Air Filter - K&N?
#21
Team Owner
Supposedly, K&Ns work real well when they are clean, but they get dirty very quickly. So if you really want to do it right, you need two of them. That way you can always have one ready to change out, and not worry about letting it dry after washing, and then reoiling. Also, this lets it sit for a while, in case you did put too much oil. Of course, this totally negates any cost benefit. But if you want the best...
#22
That's the whole point of spraying it with WD-40, to help trap dust and tiny dirt particles. The furnace/AC filter material I bought is washable.
Make the test for yourself. Take your paper filter from anyone of your cars, blow in through the paper filter, then draw air into your mouth. You'll find it very restrictive.
Do the same thing with your furnace/AC filter (preferably a new one). You'll find it's very easy to breathe through it.
Make the test for yourself. Take your paper filter from anyone of your cars, blow in through the paper filter, then draw air into your mouth. You'll find it very restrictive.
Do the same thing with your furnace/AC filter (preferably a new one). You'll find it's very easy to breathe through it.
#24
Team Owner
Member Since: Aug 2005
Location: Riverside County Southern California
Posts: 34,988
Received 501 Likes
on
342 Posts
Co-winner 2020 C4 of the Year - Modified
2018 Corvette of Year Finalist
2017 C4 of Year
2016 C7 of Year Finalist
St. Jude Donor '09-'10-'11-'12-'13-'14-'15-'16-'17-'18-'19-'20
PM sent
#26
Safety Car
Member Since: Jul 2008
Location: Made In America
Posts: 3,966
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
4 Posts
St. Jude Donor '10-'11
When I got my 85 five years ago I wanted a K&N, but I also wanted to keep money in my wallet. What I did was go to Home Depot and bought the best furnace/AC filter they had. One that stopped the smallest microns of dust and alergens.
I bought a second air cleaner lid and cut the opening out. Sandwiched the 2 furnace/AC filters in, lightly sprayed the filter material with WD-40 and put it on the car. For under $15 I have a free breathing filter that's doing the same thing an expensive K&N is doing. It works for me just fine.
I bought a second air cleaner lid and cut the opening out. Sandwiched the 2 furnace/AC filters in, lightly sprayed the filter material with WD-40 and put it on the car. For under $15 I have a free breathing filter that's doing the same thing an expensive K&N is doing. It works for me just fine.
Try Napa for 15.00 ACDelco....35.00 and 75.00 is insane!
#27
Safety Car
Member Since: Feb 2000
Location: MANDEVILLE, LA La
Posts: 3,771
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#28
Actually the K&N filter is nothing new when it came out (whenever that was). Old cars used to have what was called an oil bath air cleaner. These probaly stopped in around 1960, I don't really know. Anyway, all this oil bath air filter was, was a wire mesh soaked in oil. You could clean it with a solvent and then oil it back up and stick it back in your air cleaner.
I was born in 55 so I'm not that old (a matter of opinion I guess) and don't remember oil bath air cleaners.LOL K&N just improved on an old idea. I one bettered K&N because I kept 70 + dollars in my pocket.
I was born in 55 so I'm not that old (a matter of opinion I guess) and don't remember oil bath air cleaners.LOL K&N just improved on an old idea. I one bettered K&N because I kept 70 + dollars in my pocket.
#29
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Ditto here 1955. In fact, my birthday is tomorrow and I'll be a lot older at 54. I also remember those types of air cleaners back then. Did not think if it until you brought it up. Don't even remember what type of car had them, but it might have been on my dad's 60's Jeep.
#31
Team Owner
Member Since: Sep 2002
Location: OBAMA IS HITLER
Posts: 22,209
Likes: 0
Received 11 Likes
on
10 Posts
to the OP: if you think you were shocked at your mistake for thinking an air filter costs $75, wait till you're shocked at how much less a K&N flows when its dirty vs. paper
don't do K&N -- its a marketing ploy......stick with paper
don't do K&N -- its a marketing ploy......stick with paper
#33
Safety Car
Yes scientifically the K&N may let smaller particles thru, something like 5 microns vs 2 microns on the paper one. I believe the oil catches more dirt IMO. Dirt bikes all have oiled filters. I have used K&N in my trucks on dusty jobsites for years so I wouldnt hesitate to put one on the Vette. After 180K+ miles on one truck, the throttle body butterflys and associated parts were just as clean as they were from the factory. I also only burn Amoco/BP fuel so I believe these two factors help keep everything in pristine condition. I just purchased a new 09 GMC Sierra and one of the first aftermarket accessories I will buy will be a K&N and when I start the restoration of my 85 C4, you can bet it will get one as well.
Clean the K&N often especially when you encounter dusty conditions and definately use the oil sparingly and let it sit for a while before dropping it in and driving. As long as you are careful, you will have no issues with MAF.
Just my opinions, use what you are comfortable with. Just remember you wont buy another filter once you get the K&N.........unless you will drive the million miles its guaranteed for, lol.
