Took the Vette to a Corvette Club sponsoring dealership...
#21
Melting Slicks
Honestly when I do have a car that is no longer under warranty (about once a lunar eclipse), I then go out and find a good and reputable ma and pop garage to do my work. They tend to be more personable and easy to work with.
#22
Safety Car
The giveaway is the ridiculous prices being quoted (and I am not a cheapskate).
$315 to read the Tech2?
Seven Hundred Dollars to replace a tire sensor? Excuse me, that is just robbery. The sensor costs about $50-60 and the cost to R&R the tire and reset it shouldn't be more than $25-35.
$150 to "look at" the rear? What are they going to "look at" for that price? They sure aren't going to strip it and inspect everything. Is that just to pull the rear cover and shine a flashlight in there?
To the OP: find someone who has a tire pressure sensor "tool", an electronic box to check them. Or buy your own, they are only a little over $100. Use that to check the battery status of your sensors. My guess is they are used up. The battery life is only about 5 years, so you're about due. I wouldn't try to change the batteries, just get new sensors. If you want to save a bit, just let it ride until you need tires, then have them all replaced.
Bottom line on the dealer? A rip, imo.
Find a good independent Vette shop. Ask if they have a Tech2. If so, they can probably do your electronic TSBs anyways. Maybe there's a good dealer in Houston, but it sure ain't this one. It would be good to try and line up another, though, for those rare things like recalls that your independent may not be able to do. For everything else, use an independent.
Just imo/ime.
$315 to read the Tech2?
Seven Hundred Dollars to replace a tire sensor? Excuse me, that is just robbery. The sensor costs about $50-60 and the cost to R&R the tire and reset it shouldn't be more than $25-35.
$150 to "look at" the rear? What are they going to "look at" for that price? They sure aren't going to strip it and inspect everything. Is that just to pull the rear cover and shine a flashlight in there?
To the OP: find someone who has a tire pressure sensor "tool", an electronic box to check them. Or buy your own, they are only a little over $100. Use that to check the battery status of your sensors. My guess is they are used up. The battery life is only about 5 years, so you're about due. I wouldn't try to change the batteries, just get new sensors. If you want to save a bit, just let it ride until you need tires, then have them all replaced.
Bottom line on the dealer? A rip, imo.
Find a good independent Vette shop. Ask if they have a Tech2. If so, they can probably do your electronic TSBs anyways. Maybe there's a good dealer in Houston, but it sure ain't this one. It would be good to try and line up another, though, for those rare things like recalls that your independent may not be able to do. For everything else, use an independent.
Just imo/ime.
#23
Burning Brakes
You might want to consider a subscription to Alldata.com. I do a lot of work on my cars and the servicve instructions from Alldata are helpful. If you are having issues with your car you can read through the TSB's published on Alldata (technical service bulletins from GM) and see if any align with your issue. You might be able to take care of a lot of issues yourself. Resetting the tire pressure sensors is easy if you have the $99 tool. Otherwise most tire shops will reset them for free.
I had the infamous "service active handling" on the DIC of my '08. It sounds serious but was an easy fix that is described in a TSB.
Good luck, do what you can yourself or arm yourself with some knowledge before going to the dealership and oh yeah....enjoy the car.
Here is the Alldata link.
http://www.alldatadiy.com/
I had the infamous "service active handling" on the DIC of my '08. It sounds serious but was an easy fix that is described in a TSB.
Good luck, do what you can yourself or arm yourself with some knowledge before going to the dealership and oh yeah....enjoy the car.
Here is the Alldata link.
http://www.alldatadiy.com/
#24
I found it amusing that you got all bent up because the dealer wouldn't just take your word for what was wrong and wanted to run their own diagnostics. Next time you get sick, go on the internet and diagnose yourself, then go to the doctor, tell him what is wrong with you and then tell him to just go ahead and give you the pills. I'm sure he'll think that's a good idea.
