[Z06] Class Action Against GM !!??
#221
Le Mans Master
As someone mentioned before, I cannot wait to see what evidence is produced from discovery... if the lawsuit ever gets to that point and the information is finally open to public records search. I think that information release will be the most interesting part of this process.
There seems to be so much debate and arguing on this site regarding the actual existence of the valve issue. And of course, I can understand GM doesn't want to officially comment because anything you say can later come back to bite you... However, had GM been a little more open about results of their own internal investigation, I feel it would have garnered a little more trust instead of their "machining error on some heads from 2009-2011" statement. I think GM failed to realize the Corvette customer is oftentimes very very different from the customer who purchases an Equinox (for example). Maybe I'm wrong though - the C7 Z06's seem to be selling like hotcakes.
Anyway, can't wait to see if any internal info becomes open to the public.
There seems to be so much debate and arguing on this site regarding the actual existence of the valve issue. And of course, I can understand GM doesn't want to officially comment because anything you say can later come back to bite you... However, had GM been a little more open about results of their own internal investigation, I feel it would have garnered a little more trust instead of their "machining error on some heads from 2009-2011" statement. I think GM failed to realize the Corvette customer is oftentimes very very different from the customer who purchases an Equinox (for example). Maybe I'm wrong though - the C7 Z06's seem to be selling like hotcakes.
Anyway, can't wait to see if any internal info becomes open to the public.
The following users liked this post:
SurfnSun (10-24-2015)
#223
Team Owner
As someone mentioned before, I cannot wait to see what evidence is produced from discovery... if the lawsuit ever gets to that point and the information is finally open to public records search. I think that information release will be the most interesting part of this process.
There seems to be so much debate and arguing on this site regarding the actual existence of the valve issue. And of course, I can understand GM doesn't want to officially comment because anything you say can later come back to bite you... However, had GM been a little more open about results of their own internal investigation, I feel it would have garnered a little more trust instead of their "machining error on some heads from 2009-2011" statement. I think GM failed to realize the Corvette customer is oftentimes very very different from the customer who purchases an Equinox (for example). Maybe I'm wrong though - the C7 Z06's seem to be selling like hotcakes.
Anyway, can't wait to see if any internal info becomes open to the public.
There seems to be so much debate and arguing on this site regarding the actual existence of the valve issue. And of course, I can understand GM doesn't want to officially comment because anything you say can later come back to bite you... However, had GM been a little more open about results of their own internal investigation, I feel it would have garnered a little more trust instead of their "machining error on some heads from 2009-2011" statement. I think GM failed to realize the Corvette customer is oftentimes very very different from the customer who purchases an Equinox (for example). Maybe I'm wrong though - the C7 Z06's seem to be selling like hotcakes.
Anyway, can't wait to see if any internal info becomes open to the public.
2006---18.4% of total C6 production
2007---20.1% of total C6 production
2008---21.9% of total C6 production
2009---20.4% of total C6 production, even with another model introduced to syphon off some of it's sales(the ZR1), and the economy going into a downward spin.
Let's wait and see how the sales of the C7 Z06 is doing when it completes four years of production and another high performance model is introduced into the line up(ZR1 equivalent) and then a lower priced model(GS equivalent) in introduced into the line up.
What we didn't know in 2006, 2007, 2008 and 2009, was that there was a problem with wornout(from what ever cause) valve guides, and dropping exhaust valves.
I don't think GM will let it get to the point where "discovery" is allowed. They will settle before that(if a judge doesn't throw it out of court before that point). GM doesn't want their dirty laundry aired in public.
Last edited by JoesC5; 10-24-2015 at 05:52 PM.
#224
Team Owner
Thread Starter
Got my letter from the law firm today. It stated that the the nation wide class action has been filed against GM and that GM is in the process of being served. A response from GM is expected in about a month.
DH
DH
The following 4 users liked this post by Dirty Howie:
#226
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Sep 2006
Location: Louisville Ky NCM Lifetime Member 429 (Member Since 1993)
Posts: 3,258
Received 261 Likes
on
182 Posts
St. Jude Donor '12-'13, '16
So, you have had to pay no legal fees to have the suit filed?
