Edlebrock supercharger
#1
Edlebrock supercharger
I am considering putting an Edlebrock supercharger in my stock 2007 C6. Has anyone done this. If so:
1. How difficult
2. Pros and cons
3. Did it impact reliability
4. How much did it impact gas mileage
5. Did it increase the under hood noise
1. How difficult
2. Pros and cons
3. Did it impact reliability
4. How much did it impact gas mileage
5. Did it increase the under hood noise
#3
There are detailed installation instructions on the Edelbrock site. Not for the timid. But if you're an experienced mechanic, with proper tools and work area you won't have any trouble.
#4
Otherwise, here's my take on reliability - the stock hypereutectic pistons and connecting rods won't last forever under boost. If reliability is important to you, sit down and think this all the way through. Nobody cares about your car as much as you do, so take the following with a grain of salt: "you can make XXXrwhp safely! I am!"
A hypereutectic piston is an internal combustion engine piston cast using a hypereutectic alloy–that is, a metallic alloy which has a composition beyond the eutectic point. Hypereutectic pistons are made of an aluminum alloy which has much more silicon present than is soluble in aluminum at the operating temperature.
[...]
The biggest drawback of adding silicon to pistons is that the piston becomes more brittle as the ratio of silicon is added. This makes the piston more susceptible to cracking if the engine experiences pre-ignition or detonation.
[...]
The biggest drawback of adding silicon to pistons is that the piston becomes more brittle as the ratio of silicon is added. This makes the piston more susceptible to cracking if the engine experiences pre-ignition or detonation.
Some honest brutality: don't think you'll be the exception and your boosted engine will last a hundred thousand miles. If you don't want to be embarrassed calling a tow truck at 2am because your engine blew (personal experience), plan out your whole build from the bottom up. After that, my saying became "not building a car from the ground up to handle the power you want to make is like Reverse Jenga; the more you pile on, the higher the chance its going to topple over."
Things can work fine for a while, then blow up without warning. Here's a quote that probably says it best:
My LS2/L92 headed engine made 623 rwhp with 12 deg timing at peak torque and 11.5:1 afr nice and safe. Drove it for 2 months, raced it etc. Put it on the dyno last night and did half a dozen pulls tidying up the fuel map after installing new fuel pumps and it went bang after 10 runs spinning it to 7000rpm plus. Motor has 10.8:1 comp plus T trim and other bits had rod bolts in it stock rods and pistons. Motor never had detonation issues ran cold plugs very safe tune so had more in it just kept it 20 hp less then optimum. So yeah I found the limit. If I was building a motor specifically for boost i would run 9-9.5:1 comp forged pistons and rods arp bolts throughout lots of boost push the engine to the edge with the tune then back 20hp for safety and it will last. Fi u have to do things properly.
There are more people out there who have had their engine blow up than just the people that post about it on this forum. A lot of people are embarrassed it happened, or don't want the @ssholes on the board to start taking pot shots and saying "well you should have done THIS!" So instead of taking other people's crap, they opt not to post. Can't say I blame them.
#7
Race Director
Bottom line I always say with these things is if you wanna play, ya gotta pay. One of the biggest keys I think is the Tune itself..that is really going to impact how long the motor will live...that and your driving style.
Modding is always a domino effect IMO... you up the power, then you have to up the suspension or tranny to handle that extra HP it was not designed to handle from the factory.
#9
Burning Brakes
Check with the folks at Lingenfelter Performance Engineering for their input. They have quite a bit of hands on experience with adding superchargers to the LS3 engine.
Regards,
GSRANDY
Regards,
GSRANDY
#10
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Dec 2005
Location: North Western Connecticut
Posts: 7,597
Received 91 Likes
on
54 Posts
If you've already convinced yourself to go with F/I, you can disregard my post
Otherwise, here's my take on reliability - the stock hypereutectic pistons and connecting rods won't last forever under boost. If reliability is important to you, sit down and think this all the way through. Nobody cares about your car as much as you do, so take the following with a grain of salt: "you can make XXXrwhp safely! I am!"
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypereutectic_piston
Some honest brutality: don't think you'll be the exception and your boosted engine will last a hundred thousand miles. If you don't want to be embarrassed calling a tow truck at 2am because your engine blew (personal experience), plan out your whole build from the bottom up. After that, my saying became "not building a car from the ground up to handle the power you want to make is like Reverse Jenga; the more you pile on, the higher the chance its going to topple over."
Things can work fine for a while, then blow up without warning. Here's a quote that probably says it best:
From here: http://ls1tech.com/forums/11886428-post18.html
There are more people out there who have had their engine blow up than just the people that post about it on this forum. A lot of people are embarrassed it happened, or don't want the @ssholes on the board to start taking pot shots and saying "well you should have done THIS!" So instead of taking other people's crap, they opt not to post. Can't say I blame them.