I'm a Finance Manager for a dealership, and I have also worked as a Service Writer. And, I can tell you, there is nothing worse than some yahoo coming in and telling you he has a check engine light on and he got the code pulled at Autozone or something and he knows what needs to be done, so just go ahead and do that.
There's more to fixing a problem than that. For example, does an O2 sensor code mean that the O2 sensor is bad, or that something is happening upstream that is causing it to fail? Is a misfire code due to a bad plug, or is there an electrical problem or a fuel problem, or a clogged injector. Without performing guided fault finding diagnostics you don't really know what is going on.
If the shop just does what you say and it doesn't solve the problem are you going to be OK with wasting your money? Or, are you going to go online and start trashing them for being incompetent and not knowing what they are doing?
I had a customer once who insisted that we change his themostat because his engine was running hot. I told him that may not be the problem, but he thought charging him a 1/2 hour diagnostic fee was just one more dealer rip-off. So, I wrote it up, and put on the repair order that the repair was done at the customer's request without diagnostics, and that we accepted no responsibility for continued overheating and that the repair was non-refundable. He gladly signed it and went on his way. Some time later one of our techs that knows some guys at another dealership in town told me that the guy was in there having a faulty fan motor replaced and ripping us all kinds of sideways.
I just leaned back in my chair.. and smiled.
I'm a Finance Manager for a dealership, and I have also worked as a Service Writer. And, I can tell you, there is nothing worse than some yahoo coming in and telling you he has a check engine light on and he got the code pulled at Autozone or something and he knows what needs to be done, so just go ahead and do that.
There's more to fixing a problem than that. For example, does an O2 sensor code mean that the O2 sensor is bad, or that something is happening upstream that is causing it to fail? Is a misfire code due to a bad plug, or is there an electrical problem or a fuel problem, or a clogged injector. Without performing guided fault finding diagnostics you don't really know what is going on.
If the shop just does what you say and it doesn't solve the problem are you going to be OK with wasting your money? Or, are you going to go online and start trashing them for being incompetent and not knowing what they are doing?
I had a customer once who insisted that we change his themostat because his engine was running hot. I told him that may not be the problem, but he thought charging him a 1/2 hour diagnostic fee was just one more dealer rip-off. So, I wrote it up, and put on the repair order that the repair was done at the customer's request without diagnostics, and that we accepted no responsibility for continued overheating and that the repair was non-refundable. He gladly signed it and went on his way. Some time later one of our techs that knows some guys at another dealership in town told me that the guy was in there having a faulty fan motor replaced and ripping us all kinds of sideways.
I just leaned back in my chair.. and smiled.
Last edited by DriverC6; 12-22-2010 at 11:02 AM.
#25
Racer
Member Since: Nov 2010
Location: Indianapolis IN
Posts: 276
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
So explain $200 to replace diff fluid (a problem Chevrolet has yet to fix after 40+ years of rear end chatter issues!). Also, the customer often has to pay for your dealership to "fix" something then pay again when your lame diagnosis turns out to be wrong. What's the differnce between that and doing what the customer requests? Finally, your smiling at the customer's loss tells all we need to know about You. How about publishing the name of the dealer you work for so we can all avoid it like the plague.
Wow! Good thing I posted so you guys could have somebody to vent on. :o
A couple of things: First, I don't work for a GM dealer or a corporate multi-dealer. I work for a highline store that is owned by a local guy who was born and raised here, worked his way up from lot boy, and runs one of the most respected dealerships in this city. People drive and fly in here from many states to do business with us because of our reputation for customer service and quality work. Our service to sales ratio is one of the highest in the nation because people who have bought their cars elsewhere and have had bad experiences bring them here for service.
Also, I can tell from post after post on this forum that some - a lot - most of you have had bad experiences at dealerships. I have, too. And, that's something that I have to deal with as a Vette owner because we do not service Vettes. (We actually do have a couple of guys here that know what they are doing - how to properly lift a Vette, how to install mods and perform any number of services.) But, there are still things that require special tools, diagnostic equipment, etc, that we do not have. Since I've only had my car about three months, I haven't had to take it to a dealer yet (thank goodness). But, when something happens that we can't deal with here, I'll have to make the same decisions you guys do. Who do I trust to hand over the keys to my baby? Do they have a Corvette specialist, or is my car going to get worked on by the same greaseball who just screwed up an oil change on a Cavalier?
