[Z06] Wiggle Test Done Today At Dealer- Results As Expected
#101
Wow, I've been away from the forum for a while due to illness and slowly making my way back and man, this entire heads/valves issue remains and its bigger now vs. previous
I am glad to see that more and more folks started to listen and are doing something about it.
I can recall a few years back when I publicly brought up this issue and got a royal corvette forum beating for it, even from other vendors...well, now what?
Oh well, no need to throw any pies on any faces - glad to see that at least some dealerships are doing something about it; at least for those who have remaining GM warranties. If you don't have any type of warranty or any type of powertrain protection then DO NOT chance it There are way too many offers out there that will fix you up and erase those worries away.
Thanks,
Carlos
I am glad to see that more and more folks started to listen and are doing something about it.
I can recall a few years back when I publicly brought up this issue and got a royal corvette forum beating for it, even from other vendors...well, now what?
Oh well, no need to throw any pies on any faces - glad to see that at least some dealerships are doing something about it; at least for those who have remaining GM warranties. If you don't have any type of warranty or any type of powertrain protection then DO NOT chance it There are way too many offers out there that will fix you up and erase those worries away.
Thanks,
Carlos
Last edited by z0sicktanner; 03-24-2013 at 01:37 AM.
#102
Wow, I've been away from the forum for a while due to illness and slowly making my way back and man, this entire heads/valves issue remains and its bigger now vs. previous
I am glad to see that more and more folks started to listen and are doing something about it.
I can recall a few years back when I publicly brought up this issue and got a royal corvette forum beating for it, even from other vendors...well, now what?
Oh well, no need to throw any pies on any faces - glad to see that at least some dealerships are doing something about it; at least for those who have remaining GM warranties. If you don't have any type of warranty or any type of powertrain protection then DO NOT chance it There are way too many offers out there that will fix you up and erase those worries away.
Thanks,
Carlos
I am glad to see that more and more folks started to listen and are doing something about it.
I can recall a few years back when I publicly brought up this issue and got a royal corvette forum beating for it, even from other vendors...well, now what?
Oh well, no need to throw any pies on any faces - glad to see that at least some dealerships are doing something about it; at least for those who have remaining GM warranties. If you don't have any type of warranty or any type of powertrain protection then DO NOT chance it There are way too many offers out there that will fix you up and erase those worries away.
Thanks,
Carlos
#103
Burning Brakes
Now that's what I'm talking about. Probably the best post I have seen in here in a LONG, LONG, time.
This is getting information straight from the horse's mouth from the service manager (who is a hardcore gearhead) of a huge dealership in CA, and a 100% stand up guy, whose dealership has serviced countless LS7 Powered C6 Zs (and only seen 2 failures on stock vehicles b/c of valve failure). I totally agree with Rich that the problem is WAY overblown on the internet, just like any other problem is blown way out of proportion on the internet.
GREAT post Rich, you are a true assett to the C6 Z forum!
This is getting information straight from the horse's mouth from the service manager (who is a hardcore gearhead) of a huge dealership in CA, and a 100% stand up guy, whose dealership has serviced countless LS7 Powered C6 Zs (and only seen 2 failures on stock vehicles b/c of valve failure). I totally agree with Rich that the problem is WAY overblown on the internet, just like any other problem is blown way out of proportion on the internet.
GREAT post Rich, you are a true assett to the C6 Z forum!
#104
Race Director
Thread Starter
Just a quick update. I picked up the car this morning. Rich and his crew only needed it for about 2 work days, and that includes sending the heads out to a specialty shop where they assemble them and mate the valves to the seats. It was ready yesterday morning but I couldn't travel until today. I feel sorry for the folks who have their car hung up, sometimes for many weeks, at a dealership for the same work or less. The process for giving the car to them and getting it back was streamlined and seamless. If not for talking to Rich for a few minutes today, I would have been driving away in 5-10 minutes max, including the return of the rental car. By the way, his Z06 was on a lift getting prepped for his autocross season- sweeeet ride! I saw some aftermarket suspension bits, which will be joined by more soon, and some tires that probably shouldn't be used on the street.
I won't throw out any numbers here because Rich gave me only a ballpark idea. He didn't have the final paperwork with him (my paperwork just had a bunch of zeros on it), but I'll just say that the GMPP extended warranty has paid for itself by a ton. In addition to the heads, I did have the oil pan gasket replaced under warranty too. The car actually made it all the way home without dropping a valve or developing a noisy valve train. Just lucky I guess. It runs great and hopefully it will do so for a very long time.
