How screwed am I?!
#2
Race Director
Member Since: Aug 2005
Location: Hudson WI
Posts: 13,598
Received 181 Likes
on
162 Posts
NCM Sinkhole Donor
Your screwed pretty bad. You need to have the head gone through and a new piston, in my opinion.
Good reason to buy a new forged motor!
I guess you won't be at the Optima Ultimate Street Car event at the Autobahn on Saturday.
Good reason to buy a new forged motor!
I guess you won't be at the Optima Ultimate Street Car event at the Autobahn on Saturday.
#3
Tech Contributor
Member Since: Dec 2006
Location: Van Buren Arkansas
Posts: 10,962
Likes: 0
Received 26 Likes
on
25 Posts
Wounded Warrior Escort '11
I'm trying to understand how the valve managed to hit the piston in the first place, assuming you had the correct length pushrod? Did you pull the lifter out to see if anything is wrong with it? The piston has to be replaced...you need to see the rod bearing when you get it out. Could be some crankshaft damage too if that bearing is done.
#4
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
I'm trying to understand how the valve managed to hit the piston in the first place, assuming you had the correct length pushrod? Did you pull the lifter out to see if anything is wrong with it? The piston has to be replaced...you need to see the rod bearing when you get it out. Could be some crankshaft damage too if that bearing is done.
#5
Track Junky
What were the circumstances when the noise started? Missed shift, high rpm run, etc. Did you measure PTV clearance when you installed the cam? If you list the cam specs, others may be able to chime in with clearances. I would say that you are out a valve, spring and possible pushrods at a minimum. The piston and bearing could be in question, but I bet it would snap off the head of the valve before it did major damage to the bottom end. The thing I see that doesn't look good is that you have 100% contact around the entire circumference of the valve head as proven by the complete circle on the piston head.
Search around and ask some of the seasoned vets on this forum what your options are.
Search around and ask some of the seasoned vets on this forum what your options are.
#6
Le Mans Master
Not to screwed.... block is still whole.
First step - You need to find out why this happened.
Maybe remove the engine from the car for convenience and efficiency. Inspecting and replacing parts will be easy.
First step - You need to find out why this happened.
Maybe remove the engine from the car for convenience and efficiency. Inspecting and replacing parts will be easy.
#7
Team Owner
Member Since: Jun 2005
Location: Northern, VA
Posts: 46,111
Received 2,485 Likes
on
1,947 Posts
St. Jude Donor '15
"In honor of jpee"
just asking questions, but one piston replaced only? also, what effect does no tune at same time as cam install have?
#9
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
dgrant - I haven't had a chance to pull out the valve yet since I no longer have the tool to take the springs out.
taken - normal driving. Starting around 3500 rpm in 3rd gear cruising down the road. The cam is a Englandgreen Mayhem 2 cam (they don't list the specs anywhere).
kenny - that was the plan to take the entire engine out. I am going to need to do this anyway to replace the piston that was damaged.
aoroads - my thoughts exactly. No reason to replace the whole engine as the block is still good.
My thoughts are to pull the engine and get a stroker crank and piston set up. How hard would this be to do in a garage for someone with decent experience? I am guessing it will be pretty difficult since I will need to bore out the cylinder heads to accommodate the stroker? I figure since I'm opening the entire engine up anyway I might as well put better parts in it--more so since the engine had 70k on the clock. Any recommendations on a kit?
Still unsure what to do with the heads. Would it be possible to put LS7 heads onto a LS2? I might not be able to budget in a set of AFR's, but might be able to swing some ported LS3 or LS7 heads--or would I be better off just going with a ported set of LS2's? I seen Livernois sells some for $1k.
taken - normal driving. Starting around 3500 rpm in 3rd gear cruising down the road. The cam is a Englandgreen Mayhem 2 cam (they don't list the specs anywhere).
kenny - that was the plan to take the entire engine out. I am going to need to do this anyway to replace the piston that was damaged.
aoroads - my thoughts exactly. No reason to replace the whole engine as the block is still good.