Have you asked the law firm about GM'S first legal defense, which is they filed for bankruptcy?
Unless it can be "proved" in court (by means of emails, memos, letters, etc.) from within GM that they were intentionally covering up a product defect (basically, I may be wrong but I believe it has to be proved they knowingly committed fraud), otherwise any liability from a lawsuit such as this will be considered as part of the normal course of business, and in bankruptcy law would discharge GM from any liability.
Now if the attorneys filed the lawsuit in the hopes that GM would settle out of court to avoid the embarrassment and cost of resources of a lawsuit consumes, I wish you luck, but you never know. I am very interested in how this procedes.
Good luck!
Have you asked the law firm about GM'S first legal defense, which is they filed for bankruptcy?
Unless it can be "proved" in court (by means of emails, memos, letters, etc.) from within GM that they were intentionally covering up a product defect (basically, I may be wrong but I believe it has to be proved they knowingly committed fraud), otherwise any liability from a lawsuit such as this will be considered as part of the normal course of business, and in bankruptcy law would discharge GM from any liability.
Now if the attorneys filed the lawsuit in the hopes that GM would settle out of court to avoid the embarrassment and cost of resources of a lawsuit consumes, I wish you luck, but you never know. I am very interested in how this procedes.
Good luck!
#227
I'm thinking I should join this suit but i'm not sure if it will help me, however, if it helps someone else then I'm in. 08 dropped a valve, warranty work denied because car had a tune on it.
#229
Drifting
So, you have had to pay no legal fees to have the suit filed?
Have you asked the law firm about GM'S first legal defense, which is they filed for bankruptcy?
Unless it can be "proved" in court (by means of emails, memos, letters, etc.) from within GM that they were intentionally covering up a product defect (basically, I may be wrong but I believe it has to be proved they knowingly committed fraud), otherwise any liability from a lawsuit such as this will be considered as part of the normal course of business, and in bankruptcy law would discharge GM from any liability.
Now if the attorneys filed the lawsuit in the hopes that GM would settle out of court to avoid the embarrassment and cost of resources of a lawsuit consumes, I wish you luck, but you never know. I am very interested in how this procedes.
Good luck!
Have you asked the law firm about GM'S first legal defense, which is they filed for bankruptcy?
Unless it can be "proved" in court (by means of emails, memos, letters, etc.) from within GM that they were intentionally covering up a product defect (basically, I may be wrong but I believe it has to be proved they knowingly committed fraud), otherwise any liability from a lawsuit such as this will be considered as part of the normal course of business, and in bankruptcy law would discharge GM from any liability.
Now if the attorneys filed the lawsuit in the hopes that GM would settle out of court to avoid the embarrassment and cost of resources of a lawsuit consumes, I wish you luck, but you never know. I am very interested in how this procedes.
Good luck!
#230
Melting Slicks
The law firm shoulders all the costs win or lose. There is plenty of evidence of the problem, we have plenty of ammunition to back it up. That's all I can say, if GM is smart they will settle out of court, or have another black eye in the media on top of the ignition switch suit and the lovely new C7 Z06 issues, the Corvette Brand will tarnish if they do not step up to the plate and do what is right.
Honestly there isn't enough here to damage GM or cause a media frenzy about this. Its a high end sports car made for people with excess cash to spend on a toy. The public will feel as bad as they would if a defect was announced about a Bugatti. "Oh poor them"
Sorry, just my take on the situation. Sell it or fix it. Even if settlement is reached noone is getting a free engine or heads. Everyone will get a check for like $37 after all is said and done. Possibly a recall on late model engines. Everyone older than 2012 will get nothing but a small settlement check. How do you think they will handle the settlement? Original owners only? 2nd and 3rd and 4th hand owners of the same vehicle will profit as well. So many potential issues with this since these cars have so much overturn in owners.
Sorry, there are things to put your energy into it, but this isn't it. People just need to move on. GM's bankruptcy will be its protection and that will be that.
Last edited by propain; 10-24-2015 at 10:08 PM.
The following users liked this post:
wukyone (11-12-2015)
#231
Team Owner
Thread Starter
So, you have had to pay no legal fees to have the suit filed?