Rich, thanks again to you and your crew. We're lucky to have you guys here in NorCal.
I won't throw out any numbers here because Rich gave me only a ballpark idea. He didn't have the final paperwork with him (my paperwork just had a bunch of zeros on it), but I'll just say that the GMPP extended warranty has paid for itself by a ton. In addition to the heads, I did have the oil pan gasket replaced under warranty too. The car actually made it all the way home without dropping a valve or developing a noisy valve train. Just lucky I guess. It runs great and hopefully it will do so for a very long time.
Rich, thanks again to you and your crew. We're lucky to have you guys here in NorCal.
#105
Safety Car
A valve may not break because it is .0050, but mine at about that clearance sure looked like someone was at them with a cutting torch near the base of the guide. And you could feel the wear on the valve.
On the plus side, I have a nice arrangement for next valentines day
On the plus side, I have a nice arrangement for next valentines day
Last edited by jedblanks; 03-27-2013 at 03:19 PM.
#106
Race Director
Thread Starter
A valve may not break because it is .0050, but mine at about that clearance sure looked like someone was at them with a cutting torch near the base of the guide. And you could feel the wear on the valve.
On the plus side, I have a nice arrangement for next valentines day
On the plus side, I have a nice arrangement for next valentines day
#108
Jed, those pics didn't work for me but I would like to see them. FYI, Rich said that the shop that they use mics the valves at top, center, and bottom in relation to the guide- they are actually marked while within the guide to make sure they measure the right spots. In all the LS7s they've replaced heads on, they have found only 1 valve that was out of spec- by .0002 IIRC. Piecing together a couple of conversations, it sounds to me like the valves are harder than the guides and therefore they don't tend to take the hit as much. I wish I could have a few minutes with the guy at that shop to pick his brain.
Last edited by z0sicktanner; 03-27-2013 at 12:00 AM.
#109
Race Director
Thread Starter
Thanks John.
I take no offense to what you said. I don't have all the answers by any stretch, nor have I ever claimed to. I can only try to put out things as I hear them. It's up to you, and anybody else who's interested, to decide what they believe. Your vids opened my eyes and, in fact, I think I stood up for you once when the chit started to fly.
I can say this- I made a living for almost 30 years figuring out who was lying and who was telling the truth. I got pretty good at it. I've seen or heard nothing from Rich that would cause me the least bit of concern about anything he's said. I'm doing the best I can to relay whatever I think might help others here. Anybody who has the proof of what the problem is- please stop holding back and put it out here for all of us. So far that hasn't happened. Rich doesn't claim to know what the source of the problem is and I believe him. I also have a hard time picturing why he would tell me my valves are good when they aren't. If he was motivated by money, he'd be able to make more of it by adding the cost of new valves to the warranty claim. Then there's the problem of hurting his reputation and that of Abel Chevrolet by putting out a product (work) that could come back to haunt him if the parts fail. That just doesn't make sense to me.
I can say this- I made a living for almost 30 years figuring out who was lying and who was telling the truth. I got pretty good at it. I've seen or heard nothing from Rich that would cause me the least bit of concern about anything he's said. I'm doing the best I can to relay whatever I think might help others here. Anybody who has the proof of what the problem is- please stop holding back and put it out here for all of us. So far that hasn't happened. Rich doesn't claim to know what the source of the problem is and I believe him. I also have a hard time picturing why he would tell me my valves are good when they aren't. If he was motivated by money, he'd be able to make more of it by adding the cost of new valves to the warranty claim. Then there's the problem of hurting his reputation and that of Abel Chevrolet by putting out a product (work) that could come back to haunt him if the parts fail. That just doesn't make sense to me.
#110
Thanks John.
I take no offense to what you said. I don't have all the answers by any stretch, nor have I ever claimed to. I can only try to put out things as I hear them. It's up to you, and anybody else who's interested, to decide what they believe. Your vids opened my eyes and, in fact, I think I stood up for you once when the chit started to fly.
I can say this- I made a living for almost 30 years figuring out who was lying and who was telling the truth. I got pretty good at it. I've seen or heard nothing from Rich that would cause me the least bit of concern about anything he's said. I'm doing the best I can to relay whatever I think might help others here. Anybody who has the proof of what the problem is- please stop holding back and put it out here for all of us. So far that hasn't happened. Rich doesn't claim to know what the source of the problem is and I believe him. I also have a hard time picturing why he would tell me my valves are good when they aren't. If he was motivated by money, he'd be able to make more of it by adding the cost of new valves to the warranty claim. Then there's the problem of hurting his reputation and that of Abel Chevrolet by putting out a product (work) that could come back to haunt him if the parts fail. That just doesn't make sense to me.
