
Received 40 Likes
on
35 Posts
St. Jude Donor '12
Actually, that's the very same argument used by some of the solid valve proponents all of the time (see 2000FRCZ19's post above). That's kind of the funny part. I agree though, selective use of data can be often times deceiving.
I do think that time will show guides/solid valves to be very reliable in the LS7 heads, but it is awfully presumptive to make definitive, I-have-the-fix type statements that many throw around here while nit-picking the logic of others.
Around and `round we go!
I do think that time will show guides/solid valves to be very reliable in the LS7 heads, but it is awfully presumptive to make definitive, I-have-the-fix type statements that many throw around here while nit-picking the logic of others.
Around and `round we go!
has anyone sent a set of valves to these guys for analysis?
http://met-tech.com/motorsports.html
Last edited by 2000FRCZ19; 12-08-2012 at 09:47 PM.
#67
I don't have any anxiety driving my car on stock valves. I am confident that if the guides are machined correctly, and the valves seating properly, and all geometry correct, then the sodium valves will be more than fine. I've heard the valves went through more than just a part number change. I was told GM made changes to make them stronger. I just can't get over the fact that these SS valves are close to 100g.
#68
Race Director
I don't have any anxiety driving my car on stock valves. I am confident that if the guides are machined correctly, and the valves seating properly, and all geometry correct, then the sodium valves will be more than fine. I've heard the valves went through more than just a part number change. I was told GM made changes to make them stronger. I just can't get over the fact that these SS valves are close to 100g.
I am more concerned that it is a guide problem that causes the other issues, but none of us can be certain, we just each have to deal with it in our own way after evaluating the information available.
#69
Unfortunately late MY 2008's and newer engines let go with the valves, too, so whatever the problem is, some of the valves have still failed even after the PN was changed.
I am more concerned that it is a guide problem that causes the other issues, but none of us can be certain, we just each have to deal with it in our own way after evaluating the information available.
I am more concerned that it is a guide problem that causes the other issues, but none of us can be certain, we just each have to deal with it in our own way after evaluating the information available.
#71
Burning Brakes
I plan to keep this car so I will plan on trying to accomplish head work in the spring that will get me a good long ways down the road. My car has about 40k on it, and gets about 10k per year.
#72
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Jul 2005
Location: winter haven florida
Posts: 2,052
Likes: 0
Received 40 Likes
on
35 Posts
St. Jude Donor '12
I don't have any anxiety driving my car on stock valves. I am confident that if the guides are machined correctly, and the valves seating properly, and all geometry correct, then the sodium valves will be more than fine. I've heard the valves went through more than just a part number change. I was told GM made changes to make them stronger. I just can't get over the fact that these SS valves are close to 100g.
Last edited by 2000FRCZ19; 12-08-2012 at 08:51 PM.
#73
There will always be spectators and players. The players did not want to be a victim so they went with the ss set up. They work well. Are they heavier? yes. However with a heavier spring there is no floating and the motor revs just as before. Some of us have torn them down after the install to double check and gather data. All is good.
I am sure the Katech valve is great as well. Due to the weight savings no need to go with a heavier spring. As time goes on there will continue to be a new fix. The one thing you dont want to do is sit and wait. If you do there is a good chance you will end up being a spectator/victim.
I am sure the Katech valve is great as well. Due to the weight savings no need to go with a heavier spring. As time goes on there will continue to be a new fix. The one thing you dont want to do is sit and wait. If you do there is a good chance you will end up being a spectator/victim.
#74
Burning Brakes
There will always be spectators and players. The players did not want to be a victim so they went with the ss set up. They work well. Are they heavier? yes. However with a heavier spring there is no floating and the motor revs just as before. Some of us have torn them down after the install to double check and gather data. All is good.
I am sure the Katech valve is great as well. Due to the weight savings no need to go with a heavier spring. As time goes on there will continue to be a new fix. The one thing you dont want to do is sit and wait. If you do there is a good chance you will end up being a spectator/victim.
I am sure the Katech valve is great as well. Due to the weight savings no need to go with a heavier spring. As time goes on there will continue to be a new fix. The one thing you dont want to do is sit and wait. If you do there is a good chance you will end up being a spectator/victim.