Have you asked the law firm about GM'S first legal defense, which is they filed for bankruptcy?
Unless it can be "proved" in court (by means of emails, memos, letters, etc.) from within GM that they were intentionally covering up a product defect (basically, I may be wrong but I believe it has to be proved they knowingly committed fraud), otherwise any liability from a lawsuit such as this will be considered as part of the normal course of business, and in bankruptcy law would discharge GM from any liability.
Now if the attorneys filed the lawsuit in the hopes that GM would settle out of court to avoid the embarrassment and cost of resources of a lawsuit consumes, I wish you luck, but you never know. I am very interested in how this procedes.
Good luck!
Have you asked the law firm about GM'S first legal defense, which is they filed for bankruptcy?
Unless it can be "proved" in court (by means of emails, memos, letters, etc.) from within GM that they were intentionally covering up a product defect (basically, I may be wrong but I believe it has to be proved they knowingly committed fraud), otherwise any liability from a lawsuit such as this will be considered as part of the normal course of business, and in bankruptcy law would discharge GM from any liability.
Now if the attorneys filed the lawsuit in the hopes that GM would settle out of court to avoid the embarrassment and cost of resources of a lawsuit consumes, I wish you luck, but you never know. I am very interested in how this procedes.
Good luck!
The law firm is fully aware of the bankrupsy and if you read the claim you will see some of the reasons that bankrpusy may not cover GM.
In addition GM recently did the Fuse Box recall and now the Clutch and did not exclude the model years before the bankrupsy.
DH
#232
Team Owner
Thread Starter
#233
Drifting
They shoulder the cost and they profit if they win. The scraps go to the owners.
Honestly there isn't enough here to damage GM or cause a media frenzy about this. Its a high end sports car made for people with excess cash to spend on a toy. The public will feel as bad as they would if a defect was announced about a Bugatti. "Oh poor them"
Sorry, just my take on the situation. Sell it or fix it. Even if settlement is reached noone is getting a free engine or heads. Everyone will get a check for like $37 after all is said and done. Possibly a recall on late model engines. Everyone older than 2012 will get nothing but a small settlement check. How do you think they will handle the settlement? Original owners only? 2nd and 3rd and 4th hand owners of the same vehicle will profit as well. So many potential issues with this since these cars have so much overturn in owners.
Sorry, there are things to put your energy into it, but this isn't it. People just need to move on. GM's bankruptcy will be its protection and that will be that.
Honestly there isn't enough here to damage GM or cause a media frenzy about this. Its a high end sports car made for people with excess cash to spend on a toy. The public will feel as bad as they would if a defect was announced about a Bugatti. "Oh poor them"
Sorry, just my take on the situation. Sell it or fix it. Even if settlement is reached noone is getting a free engine or heads. Everyone will get a check for like $37 after all is said and done. Possibly a recall on late model engines. Everyone older than 2012 will get nothing but a small settlement check. How do you think they will handle the settlement? Original owners only? 2nd and 3rd and 4th hand owners of the same vehicle will profit as well. So many potential issues with this since these cars have so much overturn in owners.
Sorry, there are things to put your energy into it, but this isn't it. People just need to move on. GM's bankruptcy will be its protection and that will be that.
#234
Team Owner
Agreed with Dan. At least make them pay. Owners won't be made whole, but if it cost GM $30M or something, I would be happy with that. They can't just get away with this ****. If it doesn't hit them in the pocket books they will just keep doing it.
The following 2 users liked this post by Unreal:
<<427_V8>> (10-24-2015),
AZDANZ06 (10-24-2015)
#235
Drifting
#236
Racer
The more you hold GM accountable for their actions, the better the cars in the future will be. No reason NOT to go after them when the drop the ball like this!
#237
Melting Slicks
Like I have said before, at least we are trying to do something about it with GM, much like other BS in life like our Government, do we continue to let both of them continually screw us at our expense? I could care less about the money, it's about principle at this point.
I hear you and I wish all those luck who wish to devote the precious time we have on this planet toward this goal. Life is simply too short for me to waste my time. Fix or sell is my feeling. I have too much on my plate to chase GM for the BS flaws in their manufacturing QC. Been around too long to know this is not something that will be resolved quickly.