Otherwise, here's my take on reliability - the stock hypereutectic pistons and connecting rods won't last forever under boost. If reliability is important to you, sit down and think this all the way through. Nobody cares about your car as much as you do, so take the following with a grain of salt: "you can make XXXrwhp safely! I am!"
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypereutectic_piston
Some honest brutality: don't think you'll be the exception and your boosted engine will last a hundred thousand miles. If you don't want to be embarrassed calling a tow truck at 2am because your engine blew (personal experience), plan out your whole build from the bottom up. After that, my saying became "not building a car from the ground up to handle the power you want to make is like Reverse Jenga; the more you pile on, the higher the chance its going to topple over."
Things can work fine for a while, then blow up without warning. Here's a quote that probably says it best:
From here: http://ls1tech.com/forums/11886428-post18.html
There are more people out there who have had their engine blow up than just the people that post about it on this forum. A lot of people are embarrassed it happened, or don't want the @ssholes on the board to start taking pot shots and saying "well you should have done THIS!" So instead of taking other people's crap, they opt not to post. Can't say I blame them.
Is it going to last as long as a stock engine? No it's not but there are plenty of bone stock engines that have also died tragic deaths! I'm running an E-Force and love the extra HP and fun it's added to driving mine. Yep it could go bang but I could get hit my a meteor too! Mine was professionally installed although Motorhead 47 has installed several with ZERO problems on engine life..... so far. I do my own tuning and have had ZERO issues with the car. It's not my DD so if it pukes.. it pukes! I'll replace the motor and move on. If folks CAN NOT afford to do that they should leave everything bone stock and be happy with the HP it came with imo.
Frankly I'd be more concerned with power train problems.. IE... clutch, rears... etc then the engine giving it up. There is certainly a limit to how much power stock components can handle but my guess (yes it's a guess based on anecdotal info) is the sweet spot is 500 to 550 rwhp. How long before there are issues.. NO ONE KNOWS but it's in direct relationship to how you drive the car if the hp isn't off the charts!
Bottom line is I'm extremely happy with my E-Force setup and after a year experienced zero problems. If it's installed correctly I believe you can have a pretty reliable car with plenty of power with proper boost....
#12
Race Director
#13
I agree with you on the rest of your post, I think you were just wanting to argue My point was not to think it's going to last forever, given the engine wasn't designed to see boost at all.
Last edited by BornSUPERCHARGED; 08-10-2011 at 02:20 PM.
#14
Burning Brakes
I agree with the professionals who do this for a living. They say that engines are a wear item. The more stress that is put on them, the shorter the lifespan. Stock, the engine should last a great while, unless you regularly track the car. Nailing it regularly also will result in more wear. Eventually, something will break. Making it more powerful just shortens the overall lifespan of the motor. Sounds pretty obvious.
#16
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Dec 2005
Location: North Western Connecticut
Posts: 7,597
Received 91 Likes
on
54 Posts
Are you seriously implying that everyone who has their engine blow up, is going to come on a forum and tell people about it? When my engine blew and I had my thread(s) going, you would be surprised how many people messaged me who have had their engine blow up too, but didn't post it.
I agree with you on the rest of your post, I think you were just wanting to argue My point was not to think it's going to last forever, given the engine wasn't designed to see boost at all.
I agree with you on the rest of your post, I think you were just wanting to argue My point was not to think it's going to last forever, given the engine wasn't designed to see boost at all.
Anyone that believes you can get 500+ rwhp for FREE is whistling past the graveyard of deceased engines. THERE ARE NO FREE LUNCHES when it comes to high performance.... Of course you can spend between 80 to 110 grand for a Z or ZR1 and get a warranty. I didn't happen to have an extra 100 grand collecting dust, DID NOT WANT USED, therefore spent around 12 grand and got a pretty fast beast that looks good to me! It's IN FACT got A LOT more RWHP then a stock Z06 and about equal to a ZR1. I could EASY get more then a ZR1 but I believe that's really begging for trouble. I realize my car is not either one of those other cars but it works just fine for me... I also turning a wrench and enjoy working on my cars.... so it's a win win!
I seldom argue... sorry you took it as such because I was simply stating a difference of opinion. I enjoy the heck out of my FI setup and believe Edlebrock makes a nice unit. If you're looking for monster numbers it's not the one to go with imo. I've had the good fortune to test mine under controlled conditions and it's plenty fast enough for me... that's all that counts really.