Clean the K&N often especially when you encounter dusty conditions and definately use the oil sparingly and let it sit for a while before dropping it in and driving. As long as you are careful, you will have no issues with MAF.
Just my opinions, use what you are comfortable with. Just remember you wont buy another filter once you get the K&N.........unless you will drive the million miles its guaranteed for, lol.
#34
Burning Brakes
paper FTW. It filters much better as it wears, and they are cheap enough that my car is going to be long gone before the cost balances out vs. a K&N. No maintinence either, just pop a new one in.
#35
Safety Car
Member Since: Jul 2008
Location: Made In America
Posts: 3,966
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
4 Posts
St. Jude Donor '10-'11
Yes scientifically the K&N may let smaller particles thru, something like 5 microns vs 2 microns on the paper one. I believe the oil catches more dirt IMO. Dirt bikes all have oiled filters. I have used K&N in my trucks on dusty jobsites for years so I wouldnt hesitate to put one on the Vette. After 180K+ miles on one truck, the throttle body butterflys and associated parts were just as clean as they were from the factory. I also only burn Amoco/BP fuel so I believe these two factors help keep everything in pristine condition. I just purchased a new 09 GMC Sierra and one of the first aftermarket accessories I will buy will be a K&N and when I start the restoration of my 85 C4, you can bet it will get one as well.
Clean the K&N often especially when you encounter dusty conditions and definately use the oil sparingly and let it sit for a while before dropping it in and driving. As long as you are careful, you will have no issues with MAF.
Just my opinions, use what you are comfortable with. Just remember you wont buy another filter once you get the K&N.........unless you will drive the million miles its guaranteed for, lol.
Clean the K&N often especially when you encounter dusty conditions and definately use the oil sparingly and let it sit for a while before dropping it in and driving. As long as you are careful, you will have no issues with MAF.
Just my opinions, use what you are comfortable with. Just remember you wont buy another filter once you get the K&N.........unless you will drive the million miles its guaranteed for, lol.
I only use BP with invigorate 93 octane.
#36
I have had a K&N in my 88 Vette for about 15 years. I have read elsewhere the same thing I read here, that the K&N does not trap as much dust as a paper filter. That and the fact that it's just a pain to maintain has convinced me that I will be getting a paper filter the next go around.
I raced dirt bikes in the early seventies and the K&N was the latest and greatest thing. The one I bought in about 1973 was an oiled foam filter, not the mesh that we see now. It worked GREAT for it's purpose because we often raced in SUPER dusty conditions. In fact in many cases DANGEROUSLY dusty conditions, because we were riding blind at times just hoping for the best. The K&N fit that purpose very well, but the product it has morphed into is not as well suited for it's application.
My $0.02,
I raced dirt bikes in the early seventies and the K&N was the latest and greatest thing. The one I bought in about 1973 was an oiled foam filter, not the mesh that we see now. It worked GREAT for it's purpose because we often raced in SUPER dusty conditions. In fact in many cases DANGEROUSLY dusty conditions, because we were riding blind at times just hoping for the best. The K&N fit that purpose very well, but the product it has morphed into is not as well suited for it's application.
My $0.02,
#37
Well, it all boils down to, how much do you drive your car and where it's driven. If its an everyday car then a paper filter is probably best. The worst part of driving any car everyday is when you run into that road crew sand blasting an overhead bridge or something like that.
If its a fair weather car that is driven every other week end then a K&N or like my home made air filter is best. If I see a sand storm up ahead (sand blasting crew), I don't go through that when I'm joy riding my Corvettes.
Just one more thing. What does get past a K&N or any free breathing air filter gets burned up in one of the cylinders and out the exhaust it goes. What get's past the piston rings ends up in the oil pan then the oil filter traps it. We all know this is why we change our oil and filter. Just a comparison, how often do any of us clean the foam rubber or paper filter in our lawn mowers or change the oil?
If its a fair weather car that is driven every other week end then a K&N or like my home made air filter is best. If I see a sand storm up ahead (sand blasting crew), I don't go through that when I'm joy riding my Corvettes.
Just one more thing. What does get past a K&N or any free breathing air filter gets burned up in one of the cylinders and out the exhaust it goes. What get's past the piston rings ends up in the oil pan then the oil filter traps it. We all know this is why we change our oil and filter. Just a comparison, how often do any of us clean the foam rubber or paper filter in our lawn mowers or change the oil?
#38
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
Well everyone, thanks for all the feedback. I think I'm going to stay with the paper filter for now, but I am going to get it at a different place. The reason I originally said $75, because I had the car in for radiator work. I had the radiator replaced along with the hoses, and the transmission flushed. When they had it apart, the air filter need to be replaced so I told the shop to go ahead and replace it. I did not know they charged me that much until I got home and looked at the break down of the charges. I was assuming it was "expensive" part, but if I can get it for $15, that is not that bad.