Gee...I Don't Get It...Bose Sounds Great!
#41
Team Owner
Member Since: Feb 2005
Location: FL
Posts: 40,972
Received 320 Likes
on
152 Posts
CI-7-8-9-10 Veteran
Cruise-In IX AutoX Winner
St. Jude Donor '05-'06-'07-'08-'09-'10-'11,'19,'22
St. Jude/CI Name Tag Designer
It's all relative. If you've heard better then it sounds pretty lame. My '02 Lexus GS430 had an awesome Mark Levinson system. It REALLY puts the vette to shame. I miss that stereo, but the Bose in the vette gets me by. I don't want to give up the factory NAV so I'm stuck with it.
#42
Originally Posted by fastgts
Then there's those like me that think the best sound systems for performance cars are made by companies like Corsa, Borla and such. Ah well, to each his own.
More on topic though, I currently have a '91 300zx Twin Turbo (C6 on order) which has a Bose system. I have no problem with the sound quality (I really don't use it much) but I have run into more or less minor problems regarding how the Bose in my car has amps built into each speaker. Does the C6 Bose also use this approach? Just curious, I won't cancel the C6 if it does.
Ken
More on topic though, I currently have a '91 300zx Twin Turbo (C6 on order) which has a Bose system. I have no problem with the sound quality (I really don't use it much) but I have run into more or less minor problems regarding how the Bose in my car has amps built into each speaker. Does the C6 Bose also use this approach? Just curious, I won't cancel the C6 if it does.
Ken
The door "twiddlers" (Bose's term), the rears (wired mono), and the center dash speaker (also fed mono) are just ordinary cheap 4 ohm paper cone speakers. The thumpers use cheap built in Class D amps that don't even have an output inductance to remove the switching transients. They depend on the poor frequency response of the thumpers to work. Note that the thumpers aren't musical, ie they displace air to create a thump, but they don't accurately reproduce bass notes.
The 3 channel 23 watt per channel Bose amp itself isn't high fidelity. It has a 12 dB per octave rising response (probably in an attempt to compensate for the fact there are no tweeters in the system). There's also a huge gap in the audible frequency response of the whole system between the midrange and bass, which makes male voices sound muddy.
The rears and the dash speaker are fed mixed mono, which badly trashes the stereo soundstage. There are no real tweeters, just overdriven 3.5s that make high notes sound shrilly distorted due to cone break up. Etc. In summary, the $800 Infinity system in a 1998 Dodge pickup truck has better fidelity. Much better.
Note that the base radio (non-Bose) does have the rears wired in stereo. But otherwise uses the same crappy speakers, which couldn't cost GM more than $2 each, even if they bought them retail from JC Whitney.
The HUs, either Siemens or Denso depending on which options you get, are pretty decent, and have 4 channel output. But the 3 channel Bose amp and the cheesy speakers are crap. Even very inexpensive upgrades will make the system sound much better.
I replaced the Bose amp in my car with an inexpensive 50 watt 4 channel amp, replaced the speakers with inexpensive Eclipse component speakers, rewired the rears to be stereo, and eliminated the center dash speaker. While still not an audiophile system, it sounds so much better than stock. There is now a well defined stereo soundstage, highs are crisp, and the gap between midrange and bass has been filled.
With the 10s gone, there is no ghetto thump, but for those who like that, a separate powered sub could be installed in the rear. (Originally, before I tore out the entire Bose system, I had a small Clarion sub in the back to add musicality to the bass. But after the other upgrades I did, I removed that as unnecessary.)
I probably spent a total of about $500 upgrading the system, including some trial and error. I paid retail, buying in unit quantity. If GM were to use the same components stock, the total cost wouldn't exceed $200 at wholesale in bulk, probably considerably less. That's likely less than the licensing fee they're paying for Bose's name on the doors.
Last edited by shopdog; 09-25-2005 at 03:06 PM.
#43
Safety Car
Originally Posted by shopdog
That's likely less than the licensing fee they're paying for Bose's name on the doors.
Last edited by webdzynes; 09-25-2005 at 03:43 PM.
#45
Melting Slicks
My gripe with the Bose is that the XM input isn't as loud as CD or FM. Since the original post related to using a CD, it probably sounded fairly good. There was a thread that forum member Ted G posted a few months ago where he talked to a Denso engineer and if my memory is correct the line level input for the XM was lower than that of the FM or CD, something that was overlooked by those who designed the system.
#46
Originally Posted by webdzynes
Good post. Made me wonder however who pays who for the promotion. Would Vette pay Bose for the name inclusion (and logo on speaker panels) or would Bose pay GM to have the bragging rights of being the one selected to go in the vette and have the right to place their namesake there?