I take no offense to what you said. I don't have all the answers by any stretch, nor have I ever claimed to. I can only try to put out things as I hear them. It's up to you, and anybody else who's interested, to decide what they believe. Your vids opened my eyes and, in fact, I think I stood up for you once when the chit started to fly.
I can say this- I made a living for almost 30 years figuring out who was lying and who was telling the truth. I got pretty good at it. I've seen or heard nothing from Rich that would cause me the least bit of concern about anything he's said. I'm doing the best I can to relay whatever I think might help others here. Anybody who has the proof of what the problem is- please stop holding back and put it out here for all of us. So far that hasn't happened. Rich doesn't claim to know what the source of the problem is and I believe him. I also have a hard time picturing why he would tell me my valves are good when they aren't. If he was motivated by money, he'd be able to make more of it by adding the cost of new valves to the warranty claim. Then there's the problem of hurting his reputation and that of Abel Chevrolet by putting out a product (work) that could come back to haunt him if the parts fail. That just doesn't make sense to me.
#111
Team Owner
Member Since: Apr 2001
Location: Elmhurst, IL (West Suburb of Chicago) & Home of MEGA Horsepower
Posts: 26,714
Received 584 Likes
on
399 Posts
St. Jude Donor '06
Les,
Great news, and man you are lucky to have the services of Richie Rich and his dealership (Abel Chevrolet) at your services.
Best of luck with your fixed heads.
I think maybe part of the confusion with Z06tanner's statement is the difference between a valve being out of spec. and the valve guides (which is 2 different things, right?) I don't know, just taking a wild shot in dark regarding what the confusion might be here, but sure wish Abel Chevrolet was in driving distance from me (for future warrany work as I have 2.5 years left on my GMPP on my 2006 Z).
Great news, and man you are lucky to have the services of Richie Rich and his dealership (Abel Chevrolet) at your services.
Best of luck with your fixed heads.
I think maybe part of the confusion with Z06tanner's statement is the difference between a valve being out of spec. and the valve guides (which is 2 different things, right?) I don't know, just taking a wild shot in dark regarding what the confusion might be here, but sure wish Abel Chevrolet was in driving distance from me (for future warrany work as I have 2.5 years left on my GMPP on my 2006 Z).
Last edited by Mopar Jimmy; 03-28-2013 at 02:52 AM.
#112
Les,
Great news, and man you are lucky to have the services of Richie Rich and his dealership (Abel Chevrolet) at your services.
Best of luck with your fixed heads.
I think maybe part of the confusion with Z06tanner's statement is the difference between a valve being out of spec. and the valve stem (which is 2 different things, right? I don't know, just taking a wild shot in dark regarding what the confusion might be here).
Great news, and man you are lucky to have the services of Richie Rich and his dealership (Abel Chevrolet) at your services.
Best of luck with your fixed heads.
I think maybe part of the confusion with Z06tanner's statement is the difference between a valve being out of spec. and the valve stem (which is 2 different things, right? I don't know, just taking a wild shot in dark regarding what the confusion might be here).
#114
Instructor
Member Since: Feb 2013
Location: Dallas Texas
Posts: 202
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
St. Jude Donor '13
Corvette noob here
Is there a test to know if my engine is running in harmony? I am a perfectionist and would like to knowIif the internals are slightly off. What is the official name of a test that tests cylinder by cylinder to tell you if compression, lift, or other internal functions are out of place
For reference I have a 2002 base model.
Thanks for the post. It helped to get me to think about engine internal performance.
Is there a test to know if my engine is running in harmony? I am a perfectionist and would like to knowIif the internals are slightly off. What is the official name of a test that tests cylinder by cylinder to tell you if compression, lift, or other internal functions are out of place
For reference I have a 2002 base model.
Thanks for the post. It helped to get me to think about engine internal performance.
#115
I will say that I wouldn't reuse an LS7 exhaust valve based on micrometer measurements alone... I'd want some high magnification examination of the stem for galling.
As someone else noted, the guides are wearing out, not the valve stems (other than being abused), so maybe we have a terminology misunderstanding.
The photo jedblanks posted (below) didn't look all that bad to me, compared to some I've seen... the guides were clearly not worn badly enough to let soot get up inside the guide, which probably leads to the galling (soot or coked oil or whatever).
