[Z06] Z06 VS ZR1 Same RWH - Who Wins?
#81
Melting Slicks
Cheers, Paul.
#82
Le Mans Master
#85
#86
Intermediate
Member Since: Nov 2010
Location: Columbia MD
Posts: 37
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
As many previous posts have stated, there are too many variables for a truly objective analysis. I will however forward this bit of info as fodder for comparison. Car & Driver's annual Lightning Lap runs - pits stock vehicles driven by same drivers on the same track; a relative test of a stock vs. stock car on a given track. The most recent run (check the list here: http://www.caranddriver.com/features...to_2011_page_8) featured a new Z06 with the Z07 package, which ran the lap in 2:53.5; a ZR1 tested a year prior, ran the lap in 2:49.8. Granted, there are plenty of variables here (n/a vs blown, tires, suspension differences, weight, brakes...etc), but given the 132hp advantage the ZR1 enjoys, for track work (road course), the times seem awfully close... so to further a relative, somewhat subjective comparison - like rwhp bet. both cars in this example, seems to favor the Z06.
#87
#88
Tech Contributor
Member Since: Mar 1999
Location: Northern VA
Posts: 10,089
Received 3,842 Likes
on
1,158 Posts
"Ask Tadge" Producer
- Mass
- Engine aspiration
The Z07-equipped Z06 has the same suspension, brakes, and tires as the ZR1.
What would be more interesting would be another test of the 2010+ ZR1 with the PTM activated, vs. the 2009 they tested originally.
jas
#89
Pro
Well that's is not the story here in P.R.... Like I said I race (bolt on Z 517whp) my buddy's tuned ZR1 (576whp) and went head to head on mexico... I have another buddy with a modded ZR1 (712whp) and with a good driver did 11.0@133 vs another buddy that have a cammed Z06 (543whp) and did 11.0@131 (same night).
That same ZR1 with the same good driver went to a road course and did best lap of 1.30 sec. Vs the same cammed Z06 that did the best lap on 1.28 sec. the same day.
That's are the facts, no expeculation no assumtion... I have vids of races on the drag strip and road course if any want to see it. So can anyone explain that to me? Oh and don't star comparing times with MIR or other US road courses, everybody knows that no tracks are equals. I compared both on same tracks and with good drivers.
That same ZR1 with the same good driver went to a road course and did best lap of 1.30 sec. Vs the same cammed Z06 that did the best lap on 1.28 sec. the same day.
That's are the facts, no expeculation no assumtion... I have vids of races on the drag strip and road course if any want to see it. So can anyone explain that to me? Oh and don't star comparing times with MIR or other US road courses, everybody knows that no tracks are equals. I compared both on same tracks and with good drivers.
Scott
#90
Pro
[QUOTE=LEAVINU;1577025919]I wouldn't call a "good driver" someone who can only run 133mph in a 712rwhp ZR1 and get beat by a Z06 on the road course by 2 full secs. QUOTE]
You are absolutely right on. I believe the Lingenfelter zr1 with similar HP was in the low 10s or upper 9s in the 1/4 at a speed of 145 mph.
Scott
You are absolutely right on. I believe the Lingenfelter zr1 with similar HP was in the low 10s or upper 9s in the 1/4 at a speed of 145 mph.
Scott
#91
Pro
Just curious.
Scott
#92
Pro
As many previous posts have stated, there are too many variables for a truly objective analysis. I will however forward this bit of info as fodder for comparison. Car & Driver's annual Lightning Lap runs - pits stock vehicles driven by same drivers on the same track; a relative test of a stock vs. stock car on a given track. The most recent run (check the list here: http://www.caranddriver.com/features...to_2011_page_8) featured a new Z06 with the Z07 package, which ran the lap in 2:53.5; a ZR1 tested a year prior, ran the lap in 2:49.8. Granted, there are plenty of variables here (n/a vs blown, tires, suspension differences, weight, brakes...etc), but given the 132hp advantage the ZR1 enjoys, for track work (road course), the times seem awfully close... so to further a relative, somewhat subjective comparison - like rwhp bet. both cars in this example, seems to favor the Z06.
Scott
#93
Former Vendor
Who cares, both cars are great in their own right.
The ZR1 has plenty of potential and yes, it is heavier but all being equal, the ZR1 would come out on top due to torque albeit very close race.
Many have asked me if the extra cash for the ZR1 is worth it over the Z06 and my answer is always this: "It all depends on what you consider valuable to you". If looks, uniqueness, newer technology, brakes and so on are your thing then yes, the ZR1 is your ticket.
It has been our experience around these necks of the woods at the tracks, road course and mexico when all stock, the ZR1 pulls ahead but not by much. However, repeated runs changes things for the worse on the ZR1 in a very dramatic fashion and after dyno'ing a few of them I realized why...the supercharger and the ECU do not like each other very much when heat climbs.
