2011 Grand Sport Convertible vs. Porsche Boxster S
09-20-2010, 10:44 PM
#221
Advanced
Member Since: Apr 2010
Location: San Diego CA
Posts: 50
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
This dealership problem is a side effect of having an awesome Vette.....that is made by a company that also makes Cobalts.
The Porsche advantage is that all of their vehicles are way above average in price and quality.
Chevy is trying to service the lousiest cars at one end of the spectrum, while also trying to meet the needs of a ZR1 owner. Such a crazy extreme when we really think about it.
The Porsche advantage is that all of their vehicles are way above average in price and quality.
Chevy is trying to service the lousiest cars at one end of the spectrum, while also trying to meet the needs of a ZR1 owner. Such a crazy extreme when we really think about it.
09-21-2010, 12:25 AM
#222
Team Owner
Wow, this forum is full of haters. I traded in a Boxster for the new Vette 3 months ago. I loved the Boxster for what it is (can out handle the Vette in its sleep) but lacked the power of the vette. The Boxster is definitely built better and I had no problems for the 4 years I owned it. I have already noticed numerous poor build quality issues with the vette...BUT...I am in love with this car. The engine and tranny are unbeatable. I don't regret for a second owning the Boxster and don't regret for a second going to the Vette. (quality problems are 1) cracks in the black sidewalls in the engine compartment, missing push pins in wheel well, paint job is missing in places(!!!)). Again, none of this tempers my feelings toward the Vette and I will enjoy the hell out of it like I did the Boxster. By the way, no one has ever dared call me a girl for driving the Boxster (at least not to my face)
09-21-2010, 06:23 AM
#223
Drifting
.....to be honest, neither does your narrow body C6. Sorry
09-21-2010, 06:32 AM
#224
Melting Slicks
09-21-2010, 10:02 AM
#226
Drifting
Me thinks that some of you folks take this forum too seriously.
All in good fun as far as I'm concerned.
The serious discussion of comparing a Boxter S to a GS was over a long time ago and the GS won as expected....... on a Corvette Forum
I wonder how a Boxter would do in the sand dunes?
09-21-2010, 10:17 AM
#228
Drifting
09-21-2010, 10:39 AM
#230
Le Mans Master
09-21-2010, 10:41 AM
#231
Burning Brakes
I assume since this is a Vette forum, the Vette will win out, but can anyone with experience driving both of these cars comment on how they compare in all areas? A fully loaded GS convertible ends up at $75K MSRP. The base Boxster S with the same options as Vette (and a few more the Vette doesn't offer) also ends up around $75K. So both cars are basically the same price, with the Vette giving 4.0s 0-60, and the Boxster giving 5.0s.
The Boxster appears to be much more refined on the inside, and both cars have their ups/downs in terms of exterior appearance. Vette has more trunk space with top up or down, but interior and seats on Vette are low quality. I drove the Vette (both manual and automatic) and it is a nice, solid, stable and smooth ride. I have yet to test drive the Boxster S. I have narrowed my second "fun" car search down to these two, so any input would be appreciated. I assume the Porsche would hold its value more, but maybe not? I also don't want to get into a Vette if they are going to release the C7 in the next 1-2 years...
The Boxster appears to be much more refined on the inside, and both cars have their ups/downs in terms of exterior appearance. Vette has more trunk space with top up or down, but interior and seats on Vette are low quality. I drove the Vette (both manual and automatic) and it is a nice, solid, stable and smooth ride. I have yet to test drive the Boxster S. I have narrowed my second "fun" car search down to these two, so any input would be appreciated. I assume the Porsche would hold its value more, but maybe not? I also don't want to get into a Vette if they are going to release the C7 in the next 1-2 years...
Both cars are among the best in the world at any price, you really can't make a bad decision. I will say this, the C6 was one of the BEST road trip car I ever had. Lots of room, comfort, and storage. The MPG was simply mind boggling for the performance, I think I got 27 MPG on one road trip to the Tail of the Dragon in my '07?
I would seriously consider a Cayman S w/ PDK also. I can understand not wanting to get into a C6 if the new C7 is expected soon.