Last edited by Mark2009; 03-27-2013 at 08:36 AM. Reason: added jedblanks valve photo
#116
I measured eight used valves and didn't find any "out of spec" as far as diameter goes. Of course many of them showed galling on the lower portion of the stem which made them worthless, but the diameter was okay. The heads those valves came out of had lower guide wear in the double digits.
I will say that I wouldn't reuse an LS7 exhaust valve based on micrometer measurements alone... I'd want some high magnification examination of the stem for galling.
As someone else noted, the guides are wearing out, not the valve stems (other than being abused), so maybe we have a terminology misunderstanding.
The photo jedblanks posted (below) didn't look all that bad to me, compared to some I've seen... the guides were clearly not worn badly enough to let soot get up inside the guide, which probably leads to the galling (soot or coked oil or whatever).
I will say that I wouldn't reuse an LS7 exhaust valve based on micrometer measurements alone... I'd want some high magnification examination of the stem for galling.
As someone else noted, the guides are wearing out, not the valve stems (other than being abused), so maybe we have a terminology misunderstanding.
The photo jedblanks posted (below) didn't look all that bad to me, compared to some I've seen... the guides were clearly not worn badly enough to let soot get up inside the guide, which probably leads to the galling (soot or coked oil or whatever).
But to your part in red above, interesting, and I wonder if any such examination is being done before those who are reusing these exhaust valves in new heads, decide to use them.
I came into a set of used MY 2006 OEM LS7 exhaust valves a while back. They had 31K miles when removed, and the exhaust guides were all out of spec in the lower portion of the guide from .0074 to .0141. The middle of the guides were within service spec, and the top of the guides were within spec except for one guide.
Last edited by '06 Quicksilver Z06; 03-27-2013 at 11:37 AM.
#117
Instructor
My dealer Corvette service specialist thought they were fine initially and could be reused, I couldn't see the galling either without the microsope, with the microsope the damage looked like flaking chrome plating.
I went with new exhaust valves on my rebuilt cylinder heads.
#118
Corvette noob here
Is there a test to know if my engine is running in harmony? I am a perfectionist and would like to know if the internals are slightly off. What is the official name of a test that tests cylinder by cylinder to tell you if compression, lift, or other internal functions are out of place
For reference I have a 2002 base model.
Thanks for the post. It helped to get me to think about engine internal performance.
Is there a test to know if my engine is running in harmony? I am a perfectionist and would like to know if the internals are slightly off. What is the official name of a test that tests cylinder by cylinder to tell you if compression, lift, or other internal functions are out of place
For reference I have a 2002 base model.
Thanks for the post. It helped to get me to think about engine internal performance.
1. Compression test. A pressure gauge is connected to each cylinder's spark plug hole in turn and the engine is cranked over a few times. This will give a general indication of the condition of the rings and cylinder walls.
2. Leak down test. Again a pressure gauge is connected to each cylinder's spark plug hole, but this time air pressure is fed in externally and the engine is not cranked over. How much air leaks out determines condition of rings and wall as well as valves (sealing).
Pretty much any shop should be able to do both tests.
Neither will determine camshaft condition (lift) or guide wear (unless perhaps you have a leaky valve). Note that I am not an expert or professional mechanic so details could be lacking or overlooked, and there may be other tests available (fuel pressure, for one).
A chassis dyno test can tell you a lot as long as the dyno operator is monitoring live data (knock retard, timing, air fuel ratio, etc).
Also the science of 'reading' spark plugs is almost an art; experienced pros can tell you a lot about an engine just by looking at the plugs.
#119
I agree. I inspected my replaced 6000 mile Ls7 exhaust valves with my stereo microscope and noticed galling damage.
My dealer Corvette service specialist thought they were fine initially and could be reused, I couldn't see the galling either without the microsope, with the microsope the damage looked like flaking chrome plating.
I went with new exhaust valves on my rebuilt cylinder heads.
My dealer Corvette service specialist thought they were fine initially and could be reused, I couldn't see the galling either without the microsope, with the microsope the damage looked like flaking chrome plating.
I went with new exhaust valves on my rebuilt cylinder heads.
#120
Melting Slicks
I found it most interesting that Rich said the reason he ended up with ss valves in his heads was due to a misunderstanding, he did NOT want them and will be replacing them shortly...speaks volumes to me, but then that's only because I have a great deal of respect for Rich.
Cheers, Paul.
Cheers, Paul.