OP's that want to go FI should do a lot of research and be prepared for unexpected events.... if it happens it happens! My advice is have the money in hand should something go BOOM! The thing that drives me crazy is folks that mod the engine, it goes BOOM then they cry about it! If you're worried about something going wrong when modding for performance then leave it alone.. end of story...
#17
Race Director
I thought edelbrock offered a drivetrain warranty for a couple of hundred bucks.
Sure a person has to stay with their tune but for those concerned.. it makes sense
I think the edelbrock supercharger kit makes sense for those who want more power.
I drive my 190 mph top speed zero to 60 in 4.1 second stock C6 and have been laughing my @ss off for the past 3 or 4 years...
When the time comes that stops...? I'll consider an edelbrock supercharger and purposely go for the 550 flywheel hp kit because I believe it has pretty good reliability
Sure a person has to stay with their tune but for those concerned.. it makes sense
I think the edelbrock supercharger kit makes sense for those who want more power.
I drive my 190 mph top speed zero to 60 in 4.1 second stock C6 and have been laughing my @ss off for the past 3 or 4 years...
When the time comes that stops...? I'll consider an edelbrock supercharger and purposely go for the 550 flywheel hp kit because I believe it has pretty good reliability
#18
Again it's pure speculation when you start talking about blown engines and now secret PM's! Without at least a public admission from the victim there isn't much credibility with me! Can't understand why anyone would feel intimidated if their engine pukes for any reason? It's mechanical and they ALL fail sooner or later.... some sooner than laster as you personally experienced. However I could claim there are a lot more OP's with great FI systems and no problems but don't post because of insurance worries? Bottom line is I'm sure there are sorts of things that happens with these cars that are never posted....
Anyone that believes you can get 500+ rwhp for FREE is whistling past the graveyard of deceased engines. THERE ARE NO FREE LUNCHES when it comes to high performance.... Of course you can spend between 80 to 110 grand for a Z or ZR1 and get a warranty. I didn't happen to have an extra 100 grand collecting dust, DID NOT WANT USED, therefore spent around 12 grand and got a pretty fast beast that looks good to me! It's IN FACT got A LOT more RWHP then a stock Z06 and about equal to a ZR1. I could EASY get more then a ZR1 but I believe that's really begging for trouble. I realize my car is not either one of those other cars but it works just fine for me... I also turning a wrench and enjoy working on my cars.... so it's a win win!
I seldom argue... sorry you took it as such because I was simply stating a difference of opinion. I enjoy the heck out of my FI setup and believe Edlebrock makes a nice unit. If you're looking for monster numbers it's not the one to go with imo. I've had the good fortune to test mine under controlled conditions and it's plenty fast enough for me... that's all that counts really.
OP's that want to go FI should do a lot of research and be prepared for unexpected events.... if it happens it happens! My advice is have the money in hand should something go BOOM! The thing that drives me crazy is folks that mod the engine, it goes BOOM then they cry about it! If you're worried about something going wrong when modding for performance then leave it alone.. end of story...
Anyone that believes you can get 500+ rwhp for FREE is whistling past the graveyard of deceased engines. THERE ARE NO FREE LUNCHES when it comes to high performance.... Of course you can spend between 80 to 110 grand for a Z or ZR1 and get a warranty. I didn't happen to have an extra 100 grand collecting dust, DID NOT WANT USED, therefore spent around 12 grand and got a pretty fast beast that looks good to me! It's IN FACT got A LOT more RWHP then a stock Z06 and about equal to a ZR1. I could EASY get more then a ZR1 but I believe that's really begging for trouble. I realize my car is not either one of those other cars but it works just fine for me... I also turning a wrench and enjoy working on my cars.... so it's a win win!
I seldom argue... sorry you took it as such because I was simply stating a difference of opinion. I enjoy the heck out of my FI setup and believe Edlebrock makes a nice unit. If you're looking for monster numbers it's not the one to go with imo. I've had the good fortune to test mine under controlled conditions and it's plenty fast enough for me... that's all that counts really.
OP's that want to go FI should do a lot of research and be prepared for unexpected events.... if it happens it happens! My advice is have the money in hand should something go BOOM! The thing that drives me crazy is folks that mod the engine, it goes BOOM then they cry about it! If you're worried about something going wrong when modding for performance then leave it alone.. end of story...
#19
Drifting
The 550 kit is what I was considering among others. A good safe tune goes a long way to longevity, of course it will pull a lot of timing when it gets hot. Like a KB, it's a torque monster down low.
Most of the time you won't be in boost, only when you play. I go back and forth between the E-Force and Vortech kits.
Most of the time you won't be in boost, only when you play. I go back and forth between the E-Force and Vortech kits.
#20
Le Mans Master
E-force would be a bit quieter. The centrifugal whistle is bad *** though