Vert vs Coupe-safety in rollover
#21
Melting Slicks
Here you go this is out of the book (Corvette C6) by Phil Berg.
To provide more rollover protection, the new corvette's
windshield frame is designed to hold the same weight as a
fixed roof.
Corvette even in its convertible form actually gone beyond
the federal requirement by having convertibles exceed the
standard for a coupe, says Dorian Tyree.
To provide more rollover protection, the new corvette's
windshield frame is designed to hold the same weight as a
fixed roof.
Corvette even in its convertible form actually gone beyond
the federal requirement by having convertibles exceed the
standard for a coupe, says Dorian Tyree.
#22
Drifting
But, don't they use a really heavy grade of canvas for the top?
#25
Le Mans Master
I can provide one fact for you. At the High Performance Driver's Ed school run by our Vette club, convertibles without aftermarket rollbars are limited to 90 mph. Now, that would take a lot of the fun out of it for me. I've had my 2008 Z51 up to 145 mph on the main straight.
#26
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
OK, lots of nothing but opinion...
The only fact is that someone made an arbitrary decision that 90mph would be "safe". There is no fact here.
Can't be too bad if it can hold up a Merc...
[/IMG]
can provide one fact for you. At the High Performance Driver's Ed school run by our Vette club, convertibles without aftermarket rollbars are limited to 90 mph.
Can't be too bad if it can hold up a Merc...
[/IMG]
#28
Race Director
NHRA rules: Corvette coupes are considered hardtops. Install a removable hardtop to a convertible and you are also considered a hardtop. FYI, I had a hardtop for my C5 vert which I drag raced. It attached with 2 thumb screws epoxied to the fiberglass. Legal?...YES. Safer?...NO!
For road racing, just get the rollbar and feel good that you're smart enough for not trying to cut corners with your life.
#29
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
For road racing, just get the rollbar and feel good that you're smart enough for not trying to cut corners with your life.
I've had my 2008 Z51 up to 145 mph on the main straight.
#30
Racer
Member Since: Jun 2006
Location: Berwick Louisiana
Posts: 410
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I've been following the other thread because I'd like to drag race a bit and I'm limited to 11.5 w/o a roll bar. I don't want to compete, just run test and tune nights but most all tracks use the NHRA safety guidelines even for street cars on test and tune nights.
#31
Melting Slicks
Gee, I'm so glad I asked for something definitive...
Guys, we all know that the C6 was designed from the outset to be a convertible, so to say that the roof of the convertible was only engineered to hold up the cloth is just ridiculous. Do you really believe that the coupe is only designed to hold up a piece of flimsy fiberglass? No. They are both automobiles and both have to meet the same safety standards, right?
What chaps my hiney is that convertible owners are supposed to go install a rollbar to hit most tracks when there is NO DEFINITIVE EVIDENCE that a C6 Corvette coupe is any more protective in a rollover than is a C6 convertible.
Guys, we all know that the C6 was designed from the outset to be a convertible, so to say that the roof of the convertible was only engineered to hold up the cloth is just ridiculous. Do you really believe that the coupe is only designed to hold up a piece of flimsy fiberglass? No. They are both automobiles and both have to meet the same safety standards, right?
What chaps my hiney is that convertible owners are supposed to go install a rollbar to hit most tracks when there is NO DEFINITIVE EVIDENCE that a C6 Corvette coupe is any more protective in a rollover than is a C6 convertible.
#32
Race Director
Unfortunately the Vette makes the news a lot when people crash the Corvette. It seems like if the person dies they most likely didn't wear their seat belt. All Corvettes are extremely safe cars. I would worry about driving a Lotus more since the A pillar will actually break if you put too much pressure on it getting in and out of the car.
Corvette is an extremely hard car to roll over during normal driving. I don't think it would happen at any speed if you stay on the road. The coupe does give that extra measure of protection though, if anything from flying objects that usually fly around when a car crashes.
Corvette is an extremely hard car to roll over during normal driving. I don't think it would happen at any speed if you stay on the road. The coupe does give that extra measure of protection though, if anything from flying objects that usually fly around when a car crashes.