But since were talking about it, I see many including yourself saying they want this to settle out of court to avoid GM getting egg on their face publicly and damaging their brand. How will this improve GM products in the future? It wont. Its simply hush money. Those willing to accept and out of court monetary settlement so GM avoids public scrutiny are doing nothing to better the quality control going forward. They are just simply looking to get money for their loss. So come on... its nothing to do with getting a better product down the road. Its everything to do with compensation.
Just sayin...
Last edited by propain; 10-25-2015 at 01:39 AM.
#238
Team Owner
They shoulder the cost and they profit if they win. The scraps go to the owners.
Honestly there isn't enough here to damage GM or cause a media frenzy about this. Its a high end sports car made for people with excess cash to spend on a toy. The public will feel as bad as they would if a defect was announced about a Bugatti. "Oh poor them"
Sorry, just my take on the situation. Sell it or fix it. Even if settlement is reached noone is getting a free engine or heads. Everyone will get a check for like $37 after all is said and done. Possibly a recall on late model engines. Everyone older than 2012 will get nothing but a small settlement check. How do you think they will handle the settlement? Original owners only? 2nd and 3rd and 4th hand owners of the same vehicle will profit as well. So many potential issues with this since these cars have so much overturn in owners.
Sorry, there are things to put your energy into it, but this isn't it. People just need to move on. GM's bankruptcy will be its protection and that will be that.
Honestly there isn't enough here to damage GM or cause a media frenzy about this. Its a high end sports car made for people with excess cash to spend on a toy. The public will feel as bad as they would if a defect was announced about a Bugatti. "Oh poor them"
Sorry, just my take on the situation. Sell it or fix it. Even if settlement is reached noone is getting a free engine or heads. Everyone will get a check for like $37 after all is said and done. Possibly a recall on late model engines. Everyone older than 2012 will get nothing but a small settlement check. How do you think they will handle the settlement? Original owners only? 2nd and 3rd and 4th hand owners of the same vehicle will profit as well. So many potential issues with this since these cars have so much overturn in owners.
Sorry, there are things to put your energy into it, but this isn't it. People just need to move on. GM's bankruptcy will be its protection and that will be that.
#239
To the people that are saying the end result is not worth their time/ efforts/resources?
Really? Are you serious?
If someone is doing something wrong you will only speak up/ take action if it is worth your time ? Perhaps I misunderstood?
Maybe I was cut from a different cloth. Kudos to the ones that got this lawsuit going.
Holding manufactuors accountable is extremenly important. This defect issue is real. However it doesn't directly affect every zo6 owner but it does affect a substantial number and the defect does have the potential of killing someone.
What is wrong with people now a days? What is wrong with saying ...hey we goofed.. We are sorry... but we will fix it. Usually if that is said people work with each other, Lieing , denying and hiding usually just makes it much worse. Step up GM. Just say " aw dammit we screwed up... How can we fix this zo6 owners?" Can you imagine how GM's creditability, it's imagine and it's sales would soar. Long term goals are much more important.
Really? Are you serious?
If someone is doing something wrong you will only speak up/ take action if it is worth your time ? Perhaps I misunderstood?
Maybe I was cut from a different cloth. Kudos to the ones that got this lawsuit going.
Holding manufactuors accountable is extremenly important. This defect issue is real. However it doesn't directly affect every zo6 owner but it does affect a substantial number and the defect does have the potential of killing someone.
What is wrong with people now a days? What is wrong with saying ...hey we goofed.. We are sorry... but we will fix it. Usually if that is said people work with each other, Lieing , denying and hiding usually just makes it much worse. Step up GM. Just say " aw dammit we screwed up... How can we fix this zo6 owners?" Can you imagine how GM's creditability, it's imagine and it's sales would soar. Long term goals are much more important.
The following 2 users liked this post by olddragger:
bambihunter (10-25-2015),
CTYANK2 (10-26-2015)
#240
Team Owner
Luckily Dan took on the effort, and the other 99.9% of us just sit back and relax. The work is done, there is nothing to do now but sit back and wait. Not that hard to do.