This Texas heat does a number to those ZR1 machines; any forced induction platform will be more finicky to heat vs. an N/A application. When the HP levels are equaled out, it is easy to predict a winner if all being equal (driver, traction, tires and track)…the Z06! Manny of my ZR1 customers make the switch to E85; this stops all the harassments from those lightly modded Z06’s. A tuned ZR1, with pulleys, exhaust and E85 changes the game dramatically for the better. AND when the ZR1 gets meaner (heads, cams, boost-a-pump and bigger injectors) the game is really over…I called this my Machismo package.
Hope this helps
Thanks,
Carlos
The ZR1 has plenty of potential and yes, it is heavier but all being equal, the ZR1 would come out on top due to torque albeit very close race.
Many have asked me if the extra cash for the ZR1 is worth it over the Z06 and my answer is always this: "It all depends on what you consider valuable to you". If looks, uniqueness, newer technology, brakes and so on are your thing then yes, the ZR1 is your ticket.
It has been our experience around these necks of the woods at the tracks, road course and mexico when all stock, the ZR1 pulls ahead but not by much. However, repeated runs changes things for the worse on the ZR1 in a very dramatic fashion and after dyno'ing a few of them I realized why...the supercharger and the ECU do not like each other very much when heat climbs.
This Texas heat does a number to those ZR1 machines; any forced induction platform will be more finicky to heat vs. an N/A application. When the HP levels are equaled out, it is easy to predict a winner if all being equal (driver, traction, tires and track)…the Z06! Manny of my ZR1 customers make the switch to E85; this stops all the harassments from those lightly modded Z06’s. A tuned ZR1, with pulleys, exhaust and E85 changes the game dramatically for the better. AND when the ZR1 gets meaner (heads, cams, boost-a-pump and bigger injectors) the game is really over…I called this my Machismo package.
Hope this helps
Thanks,
Carlos
#95
Melting Slicks
You guys make me laugh with your heroes.Those wicked times are always run at a prepped track so lets see them happen at a regular track or simply hand him someone else s z06 and see if the times are so amazing i d really be curious.The rest of the world has to run good year run flats to be recognized but for others a prepped track is not an advantage.Makes me laugh.You guys bought a z06 for gods sake instaed of beeing a spectator learn how to drive it properly.
#96
their was already a guy on here who posted a vid of his cam & bolt on z pullin a stock zr1 from a roll. do a you tube search:
2010 ZR-1 vs Heads Cam C6 Z06 vs YSI Cams 04 Cobra
2010 ZR-1 vs Heads Cam C6 Z06 vs YSI Cams 04 Cobra
Last edited by FNQWK; 03-19-2011 at 05:51 AM.
#97
Instructor
Member Since: Nov 2004
Location: daphne alabama
Posts: 133
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Not exactly same RWHP for one. the zr1 had 200 miles on it. it made 510 on the same dyno the z06 made 570. as for the race the zr1 hit rev limiter in third on the first run and backed out. the second run was much closer and the zr1 was shifting at 5500 due to the mileage on the car and hitting rev limiter the first time. i was the one driving so i know. and i know what h/c z06's can do, i have had 3 of them and have been to the track and run 10's. all in all i would still say the z06 will have a slight advantage with same whp but would be very close.
#98
Drifting
[QUOTE=ZR1Gerhardt;1577087340]
Excuses, excuses... I post proof, videos of same date and track. Don't bring LP or rager driving skills
I wouldn't call a "good driver" someone who can only run 133mph in a 712rwhp ZR1 and get beat by a Z06 on the road course by 2 full secs. QUOTE]
You are absolutely right on. I believe the Lingenfelter zr1 with similar HP was in the low 10s or upper 9s in the 1/4 at a speed of 145 mph.
Scott
You are absolutely right on. I believe the Lingenfelter zr1 with similar HP was in the low 10s or upper 9s in the 1/4 at a speed of 145 mph.
Scott
Excuses, excuses... I post proof, videos of same date and track. Don't bring LP or rager driving skills
#99
Pro
[QUOTE=WhiteSneaky-PR;1577101545]
I call him a bad driver. Here is the link of the record 10.6.. 1/4 mile run in a ZR1 with slicks and 10.74.. with stock tires. Three videos for you to watch. I now it is from the ZR1 forum and you appear to ignore anything posted there.
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/c6-c...d-10-66-a.html
Plenty of other posts in that forum of most stock cars in the 10s, if you care to take the time and educate yourself.
Look at the Nurbring, a course that takes everything into consideration (lots of turns and one long straight away). If you upped the Z06 power to the ZR1 (without changing anything else) it would not make up the 23 second differential (zr1 7:23 - Z06 - 7:46). It would not brake, handle or turn as well as the ZR1.
Scott
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/c6-c...d-10-66-a.html
Plenty of other posts in that forum of most stock cars in the 10s, if you care to take the time and educate yourself.
Look at the Nurbring, a course that takes everything into consideration (lots of turns and one long straight away). If you upped the Z06 power to the ZR1 (without changing anything else) it would not make up the 23 second differential (zr1 7:23 - Z06 - 7:46). It would not brake, handle or turn as well as the ZR1.
Scott
#100
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Oct 2007
Location: East Hampton Connecticut
Posts: 2,123
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
St. Jude Donor '09-'10-'11
But yes, the facts do support your statement....