My Vette VS my BMW
#1
My Vette VS my BMW
I have a 2012 Vette GS convert with all the factory bells and whistles but I'm bothered by the fact that my Dinan 3 BMW 335i Xdrive coupe accelerates harder then my Vette in a throttle plant in 6th gear. I guess the Bimmer has more torque at around 2000-2500 RPMs even though the Bimmer has maybe 360-370 HP and the Vette is supposed to have 435 HP. Is there anything simple and/or inexpensive that I can do to the Vette to get it to accelerate like the Bimmer?
Please don't tell me to get a supercharger. That's expensive in purchase price and the cost of installation.
Please don't tell me to get a supercharger. That's expensive in purchase price and the cost of installation.
#4
start in 1st gear, then 2nd, then 3rd...... now compare. 6th gear is for gas mileage and I am sure the vette in 6th will turn less rpms at 70 than the bimmer, thus your thought on the torque curve is probably accurate.
#5
M3 over a c7? was it cheaper or something? The Corvette finally really updates its interior to compete and you still went M3 l
#7
Melting Slicks
The C6 will not hit its factory rated top speed in 6th gear, it's too tall to push the air, you have to downshift to 5th and then you can hit 186 mph in 5th. 6th gear is strictly for gas milage and forget about any acceleration. The 335 responds very well to tuning, it will pull hard. Headers and a tune on your GS will add 30 HP and torque and put a smile on your face for a couple of grand, which I'm sure you spent for the Dinan setup. Do that, and downshift, or just downshift period, and the 335 wont leave the garage unless you need the back seat.
Last edited by v26278; 11-01-2014 at 02:11 AM.
#8
Team Owner
Member Since: Jun 2005
Location: Northern, VA
Posts: 46,134
Received 2,492 Likes
on
1,953 Posts
St. Jude Donor '15
"In honor of jpee"
All the above plus v, above. You are seriously comparing sixth or top gear pull of both cars? Have you looked at the trans gear ratios and rear end ratios to compare them?
#11
Le Mans Master
Your BMW has considerably different gear ratios compared to the Vette. Based on this chart from a Bimmer forum, a better (although still not exact) comparison would be 5th gear in the Vette to 6th gear in the BMW.
Edit 1: Chart below.
Edit 2: Actually, if that chart is accurate, the BMW should be turning about 2500RPM at 60MPH so a manual GS with a 3.42 rear axle might have to be in 4th to level the field depending on the tire size (which I am too lazy to look up on Google).
Edit 1: Chart below.
Edit 2: Actually, if that chart is accurate, the BMW should be turning about 2500RPM at 60MPH so a manual GS with a 3.42 rear axle might have to be in 4th to level the field depending on the tire size (which I am too lazy to look up on Google).
Last edited by Dale1990; 11-01-2014 at 01:14 PM.
#12
Team Owner
6th gear in the Vette is a far higher gear than in the BMW. In fact, I'm not aware of any car that has a higher top gear than 6th in the Vette. The comparison is not valid.
#13
Melting Slicks
I have a 2012 Vette GS convert with all the factory bells and whistles but I'm bothered by the fact that my Dinan 3 BMW 335i Xdrive coupe accelerates harder then my Vette in a throttle plant in 6th gear. I guess the Bimmer has more torque at around 2000-2500 RPMs even though the Bimmer has maybe 360-370 HP and the Vette is supposed to have 435 HP. Is there anything simple and/or inexpensive that I can do to the Vette to get it to accelerate like the Bimmer?
Please don't tell me to get a supercharger. That's expensive in purchase price and the cost of installation.
Please don't tell me to get a supercharger. That's expensive in purchase price and the cost of installation.
#14
Racer
Member Since: Aug 2014
Location: Elizabethtown, NC
Posts: 469
Likes: 0
Received 61 Likes
on
47 Posts
I have a 2012 Vette GS convert with all the factory bells and whistles but I'm bothered by the fact that my Dinan 3 BMW 335i Xdrive coupe accelerates harder then my Vette in a throttle plant in 6th gear. I guess the Bimmer has more torque at around 2000-2500 RPMs even though the Bimmer has maybe 360-370 HP and the Vette is supposed to have 435 HP. Is there anything simple and/or inexpensive that I can do to the Vette to get it to accelerate like the Bimmer?
Please don't tell me to get a supercharger. That's expensive in purchase price and the cost of installation.
Please don't tell me to get a supercharger. That's expensive in purchase price and the cost of installation.
#15
Melting Slicks
Tom. You can not be serious. Are you listening to yourself. When you utilize a cars performance potential you utilize the engine's peak performance, meaning being in the correct gear at the correct hp/torque curve and not every car is the same. Do yourself a favor and take 6 th gear out of the equation. Listen to not only me but everybody else as well. HELLO!!!
#16
Safety Car
If you want more throttle response on the highway and are ok with running 2000 - 2500 rpm on the highway like your BMW, there are two options:
1) Don't upshift into 6th gear below 100 mph. This solution is free.
2) Put 4.10s (or higher if you find them) in the rear. That will bring your highway rpms up 20% and by the time you're doing 75 mph you can at least get to 2000 rpms. With 4.10s you're not going to race anybody in 6th gear, but the car will at least respond for basic passing needs. Additionally, the lower gears become more fun too.
1) Don't upshift into 6th gear below 100 mph. This solution is free.
2) Put 4.10s (or higher if you find them) in the rear. That will bring your highway rpms up 20% and by the time you're doing 75 mph you can at least get to 2000 rpms. With 4.10s you're not going to race anybody in 6th gear, but the car will at least respond for basic passing needs. Additionally, the lower gears become more fun too.
#17
Tech Contributor
Member Since: Oct 1999
Location: Charlotte, NC (formerly Endicott, NY)
Posts: 40,173
Received 9,003 Likes
on
5,370 Posts
Bill
#18
Team Owner
I think that DCTs seem very complicated and because of this, they may not hold up as well long term. Some cars with them will never know, like Ferraris, because most never are driven any significant number of miles. People expect an automatic transmission to go over 100,000 miles with no problems. If a complicated DCT requires an overhaul or big repair at 50,000, regular people will complain, while Ferrari drivers will brag about it. After all, the 12,000 mile regular service on a 599 Ferrari is about $15,000. I would like to know how much a trans overhaul would be on that DCT. I would also doubt that a dealer would be capable of doing it.
#19
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Jul 2010
Location: Tacoma, Wa/Surprise, Az
Posts: 2,854
Received 202 Likes
on
170 Posts
Although I would like to see a DCT in the Vette I doubt it needs one. The broad torque range provided by the engine means you just don't have to shift that often. The DCTs advantages are making smooth appropriately rev matched down shifts and very fast upshifts. In a drag race from a dead stop with launch control a DCT can get an advantage due to quick shifts but on a road course where you only use 3rd and 4th gears. Up or down shifting isn't anywhere near as much of a big dea other than you take a few tenths of a second longer on the upshift so power isn't flowing to the wheels during that time.
Bill
Bill
The tracks I visit I use 2-3-4.