I don't know where I'll take my car for service. I'll probably ask other local Vette owners, the guys in our shop who's opinions I trust, etc. and go from there. Hopefully I'll be able to find someone with whom I can develop a long-term realtionship.
Now, about the charges the author of this thread was asked to pay: I have no idea what it costs to diagnose and service a Vette. You guys think the quote was outrageous, so I defer to you. And, I agree that if something doesn't sound right you should walk away. In fact, in another thread a few days ago, a member said a dealer was going to charge him something like $325 to install aftermarket mufflers. I was the first one to jump on and tell him to shop around for a better price, and that I thought an independent shop or muffler shop would do it for $100 or less.
Nothing kills a business and a reputation like gouging customers and performing sub-par work. Places may have been able to get away with that in the past when there was less competition and no internet. But, not anymore. To build a business these days, you have to do a better job than your competition and earn repeat business.
Despite what some of you may think, I am one of the good guys. Most of you would like me if you knew me, and would probably enjoy having a beer and cigar out on my deck while swapping racing stories. (Unless you're a Michigan fan. Then, never mind.)
I run an honest business and don't try to sell people things they don't need or want. In fact, today I did something that I guarantee none of you have ever had happen. I called a customer who took delivery of a vehicle on Monday and offered to have him come back in and re-contract his car because one of the credit unions we use lowered their rates.
Oh, and BTW, the reason I said I smiled when I heard the customer had to spend more on a repair, was because I offered to solve his problem and guarantee a proper solution for 1/2 hour diagnostic charge (about $50) and he went off on me about trying to rip him off when he already knew what the problem was. He was a total jerk, but I did the repair he wanted. He then ended up spending more money because he thought he knew best.
#26
Race Director
Member Since: May 2006
Location: SOFLA
Posts: 12,973
Received 1,013 Likes
on
599 Posts
2016 Corvette of Year
2015 C6 of Year Finalist
You are the customer, you have the right to go in and tell them what you want replaced and fixed. They cannot force you to get a diganostic done. You can give them the service bulletins and say I want these performed, how much is it to do each of these per the TSB.
I want my rear fluid changed, I want the column clip done or whatever it is....
Jimmie Jam, what dealer do you work for so I can stay away from it ?
I want my rear fluid changed, I want the column clip done or whatever it is....
Jimmie Jam, what dealer do you work for so I can stay away from it ?
#27
Instructor
I have been scrolling the forums for going on five years in hopes that I one could possibly own one of these amazing machines luckily that day came a little over a month ago and I was finally able to get my dream car, picked up an 05 black m6 30k miles! The first week was great, minus dreaded rear end chatter then the little annoying stuff begins. First, CEL comes on, run the code and do some research and it has to do with the clutch switch positioning. Next, service active handling pops up as I am cruising down the road. Finally, the service tire sensor pops up as well. After searching and reading through many posts on the forum, none of the problems seems to be anything major, most can be found through TSB's.
I was quite skeptical about taking it to a dealer knowing I didn't purchase the extended warranty due to future modifications etc and I don't trust dealer service techs with my dream car, but many people in the Houston area highly recomended a service center located at one of our corvette club sponsoring dealerships so I gave in and dropped it off there yesterday. I tell the guy everything wrong and even tell them what they need to do to fix the 4 issues from all the information available on this forum. Well I get the call today and for them to run a diagnostic on it was $315, this gives them all the information I had already told them to do with the CEL, service active handling, tire sensor. Okay nice to know I just burned $315, wish I could have spent that on a Varam intake on sale lol. Next he proceeds to tell me it will be near $700 to replace the tire sensor and near $200 to get the CEL off and be assured that service active handling won't pop up again. Next he tells me that they still haven't looked at the rear end, but it will be about $150 to look at it and near $200 to swap fluid. At this point I say whats the point of trying to diagnose the rear end when you know that it has the wrong fluid in there. Long story short I ended up telling to leave the CEL and tire sensor on and just swap the differential fluid without "looking at it" and give me my car back. When I pick up my car the check tire sensor will still be there along with the CEL. For the dealer to tell me what I already knew and the rear fluid swap = over $500. Last time it will be going to the dealer to say the least.