My thoughts are to pull the engine and get a stroker crank and piston set up. How hard would this be to do in a garage for someone with decent experience? I am guessing it will be pretty difficult since I will need to bore out the cylinder heads to accommodate the stroker? I figure since I'm opening the entire engine up anyway I might as well put better parts in it--more so since the engine had 70k on the clock. Any recommendations on a kit?
Still unsure what to do with the heads. Would it be possible to put LS7 heads onto a LS2? I might not be able to budget in a set of AFR's, but might be able to swing some ported LS3 or LS7 heads--or would I be better off just going with a ported set of LS2's? I seen Livernois sells some for $1k.
#10
Le Mans Master
If it were me, with 80k miles on the odo, I'd send the heads out to WCCH and have them rebuilt. Then rebuild the bottom end as well. Otherwise you may end up spending a lot more $$ in the not so distant future.
#11
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
What would need to be rebuilt in the heads? They currently have patriot dual valve springs and titanium retainers that have less then 50 miles on them. Only item in there that would be old are the valves.
#12
Race Director
Bottom end will be rebuild with a stroker kit--might as well do the whole bottom end as mentioned because of the miles.
What would need to be rebuilt in the heads? They currently have patriot dual valve springs and titanium retainers that have less then 50 miles on them. Only item in there that would be old are the valves.
What would need to be rebuilt in the heads? They currently have patriot dual valve springs and titanium retainers that have less then 50 miles on them. Only item in there that would be old are the valves.
#13
Melting Slicks
Actually, I think you are very lucky.
Actually, I think you are very lucky. If that exhaust valve head had broken off it would have broken up the piston which would have left the rod free to trash the block.
The easy fix would be to replace that one exhaust valve, and retainer. Did the spring break or the keepers come loose or did the valve stick in the guide?
You can do a leakdown test by putting the opposite head on that side and the turn the piston to TDC.
It appears the piston is OK, but I would clean it up and use some dye-chem on it looking for cracks.
You need to check piston to valve clearance!!!!
If you want to go through this motor, replace the valve guides with bronze guides and replace all the valves with a quality 1-piece valve, replace the pistons with forged coated pistons, and balance it.
If you are going to install a stroker kit, the heads need to be gone through and all the valve guides replaced as well as the OEM valves. I would just send the heads to WCCH and they will do it all. You mentioned boring out the cylinder heads? That is not required. If the new pistons are oversize, the block will need to be bored to fit the new pistons.
If there is any wear in the bores or a ridge at the top, the block will need boring and new oversize pistons. You can take the bare block and new pistons to a machine shop and they can take care of it. Replace the timing chain, check all the geometry/pushrod lengths, and replace the rod bolts with ARP. Of course replace rings and bearings and use some quality fasteners for the heads. All of this is doable in your garage and some machine shop help.
Best of luck!
The easy fix would be to replace that one exhaust valve, and retainer. Did the spring break or the keepers come loose or did the valve stick in the guide?
You can do a leakdown test by putting the opposite head on that side and the turn the piston to TDC.
It appears the piston is OK, but I would clean it up and use some dye-chem on it looking for cracks.
You need to check piston to valve clearance!!!!
If you want to go through this motor, replace the valve guides with bronze guides and replace all the valves with a quality 1-piece valve, replace the pistons with forged coated pistons, and balance it.
If you are going to install a stroker kit, the heads need to be gone through and all the valve guides replaced as well as the OEM valves. I would just send the heads to WCCH and they will do it all. You mentioned boring out the cylinder heads? That is not required. If the new pistons are oversize, the block will need to be bored to fit the new pistons.
If there is any wear in the bores or a ridge at the top, the block will need boring and new oversize pistons. You can take the bare block and new pistons to a machine shop and they can take care of it. Replace the timing chain, check all the geometry/pushrod lengths, and replace the rod bolts with ARP. Of course replace rings and bearings and use some quality fasteners for the heads. All of this is doable in your garage and some machine shop help.
Best of luck!
#14
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Thanks for the info. Spring held together and retainer keepers are still in place. It looks like the valve is stuck in the guide, but will not know for sure until I can get the spring off.
This is the kit I will be more than likely going with.