#47
Race Director
Member Since: Nov 2003
Location: I am Jack's out-dated Fight Club reference. MD
Posts: 10,115
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by JmpnJckFlsh
Nah. Guys on this board are nice guys; we have fun, but not a lot a vicious flaming here.
Depends on the day.
#49
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Feb 2002
Location: Kansas City Missouri
Posts: 2,450
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The stereo in my 2004 grand cherokee sounds better than the stereo in either my C5 or friends C6. BlOSE is known for "all highs and no lows", this does not mean that the highs are high quality, as they are typically laden with distortion. I have not found anybody that when demonstrated the difference between a high quality audio system and BOSE has not seen the difference. If you think their auto stereos are a rip off you should look into their home theater systems where they charge thousands for cheap paper speakers, and poor quality amps with pathetic sound reproduction. Look into any of the audiophile forums for the inside story on BOSE. They spend huge amounts on advertising. Note that these are not just snobs who debate esoteric differences in 70$/ft audio cables, but these guys/gals will admit when a cheaper product has good sound. BOSE is just the opposite.
#50
Le Mans Master
Originally Posted by webdzynes
What is different between the 2005 C6 stereo and the 2006 C6 stereo? Anything?
#51
Originally Posted by Guitarstar
I own a Record Label & have a Hot Heavy Metal CD out on Tower Records.com, so I guess I know alittle about studio acoustics & sound. My 05 Bose system sounds great!
I may have gotten a later model- my Car was built in May 05 but no complaints at all, it kicks.
I may have gotten a later model- my Car was built in May 05 but no complaints at all, it kicks.
#52
Team Owner
Member Since: Jul 2003
Location: [Enter Unoffensive Comment Here]
Posts: 34,299
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Cruise-In VI Veteran
Cruise-In VII Veteran
St. Jude Donor '06
Originally Posted by Skytrader
Sorry I can't answer your question, all I can tell you is that I love mine. Some people complain about everything? If you are looking for something that sounds like a gang bangers home made system that you can hear a mile away (like my teen age son), then Bose is not for you. If you are looking for quality sound reproduction then it probably is. To each their own. You can’t please everyone, sorry you don’t like yours.
A high end system creates an equalization across the entire sound stage...from unaudible bass to pin drop treble. If your system is not balanced, you don't win..and a system can be VERY loud with all of this possible. When i competed pro I had a perfect score on the RTA and still hit 140db.
You should be able to close your eyes and see every instrument of an orchestra or band, not tell the bass is coming from the rear; bass is undirectional.
The C6 plays music, it's fairly loud...I certainly wouldn't call it "quality sound reproduction".
#58
Le Mans Master
Originally Posted by Crazy Cowboy
Bose, just like any other quality speaker manufacturer, has their high-end, low-end, and in between speakers. If you have ever pulled a C5 or C6 Bose speaker out you will see that they are DEFINATELY on the low-end of Bose production. I've heard some of Bose's best home audio and there is absolutely NO comparison in sound quality between those and the ones in the car systems. But the price of the stereo alone would probably increase by at least $1-2k for that kind of sound quality, there is definately not enough market out there by the average car owner to justify it even as an option. I'm not saying I don't like the C6 Bose system, it's definately more than adequate for listening to - all just depends how 'into' listening to music you are.
Last edited by Vette5.5; 09-25-2005 at 11:18 PM.
#59
Safety Car
Thread Starter
Member Since: Jul 2001
Location: Spicewood, Texas, USA TX-Texas
Posts: 4,456
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
Originally Posted by sjreeh
Personally I think the Bose system sounds okay except that max volume is not even close to what it should be.
#60
Originally Posted by lager99
You've obviously never spent even a minute in a high end system...and your son's system wouldn't count. I have never seen Bose in a car audio competition, not that they don't possibly make high end product, but I've never seen it.
A high end system creates an equalization across the entire sound stage...from unaudible bass to pin drop treble. If your system is not balanced, you don't win..and a system can be VERY loud with all of this possible. When i competed pro I had a perfect score on the RTA and still hit 140db.
You should be able to close your eyes and see every instrument of an orchestra or band, not tell the bass is coming from the rear; bass is undirectional.
The C6 plays music, it's fairly loud...I certainly wouldn't call it "quality sound reproduction".
A high end system creates an equalization across the entire sound stage...from unaudible bass to pin drop treble. If your system is not balanced, you don't win..and a system can be VERY loud with all of this possible. When i competed pro I had a perfect score on the RTA and still hit 140db.
You should be able to close your eyes and see every instrument of an orchestra or band, not tell the bass is coming from the rear; bass is undirectional.
The C6 plays music, it's fairly loud...I certainly wouldn't call it "quality sound reproduction".