I went all out with Manley's duel coil .700 lift spring with my .660 lift cam to have extra assurance with the SI SS valves WCCH installed in my new heads. I would rather spend a little extra to be safe than sorry.
Last edited by ClarksZ06; 12-08-2012 at 10:30 PM.
#75
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Jul 2005
Location: winter haven florida
Posts: 2,052
Likes: 0
Received 40 Likes
on
35 Posts
St. Jude Donor '12
Correct. We all have to take the information we learn and apply it the best we can. I feel there is more evidence suggesting the exhaust valves aren't the cause than evidence suggesting they are. I've waited almost two years to start modding my car/addressing the issue. The key provision, like I said: don't be wrong. I strongly feel there is a right and wrong answer as to how to address this guide wear issue. My 2 cents. If I had the money right now, and who knows maybe I do, Id throw a set of these valves in there because they pass the weight test and won't force a compromise on another part of the engine which might force you to have to change out another part to compensate and when do you stop and when is everything verifiably stable for 100,000 miles? Who has 100,000 miles on a set of SS exhaust valves in an LS7? That's great some have 15,000. What happens if the setup fails at 40,000? What did you accomplish then? Again this is just my 2 cents. I don't lose sleep if another forum member runs SS vales in their heads. Maybe Im wrong, maybe there are multiple solutions. I hope I am.
just some random info found outside of the forum.
General Recommendations
For most street engines, a quality stainless-steel valve is recommended. Titanium is generally preferred for most race applications, but some engine builders that specialize in turbocharged applications prefer a high-nickel Inconel valve. Hollow-stem valves tend to work great on the intake side, but are much more difficult to manufacture and to inspect for defects on the I.D. surface. Many upper-echelon engine builders shy away from hollow valves for that reason in endurance (NASCAR or 24-hour style) racing.
Stainless-steel valves are most common in street and mild-performance racing. Titanium is used when valve weight is important and cost is not a consideration. Inconel is used when exhaust gas temperatures get really high. Stainless steel (for street performance) has much better durability characteristics than titanium, and the street guys won’t usually see the real benefits of titanium. In racing, use titanium when you want to lose weight…and spend a lot of money.
If durability is your customer’s concern and he’s already making as much power as he wants and is already turning the engine as high as he wants, then use a stainless-steel material. If he’s running nitromethane, then an Inconel exhaust valve material will be his best bet if he wants to finish a race.
Last edited by 2000FRCZ19; 12-08-2012 at 11:49 PM.
#76
Race Director
Nothing like another session of complaining to get Jason out of here.......I was looking forward to a couple of the answers asked for.
#77
In the past, they recommended their Titanium/Molybdenum intake valves when going with the bronze guides.
A set of those runs about $1200.00. So another $1200.00 for these exhaust valves, puts you at $2400.00 just for valves.
You get done with springs, retainers, guides, hot tanking, valve job, and any other work to your current heads, you'll end up with about a $3600.00 into reinforcing your stock set of heads, if you go with the titanium intake and exhaust valves.
It will be interesting to see who goes this route first and what kinds of results they get.
#79
Safety Car
I'd be interested in knowing the answer to this too out of curiosity.
In the past, they recommended their Titanium/Molybdenum intake valves when going with the bronze guides.
A set of those runs about $1200.00. So another $1200.00 for these exhaust valves, puts you at $2400.00 just for valves.
You get done with springs, retainers, guides, hot tanking, valve job, and any other work to your current heads, you'll end up with about a $3600.00 into reinforcing your stock set of heads, if you go with the titanium intake and exhaust valves.
It will be interesting to see who goes this route first and what kinds of results they get.
In the past, they recommended their Titanium/Molybdenum intake valves when going with the bronze guides.
A set of those runs about $1200.00. So another $1200.00 for these exhaust valves, puts you at $2400.00 just for valves.
You get done with springs, retainers, guides, hot tanking, valve job, and any other work to your current heads, you'll end up with about a $3600.00 into reinforcing your stock set of heads, if you go with the titanium intake and exhaust valves.
It will be interesting to see who goes this route first and what kinds of results they get.
But its another option for people to choose from to fix the problem and thats good never like hearing about people having motor issues
#80
Safety Car