Customer service can be spotty across the board. I know of a few Porsche dealers that could learn a few things from Chevy dealers. I think Corvette owners might get better treatment then a regular Chevy customer. That has been my experience local dealers. My experience with EVS, my Corvette dealer has been nothing short of exceptional. I am in Chicago and I'd actually drive up to EVS in WI for service for anything more then a oil change. They are that good.
Last edited by rexracerx9; 09-22-2010 at 09:30 AM.
09-21-2010, 10:00 PM
#233
Team Owner
Member Since: Feb 2000
Location: Conroe Texas
Posts: 35,340
Received 865 Likes
on
608 Posts
CI 1-4-5-8-9-10 Vet
St. Jude Donor '03,'04,'05,'07,08,'09,'10,’17
I've experienced service at several Chevrolet dealerships with previous Corvettes. Nearly all episodes have been bad-the poor workmanship has been matched only by the bad attituamandade. I've gone with non-dealership shops and a Cadillac dealership and have been pleased. The Vette costs as much as the Porsche, so why shouldn't customer service be equal or better? GM needs to address this if the "new GM" is going to survive. I hope that happens, but it remains to be seen. Otherwise, a huge bailout will go for naught.
09-21-2010, 10:04 PM
#235
Intermediate
Member Since: Aug 2010
Posts: 34
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Funny you should write that. I was on a large Porsche Forum for 4+ years and don't remember any comments about the Vette. They just were not concerned about putting down other cars to make themselves feel better. The same goes for the many years I was active on the Bimmer Forum. As a matter of fact, most comments about other cars were based on praise for their qualities.
Last edited by ralteredstates; 09-21-2010 at 10:07 PM.
09-21-2010, 11:37 PM
#236
Team Owner
Funny you should write that. I was on a large Porsche Forum for 4+ years and don't remember any comments about the Vette. They just were not concerned about putting down other cars to make themselves feel better. The same goes for the many years I was active on the Bimmer Forum. As a matter of fact, most comments about other cars were based on praise for their qualities.
Now you just spread it on too thick this time... 
09-22-2010, 08:02 AM
#237
Intermediate
Member Since: Aug 2010
Posts: 34
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
As I said on my first post (and you prove it), too many haters. If you think it's BS then check out those forums yourself. You seem too obsessed in patting yourself on the back for buying a Vette. The other forums focus on improving their cars and knowledge about their cars. Don't get me wrong, there seem to be many people on this form that strive for just that but you seem driven to put down others. Grow up
09-22-2010, 10:12 AM
#238
Team Owner
As I said on my first post (and you prove it), too many haters. If you think it's BS then check out those forums yourself. You seem too obsessed in patting yourself on the back for buying a Vette. The other forums focus on improving their cars and knowledge about their cars. Don't get me wrong, there seem to be many people on this form that strive for just that but you seem driven to put down others. Grow up
09-22-2010, 12:38 PM
#239
Drifting
As I said on my first post (and you prove it), too many haters. If you think it's BS then check out those forums yourself. You seem too obsessed in patting yourself on the back for buying a Vette. The other forums focus on improving their cars and knowledge about their cars. Don't get me wrong, there seem to be many people on this form that strive for just that but you seem driven to put down others. Grow up
We just like to have fun around here.
If somebody posts a picture of the pink Barbie Vette, most of us don't get our noses bent out of joint.
Real car guy/gals can dish it out and take it like big boys and girls.
A little fun never hurt anybody.
After all IT'S JUST A CAR DUDE
09-22-2010, 01:20 PM
#240
Team Owner
I hope you have something else worthwhile to do with your time.
We just like to have fun around here.
If somebody posts a picture of the pink Barbie Vette, most of us don't get our noses bent out of joint.
Real car guy/gals can dish it out and take it like big boys and girls.
A little fun never hurt anybody.
After all IT'S JUST A CAR DUDE
We just like to have fun around here.
If somebody posts a picture of the pink Barbie Vette, most of us don't get our noses bent out of joint.
Real car guy/gals can dish it out and take it like big boys and girls.
A little fun never hurt anybody.
After all IT'S JUST A CAR DUDE