403NA LSX Rotating Assembly 11.7 w/62cc
-Callies Compstar4.000 Forged 4340
-Crank w/24x Reluctor
-Eagle 6.125 LS1 3D Forged H-beam
-Rods w/ARP2000 bolts
-Diamond Forged Pistons & Rings
-Clevite Main and Rod bearings
Will require any modification to the block?
This is the kit I will be more than likely going with.
403NA LSX Rotating Assembly 11.7 w/62cc
-Callies Compstar4.000 Forged 4340
-Crank w/24x Reluctor
-Eagle 6.125 LS1 3D Forged H-beam
-Rods w/ARP2000 bolts
-Diamond Forged Pistons & Rings
-Clevite Main and Rod bearings
Will require any modification to the block?
#15
Burning Brakes
Member Since: Aug 2009
Location: Virginia Beach Virginia
Posts: 816
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks for the info. Spring held together and retainer keepers are still in place. It looks like the valve is stuck in the guide, but will not know for sure until I can get the spring off.
This is the kit I will be more than likely going with.
403NA LSX Rotating Assembly 11.7 w/62cc
-Callies Compstar4.000 Forged 4340
-Crank w/24x Reluctor
-Eagle 6.125 LS1 3D Forged H-beam
-Rods w/ARP2000 bolts
-Diamond Forged Pistons & Rings
-Clevite Main and Rod bearings
Will require any modification to the block?
This is the kit I will be more than likely going with.
403NA LSX Rotating Assembly 11.7 w/62cc
-Callies Compstar4.000 Forged 4340
-Crank w/24x Reluctor
-Eagle 6.125 LS1 3D Forged H-beam
-Rods w/ARP2000 bolts
-Diamond Forged Pistons & Rings
-Clevite Main and Rod bearings
Will require any modification to the block?
#16
Le Mans Master
Time for some upgrades to the heads and intake mani. Stock 243 heads are a pretty serious bottle neck on a 403. Lots of options depending on goals and fatness of wallet. LS3 heads and intake mani is a pretty cost effective route. Lots of threads on the subject. Sucks that you have to do it.....but it's an "opportunity" to make it much better
#17
My friend just went with the same 403 setup and some wcch ported ls3 heads. He is very happy with all the new torque and piece of mind that comes with a forged motor.
#18
Melting Slicks
#19
Melting Slicks
Thanks for the info. Spring held together and retainer keepers are still in place. It looks like the valve is stuck in the guide, but will not know for sure until I can get the spring off.
This is the kit I will be more than likely going with.
403NA LSX Rotating Assembly 11.7 w/62cc
-Callies Compstar4.000 Forged 4340
-Crank w/24x Reluctor
-Eagle 6.125 LS1 3D Forged H-beam
-Rods w/ARP2000 bolts
-Diamond Forged Pistons & Rings
-Clevite Main and Rod bearings
Will require any modification to the block?
This is the kit I will be more than likely going with.
403NA LSX Rotating Assembly 11.7 w/62cc
-Callies Compstar4.000 Forged 4340
-Crank w/24x Reluctor
-Eagle 6.125 LS1 3D Forged H-beam
-Rods w/ARP2000 bolts
-Diamond Forged Pistons & Rings
-Clevite Main and Rod bearings
Will require any modification to the block?
I like your list of parts except the Eagle rods. See if they offer an upgrade option for the rods. Most Eagle parts are imported from China. Some of the parts are great, especially for the price, but the quality control over the steel alloy and the forging/machining process is not the best. It only takes one flaw in 1 of the 8 rods to have a big problem. The best example is, what other companies do you know that sells brand new parts that are already .010-.030" undersize?
Your LS2 cathedral port heads will be ok, but definitely a limiting factor. At the very least you need to have them rebuilt with new guides and new exhaust valves. You could have them ported, but with the cost of porting you could buy new L92 heads that are identical to the LS3 rectangular port head and offer a lot more potential. Scoggin Dickey had new L92 heads for $150 each as well as several upgrade packages. The best option is a new pair of bare L92 heads and send them to WCCH for new guides, porting, and new quality 1-piece valves. The only negative to this is you will need 8 new offset LS3 intake rockers (these are very inexpensive) and a rectangular port intake like an LS3 or a FAST 102. Your headers and everything else will swap right over to the new heads.
Hope this helps!