K&N or stock paper filter?
#1
Instructor
Thread Starter
Member Since: Jul 2005
Location: CORVETTIESBERG
Posts: 139
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
K&N or stock paper filter?
I was wondering if its worth paying the extra money
as far as perfomance goes do you think i'll get at least 1.5 to 2 RWhp
or is it best i stick to the paper filter and change it every 3K miles
every thing but the borla stingers are/is stock
Thanks in advance
as far as perfomance goes do you think i'll get at least 1.5 to 2 RWhp
or is it best i stick to the paper filter and change it every 3K miles
every thing but the borla stingers are/is stock
Thanks in advance
#2
Team Owner
Member Since: Mar 2004
Location: Oklahoma City OK
Posts: 58,264
Received 1,680 Likes
on
1,302 Posts
C6 of Year Finalist (appearance mods) 2019
I think it is!
#4
Team Owner
Paper filter, and why do you need to change it every 3k, do you drive on dirt roads all the time?
Never seen anyone report a gain when replacing the stock filter with a k&n on the dyno, over oiling can contaminate your mass air wires, and paper filters better.
Never seen anyone report a gain when replacing the stock filter with a k&n on the dyno, over oiling can contaminate your mass air wires, and paper filters better.
#5
Instructor
Thread Starter
Member Since: Jul 2005
Location: CORVETTIESBERG
Posts: 139
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by StephenT
Paper filter, and why do you need to change it every 3k, do you drive on dirt roads all the time?
Never seen anyone report a gain when replacing the stock filter with a k&n on the dyno, over oiling can contaminate your mass air wires, and paper filters better.
Never seen anyone report a gain when replacing the stock filter with a k&n on the dyno, over oiling can contaminate your mass air wires, and paper filters better.
i check the filter as well and it is usually a gray shade
(bright white when new) so i figure might as well do it to
#7
Safety Car
Member Since: Jan 2005
Location: Lake Ridge VA
Posts: 4,799
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by screw991le
Paper, and the 3k miles is not needed. 10k is about right. IMHO
Unless you drive through dust storms every day...3k is just a waste
#8
Instructor
Member Since: Jun 2001
Location: Crestview Florida
Posts: 187
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Advance Auto store has a display where they use a Fram filter to flow air thru a tube to pick up a plastic ball. If you set up the display to allow the ball to just hover in the lower section of the tube then change out the Fram for a K&N the ball slams up to the limit. This tells you that the K&N flows a lot better even without the oil on the filter. do you have to use the oil or can you just use the K&N filter alone and clean it once in awhile? Seems the K&N would be better anyway you look at it.
#9
Team Owner
Originally Posted by Torchred62
Advance Auto store has a display where they use a Fram filter to flow air thru a tube to pick up a plastic ball. If you set up the display to allow the ball to just hover in the lower section of the tube then change out the Fram for a K&N the ball slams up to the limit. This tells you that the K&N flows a lot better even without the oil on the filter. do you have to use the oil or can you just use the K&N filter alone and clean it once in awhile? Seems the K&N would be better anyway you look at it.
So a floating Ping-Pong ball is a better measurement of RWHP then a dyno? The k&n filter needs oil to help trap dirt.
#10
Team Owner
Originally Posted by CORVETTE CRAZY 2
I only do city and highway but when ever i get my oil changed
i check the filter as well and it is usually a gray shade
(bright white when new) so i figure might as well do it to
i check the filter as well and it is usually a gray shade
(bright white when new) so i figure might as well do it to
Unless you only drive 3k a year, getting your oil changed at 3k is excessive too. The DIC will indicate when a change in needed, or change it once a year.
#11
Melting Slicks
Originally Posted by StephenT
So a floating Ping-Pong ball is a better measurement of RWHP then a dyno? The k&n filter needs oil to help trap dirt.
In considering K&N I was concerned about particle size that will be passed to the engine. I'm still on the fence about which way to go.
#12
Drifting
I can tell this is going to be an interesting thread, so I'll ask a question I've been thinking about lately. What type of filters do NASCAR and other racing series use? I bet they don't use stock paper filters do they?
PS: Before someone replies with "Nascar would go faster with a Vararam"....save it
PS: Before someone replies with "Nascar would go faster with a Vararam"....save it
#14
Drifting
Originally Posted by indy300
I can tell this is going to be an interesting thread, so I'll ask a question I've been thinking about lately. What type of filters do NASCAR and other racing series use? I bet they don't use stock paper filters do they?
PS: Before someone replies with "Nascar would go faster with a Vararam"....save it
PS: Before someone replies with "Nascar would go faster with a Vararam"....save it
Seriously though Torchred52, that auto supply store's K&N display is kind of a farce! K&N uses the oil to catch contaminants. Without the oil, all the fine grit stuff goes straight through! And adding oil to the filter would somewhat reduce the airflow. So the idea that, “. . . K&N flows better EVEN without the oil . . . “ is very much backwards!
Bottom line is that the K&N, properly maintained, will flow slightly better and clean better than the paper filter. But if it's not serviced properly, it will either let the fine grit into your intake, gradually eating up the pistons & rings, or it can introduce oil contamination into the intake sensors.
On a car anything close to stock, I don’t think a K&N filter will add any HP. My understanding is that the primary airflow restriction on a stock motor is more in the heads, valves, and exhaust.
But if you’re running a pumped up motor (moddified heads, cam, valves and exhaust) that needs to suck more air, then the K&N can help it breath better, thus milking out a few extra ponies. But most guys in that world go with something like a Black Wing or a Halitech (same idea as K&N, but more surface area and even more flow).
BTW – Torchred62 – Running the K&N dry is NOT an option, no matter how often you clean it, unless you like to contribute to your mechanic’s retirement fund.
Last edited by 1998 GTR; 08-01-2005 at 02:51 PM.
#15
Drifting
Originally Posted by CORVETTE CRAZY 2
I only do city and highway but when ever i get my oil changed
i check the filter as well and it is usually a gray shade
(bright white when new) so i figure might as well do it to
i check the filter as well and it is usually a gray shade
(bright white when new) so i figure might as well do it to
Last edited by 1998 GTR; 08-01-2005 at 03:11 PM.