Is there a better way for us out of warranty guys to get little problems like these taken care of in a more efficient manner??
I was quite skeptical about taking it to a dealer knowing I didn't purchase the extended warranty due to future modifications etc and I don't trust dealer service techs with my dream car, but many people in the Houston area highly recomended a service center located at one of our corvette club sponsoring dealerships so I gave in and dropped it off there yesterday. I tell the guy everything wrong and even tell them what they need to do to fix the 4 issues from all the information available on this forum. Well I get the call today and for them to run a diagnostic on it was $315, this gives them all the information I had already told them to do with the CEL, service active handling, tire sensor. Okay nice to know I just burned $315, wish I could have spent that on a Varam intake on sale lol. Next he proceeds to tell me it will be near $700 to replace the tire sensor and near $200 to get the CEL off and be assured that service active handling won't pop up again. Next he tells me that they still haven't looked at the rear end, but it will be about $150 to look at it and near $200 to swap fluid. At this point I say whats the point of trying to diagnose the rear end when you know that it has the wrong fluid in there. Long story short I ended up telling to leave the CEL and tire sensor on and just swap the differential fluid without "looking at it" and give me my car back. When I pick up my car the check tire sensor will still be there along with the CEL. For the dealer to tell me what I already knew and the rear fluid swap = over $500. Last time it will be going to the dealer to say the least.
Is there a better way for us out of warranty guys to get little problems like these taken care of in a more efficient manner??
knapp chevrolet is who I use and they do exactly what you ask, and no bs.
#28
Racer
Member Since: Nov 2010
Location: Indianapolis IN
Posts: 276
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
You are the customer, you have the right to go in and tell them what you want replaced and fixed. They cannot force you to get a diganostic done. You can give them the service bulletins and say I want these performed, how much is it to do each of these per the TSB.
I want my rear fluid changed, I want the column clip done or whatever it is....
I want my rear fluid changed, I want the column clip done or whatever it is....
100%
One thing, though... If you waive diagnostics, please don't trash the dealer or shop if your self-diagnosed repair doesn't fix the problem.
#29
You are the customer, you have the right to go in and tell them what you want replaced and fixed. They cannot force you to get a diganostic done. You can give them the service bulletins and say I want these performed, how much is it to do each of these per the TSB.
I want my rear fluid changed, I want the column clip done or whatever it is....
Jimmie Jam, what dealer do you work for so I can stay away from it ?
I want my rear fluid changed, I want the column clip done or whatever it is....
Jimmie Jam, what dealer do you work for so I can stay away from it ?
It's threads like this that make me hate the interweb
#32
Race Director
Member Since: May 2006
Location: SOFLA
Posts: 12,973
Received 1,013 Likes
on
599 Posts
2016 Corvette of Year
2015 C6 of Year Finalist
Of course, if changing XYZ doesn't fix the problem then thats on you
#34
Melting Slicks
even when a diag is done it might not pin point it and they still have to replace several parts in sequence to see if that works. With all the knowledge on here, I think every problem that the vette can have has been had and a fix to it posted. If 10 people on here had the same prob as I am having, I trust their fix more than a diag test. What did they do before diags? Good old knowledgeable troubleshooting.
#35
Melting Slicks
Tis true and as long as you know that then all is good. Like I said I find a good ma and pa garage when warranties run out, not that I let that happen often.
