[Z06] Possible cause of valve failure
#1
Race Director
Thread Starter
Possible cause of valve failure
I know we're all sick of these threads, but I ran across this in another section of the cf forum and thought it was really interesting. I thought I would pass it on. It's a wonder our cars even run at all.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_REQ1PUM0rY
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_REQ1PUM0rY
#4
Burning Brakes
This was just discussed the other day. LG and Livernois Motorsports said many of the failures, especially with modded Z's, is due to poor setups. The wrong combination of parts. Alot of that being "under spring'd"
These companies are not seeing the problems some others are.
I know LG spintron tests all there cam packages and uses the high end comp valve springs.
These companies are not seeing the problems some others are.
I know LG spintron tests all there cam packages and uses the high end comp valve springs.
Last edited by ClarksZ06; 07-22-2012 at 03:15 PM.
#5
Team Owner
Member Since: Apr 2001
Location: Elmhurst, IL (West Suburb of Chicago) & Home of MEGA Horsepower
Posts: 26,714
Received 584 Likes
on
399 Posts
St. Jude Donor '06
Here we go again!
I must admit these threads going up daily and reshashing the same crap with nothing getting accomplished, except negative energy and debates going back and forth between the same people, is starting to become comical to me.
What is not comical is how this same old crap beging rehased over, and over and over, and over, and over, and over, and over, and over, and over, and over again, has chased away many stand up C6 Z owners from frequenting the C6 Z section of the forum, and does not make it enjoyable for many more to come here to frequent this section anymore.
I must admit these threads going up daily and reshashing the same crap with nothing getting accomplished, except negative energy and debates going back and forth between the same people, is starting to become comical to me.
What is not comical is how this same old crap beging rehased over, and over and over, and over, and over, and over, and over, and over, and over, and over again, has chased away many stand up C6 Z owners from frequenting the C6 Z section of the forum, and does not make it enjoyable for many more to come here to frequent this section anymore.
Last edited by Mopar Jimmy; 07-22-2012 at 04:02 PM.
#7
Drifting
Here's a question... How close is the water jacket to the guides in a LS7...? Maybe it's a heat issue... Im not here to blame the LS7 anymore but I'd like to know why STOCK cars have failed... Like others have stated maybe is a cooling issue causing the premature wear in the guides... Maybe the exhaust valve is expanding cause wear due to poor cooling... Now don't flame me I'm just putting it out there... My car is almost done so I'll be back out soon...!
#8
Here's a question... How close is the water jacket to the guides in a LS7...? Maybe it's a heat issue... Im not here to blame the LS7 anymore but I'd like to know why STOCK cars have failed... Like others have stated maybe is a cooling issue causing the premature wear in the guides... Maybe the exhaust valve is expanding cause wear due to poor cooling... Now don't flame me I'm just putting it out there... My car is almost done so I'll be back out soon...!
Especially those in hot climates.
Last edited by '06 Quicksilver Z06; 07-22-2012 at 04:25 PM.
#9
Drifting
Well friend of mine was doing some measuring on my heads and on a couple sets of LS1, LS2, LS6 heads and the jackets are much closer is those heads compared to the LS7... I wish everyone had the time to pull their heads and check guide wear cause I'm pretty sure every 06-08 heads out there would have some excessive wear... Now Quick dont flame me on my wording or pick at the small things im saying just try to look pass that... I'm not here to harp on the LS7 anymore... I've gotten a report from a friend with a 2010 ZO6 that just dropped a exhaust valve with only 12k miles and JUST a CAI without a tune... I'm gonna try to get more info on driving style and everything else you look for to see what's at fault... As soon as I know more you will know... As for the cooling.. It may not cause failure but it might have to do with the guide wear people are finding...
#10
Drifting
A shop up hear in Canada called Champion Motors does a head cooling mod to the rear of the heads... I need to ask them more of why they do it and what exactly done cause I haven't ever seen any one or shop talk about it too..
#11
This was just discussed the other day. LG and Livernois Motorsports said many of the failures, especially with modded Z's, is due to poor setups. The wrong combination of parts. Alot of that being "under spring'd"
These companies are not seeing the problems some others are.
I know LG spintron tests all there cam packages and uses the high end comp valve springs.
These companies are not seeing the problems some others are.
I know LG spintron tests all there cam packages and uses the high end comp valve springs.