#33
Supporting Vendor
Member Since: Sep 2007
Location: Pensacola Florida GO GATORS!!! www.rlsebring.com www.c6c7vette.com
Posts: 11,216
Received 174 Likes
on
92 Posts
St. Jude Donor '17
No facts on your question BUT a quick fact on a related topic. The tracks have to deal with this annoying little thing called liability insurance that probably spells out everything the track needs to know and comply with on protecting itself from getting sued by people like you that want to run they're Vert (or any other car that the insurance carrier considered unsafe for this purpose) anyway they choose but then would probably sue the track for letting you and not looking out for your best interest. You could probably fabricate a removable bar for track use then remove it when you want the car to function as GM designed. Although the Halo is very strong there is not a whole lot of material there. Should be easy enough to emulate it temporarily.
#34
Race Director
However, ECS used to custom build roll bars for C5 verts, and they were also thought to be impractical/impossible at the time. They figured it out and now other shops make them. I'm actually surprised if there's that much difference between a C5-C6 roof clearances. Maybe ECS could be convinced to pioneer the development again. It's worth a phone call.
Last edited by C5pilot; 01-08-2009 at 12:26 AM.
#36
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Feb 2008
Location: S.F. Bay Area CA.
Posts: 5,188
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
[QUOTE=SSTEVEGS;1568464829]I doubt there is any published information you're looking for, hence one more 'factual' opinion: Insurance rates from my insurance company (State Farm) are lower for the convertible than coupe or Z06. This is probably due more to fact that 'Verts are used less in racing and have a lower frequency of claims. I never want to be involved in a roll over but if I was...I'd rather be in a coupe![/QUOTE]
Kind of a no brainer.
Kind of a no brainer.
#37
Le Mans Master
Unfortunately the Vette makes the news a lot when people crash the Corvette. It seems like if the person dies they most likely didn't wear their seat belt. All Corvettes are extremely safe cars. I would worry about driving a Lotus more since the A pillar will actually break if you put too much pressure on it getting in and out of the car.
Corvette is an extremely hard car to roll over during normal driving. I don't think it would happen at any speed if you stay on the road. The coupe does give that extra measure of protection though, if anything from flying objects that usually fly around when a car crashes.
Corvette is an extremely hard car to roll over during normal driving. I don't think it would happen at any speed if you stay on the road. The coupe does give that extra measure of protection though, if anything from flying objects that usually fly around when a car crashes.
In a Corvette, this is difficult due to the stiff sidewalls on the run flats and the low center of gravity. However, ride on under inflated tires or exceed the frictional limitations of the roadway and you can get a Corvette to roll over.(not very easy to do)
****If you have a sport utility vehicle, check the tire pressure often. The tire pressure is critical to a SUV suspension and roll over prevention due to the high center of gravity and the extreme weight shift they undergo in turns. Monthly is a good idea.*****
#39
Team Owner
Member Since: Sep 2000
Location: Far NW 'burbs of Chicago
Posts: 23,958
Received 2,057 Likes
on
1,366 Posts
St. Jude Donor '13
I can't verify this, but was told at the factory that the W/S frame on a Coupe is structually identical to a 'vert. If that's true, then the halo on a Coupe is something extra and something good.
A few rollovers are a flip where the top of the car barely touches the ground, or a very gentle tip over. But many of them are quite violent, imposing big side loads and multiple impacts to the top structure. In that case the Coupe is definitely better but maybe still not enough.
A few rollovers are a flip where the top of the car barely touches the ground, or a very gentle tip over. But many of them are quite violent, imposing big side loads and multiple impacts to the top structure. In that case the Coupe is definitely better but maybe still not enough.
#40
Drifting
Member Since: Feb 2002
Location: Forest Lake MN
Posts: 1,266
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
In the C5 Forum, I recall an incident where a couple with a C5 convertible were following a group of club members onto a freeway onramp, lost control of the vehicle, and ended up in a pasture rolling over multiple times. The couple walked away from the incident severly shaken but alive. As I recall, the convertible top bows are made of titanium starting with the C5 so maybe that helped keep the top structure together during the rollover.
Try doing a search in the C5 archives for this story.
Try doing a search in the C5 archives for this story.
When we think back on this incident - we are both very thankful that there was a chill in the air that morning....we're not sure we would of made it otherwise.
Here is the link to the story...along with plenty of pictures... http://forums.corvetteforum.com/c6-c...-included.html
Last edited by batmann; 01-09-2009 at 03:09 PM.