#36
Pro
I''ve made my living working on cars at the dealership level all my life and I'm now 61. Hard to believe. I've often said that if I couldn't fix my cars myself, I couldn't afford to own one. And this goes doubly true for a Corvette. If you are the least bit handy. Go online to ebay and pick up a scanner/code reader. You can get a nice one for @$200. Also call or email Gene Culley and buy yourself a complete set of manuals for your '05 Corvette.Then, read and learn and repair. You really don't have much to lose for most repairs. Otherwise, look for a knowledgeable independent ,honest mechanic, maybe even one who specializes in Corvettes. Dealerships usually have one or two extremely sharp techs in their service dept. The rest are just bodies. So, unless you are very lucky, you wonlt get a good job done and at @$100/flatrate hr for labor, the bill goes up in a hurry.Also to make a decent living, techs are forced to sell all sorts of unneccessary services on you vehicle which makes them money and only drains your wallet faster. Example: Injector flush. Vehicles have had deposit resistant injectors since the early Nineties and very rarely need any type of maintenance service. The list goes on and on.Corvettes are highly technical, complicated cars, but worth their troublesome nature to me and many others. You just have to learn to do it yourself!!!! Good luck and happy ownership!!!!
#37
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Nov 2009
Location: Klein TX
Posts: 3,052
Received 921 Likes
on
578 Posts
2023 C6 of the Year Finalist - Unmodified
2022 C6 of the Year Finalist - Unmodified
Thanks for all the positive responses. I was just a shocked that a dealership as well as two individual techs that came so highly recomended from the Houston guys on the forum would treat a customer who is knowledgable about his vehicle like an idiot, along with knowingly wasting my money. For any other minor problems I will surely be trying out other recomended shops.
#39
Le Mans Master
I''ve made my living working on cars at the dealership level all my life and I'm now 61. Hard to believe. I've often said that if I couldn't fix my cars myself, I couldn't afford to own one. And this goes doubly true for a Corvette. If you are the least bit handy. Go online to ebay and pick up a scanner/code reader. You can get a nice one for @$200. Also call or email Gene Culley and buy yourself a complete set of manuals for your '05 Corvette.Then, read and learn and repair. You really don't have much to lose for most repairs. Otherwise, look for a knowledgeable independent ,honest mechanic, maybe even one who specializes in Corvettes. Dealerships usually have one or two extremely sharp techs in their service dept. The rest are just bodies. So, unless you are very lucky, you wonlt get a good job done and at @$100/flatrate hr for labor, the bill goes up in a hurry.Also to make a decent living, techs are forced to sell all sorts of unneccessary services on you vehicle which makes them money and only drains your wallet faster. Example: Injector flush. Vehicles have had deposit resistant injectors since the early Nineties and very rarely need any type of maintenance service. The list goes on and on.Corvettes are highly technical, complicated cars, but worth their troublesome nature to me and many others. You just have to learn to do it yourself!!!! Good luck and happy ownership!!!!
The best investment you can make is purchasing the manuals from Gene. While codes can be read with a hand held you still need to run down a trouble tree in order to determine the component or circuit to be replaced or repaired. The Corvette Manuals give you everything you need to check out any problem. (see example Oxygen sensor in snowman0920 original post)
TSB issues are known by the dealers and should not be a problem. We all know the 07 Corvettes have the wrong rear fluid. Unfortunately, some require more than changing the fluid. We all know about many of the other issues Corvettes have as they are listed in the FAQ as a sticky. A dealer who is familiar with Corvettes and has a one tech who specializes in Corvettes should know exactly how to deal with these issues.
Unfortunately, as snowman0920 posted dealers need to diagnose the problem regardless of what we ask. If the car leaves the shop and is involved in accident or some other nasty event the dealer can be held responsible.
I have found it best to ask other CF members for recommendations with regard to vendors, dealers and alike (excluding modifying as this is an entirely different issue) When one individual is highly recommended by more than one forum member there is a better chance of not getting taken to the cleaners (AH a Corvette this guy can pay). Just use common sense after all it is your money to spend