I'd be interested in reading what they have to say.
Thanks.
#12
Well friend of mine was doing some measuring on my heads and on a couple sets of LS1, LS2, LS6 heads and the jackets are much closer is those heads compared to the LS7... I wish everyone had the time to pull their heads and check guide wear cause I'm pretty sure every 06-08 heads out there would have some excessive wear... Now Quick dont flame me on my wording or pick at the small things im saying just try to look pass that... I'm not here to harp on the LS7 anymore... I've gotten a report from a friend with a 2010 ZO6 that just dropped a exhaust valve with only 12k miles and JUST a CAI without a tune... I'm gonna try to get more info on driving style and everything else you look for to see what's at fault... As soon as I know more you will know... As for the cooling.. It may not cause failure but it might have to do with the guide wear people are finding...
Forum member ConfusedGarage, has an '06 and his guides were fine. At least one other member, EViL427 with an '08, discovered the same thing after having his guides measured.
In addition to that, it has been mentioned several times that valve guide wear, in and of itself, might not even be a guarantee of valve failure as there are cars out there with in excess of 100,000 miles, which have not suffered a valve failure, but probably have at least one valve guide worn out of spec.
Finally, as for the 2010 which has "dropped a valve". There have been, 5,263 Z06s built since 2009 model year. One known example of a car from out of that lot, does not indicate a thing, and is likely well within the number of expected failures.
To wit, there has been ONE known example of a valve spring failure of a 2009 on this forum, yet we don't view that as an epidemic among 2009 cars.
Last edited by '06 Quicksilver Z06; 07-22-2012 at 06:47 PM.
#13
Drifting
First off who said that I was indicating anything about 2009 and up failures.. I was just saying one did fail... Not that it means they are all gonna fail too... You read too much into what I posted... Also I was talking about excessive guide wear not about it leading to failure... Let's replace every with most... Again like I said don't read too much into what I've posted... Your putting words in my mouth now or words in a post I didnt post...
#14
Team Owner
#15
Instructor
Member Since: Jul 2006
Location: Peoria AZ
Posts: 142
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Great now the 2010s are dropping valves. The car is almost new. There is no excuse for this. Dont even bother saying its only one. Its just the only one reported. I would bet after all this time owners arnt bothering to report their own due to the resell value droping. Only going to hear this from others. Flame suit on I only say this because im a potiental buyer and i dont want this covered up and hushed because your worried about your resell value
#16
I know I didn't. I was just pointing out that one example says nothing of their extent. No matter who decides to point to it. You or anyone else.
Then in your own words, and without me or anyone else, "putting them in your mouth", what say you is the significance of valve guide wear? And please show how you have proven it's significance.
Last edited by '06 Quicksilver Z06; 07-22-2012 at 06:46 PM.
#17
Safety Car
#18
Le Mans Master
Great now the 2010s are dropping valves. The car is almost new. There is no excuse for this. Dont even bother saying its only one. Its just the only one reported. I would bet after all this time owners arnt bothering to report their own due to the resell value droping. Only going to hear this from others. Flame suit on I only say this because im a potiental buyer and i dont want this covered up and hushed because your worried about your resell value
And at least this makes it easy for you to not buy the Z06. Just buy a 911 Turbo or a Ferrari 458. On the plus side they are both slower and on the negative side they are twice the price.
Or buy a GTR and ignore the class action lawsuit that had to be filed to get them to honor the warranty on their grenading 20K transmissions.
#19
Drifting
Man now for you to believe me I gotta get every shop and engine builder I've personally talked to or have gone to see to come on here and either show you or message you their findings for you to believe me... Carlos & ZoSicktanner are a few that you might know... I gotta do this in person with you or you'll just discredit me... Now I see why people just say this is a waste of time talking about... Cause some desk jockey is gonna sit there and spend all his time to prove me wrong so f*^% it... I bow out Quick aka white night... Shouldve just left it alone... You should pull your heads and check just to see for yourself... Can't deny what's right in front of you... You edit your stuff all the time to remove what you say...
#20
Drifting
Great now the 2010s are dropping valves. The car is almost new. There is no excuse for this. Dont even bother saying its only one. Its just the only one reported. I would bet after all this time owners arnt bothering to report their own due to the resell value droping. Only going to hear this from others. Flame suit on I only say this because im a potiental buyer and i dont want this covered up and hushed because your worried about your resell value