In order for the Catalytic Converter to “Light Off” and continue to maintain a working temperature, it actually needs some excess fuel (rich fuel mixture) in the exhaust.
Most OEM’s will cycle from Rich to Lean (but averaging 14.7) during normal driving to provide the fuel “wash” to keep the converter happy.
See the image bellow.
That’s why the cheap AF meters, using the narrow band sensors output, bounce around and are worthless during normal cruising.
With a Wide Band AF meter, your results will depend on how the data sampling matches the OEM software’s cycle, and how much filtering (averaging) of the data is being done.
You can imagine if you read mostly on the Peaks or Valleys, how your readings could be skewed.
Most of the Wide Band meters should have settings to increase averaging or change the sample rate, which should help your problems.