You ready for this one? I think I found my engine miss.
#1
Senior Member since 1492
Thread Starter
You ready for this one? I think I found my engine miss.
Here's my first post about my recent engine miss.
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/showthread.php?t=915441
Well I replaced the plug wires and the coil....no change. Then I noticed that the engine began to miss right after my spal fans "kicked-on."
I was baffeled. So I disconnected the fan wires leading to the temperature switch....miss is gone? Engine runs great. I connect one of the leads back to the sending unit....no miss! I connect the other wire to the same sending unit and I start getting a miss???
Any ideas? Should I have two separate sending units and have each fan have it's own sending unit?
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/showthread.php?t=915441
Well I replaced the plug wires and the coil....no change. Then I noticed that the engine began to miss right after my spal fans "kicked-on."
I was baffeled. So I disconnected the fan wires leading to the temperature switch....miss is gone? Engine runs great. I connect one of the leads back to the sending unit....no miss! I connect the other wire to the same sending unit and I start getting a miss???
Any ideas? Should I have two separate sending units and have each fan have it's own sending unit?
#3
I'm wondering, are the fans wired to a relay? I'm not an expert ( so don't anyone jump on me), but I was wondering if they were wired to a relay maybe that would help. I had an electric fan hooked up once and my buddy wired it through a relay that had 4 or 5 connections
#5
Melting Slicks
Member Since: Jul 2001
Location: Massapequa Park NY
Posts: 2,604
Likes: 0
Received 10 Likes
on
8 Posts
Are you running the stock 42 amp alternator? Maybe you're exceding the capacity of the system. What kind of current draw are you experiencing with both fans running and what does the voltage dip to?
I will be installing the same setup & maybe electric headlight operators. I also plan to upgrade to a higher output alternator.
Jim
I will be installing the same setup & maybe electric headlight operators. I also plan to upgrade to a higher output alternator.
Jim
#6
Team Owner
Member Since: Jun 2004
Location: Smile, it's just the internet.
Posts: 20,216
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
2 Posts
I'm running dual Spals with both gray leads connected directly to a single sending unit with no problems. The orange leads are connected to the ignition switch. The yellow leads are connected directly to the battery. The red leads are connected to the fans. The black leads are connected to the engine PS head. None of the wires were spliced or cut. I just crimped connectors on the ends of the wires and fastened them down. I'm not even using an alternator...yet. Heck, I'm even running MSD w/a HVC coil. If it's a matter of current, mine should be doing it too!
You got me...
You got me...
#7
Burning Brakes
Originally Posted by Jughead
I connect one of the leads back to the sending unit....no miss! I connect the other wire to the same sending unit and I start getting a miss???
#8
Senior Member since 1492
Thread Starter
Fans are running thru 2 realys.
The alternator is SB stock, don't know the amp.
This setup worked great when I had my SB in there. I think the SB put a voo-doo curse on the wiring and the BB before it left the car.
I have the red wires going directly to the fans.
The yellow wires are running to the 30A fuses and then the outer most starter terminal.
The orange wires I have running to a red wire which I believe runs off the winshield wipers.
Like I said this setup worked great 2 months ago.
What's that Italian curse....Scala-ma-gooch? Maybe I got some of that too.
It felt good though, going foward about 10 ft over and over again.
The alternator is SB stock, don't know the amp.
This setup worked great when I had my SB in there. I think the SB put a voo-doo curse on the wiring and the BB before it left the car.
I have the red wires going directly to the fans.
The yellow wires are running to the 30A fuses and then the outer most starter terminal.
The orange wires I have running to a red wire which I believe runs off the winshield wipers.
Like I said this setup worked great 2 months ago.
What's that Italian curse....Scala-ma-gooch? Maybe I got some of that too.
It felt good though, going foward about 10 ft over and over again.
#9
Team Owner
Member Since: Jun 2004
Location: Smile, it's just the internet.
Posts: 20,216
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
2 Posts
What kind of ignition are you running? The outermost terminal on the starter goes to the coil on the stock systems. My MSD doesn't use it, though. I left it unused. Perhaps you have some noise getting into the coil from the fans. Try connecting the yellow to the big dog on the starter.
#10
Senior Member since 1492
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by CGGorman
What kind of ignition are you running? The outermost terminal on the starter goes to the coil on the stock systems. My MSD doesn't use it, though. I left it unused. Perhaps you have some noise getting into the coil from the fans. Try connecting the yellow to the big dog on the starter.
Stock ignition.
Outermost = passenger side.
Both yellows? I gotta wait until the behemoth cools down.
#11
Senior Member since 1492
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by Bobchad
Does it do the same thing if you connect the fans in the reverse order? Or does it start to miss when you connect that one fan. I guess I'm trying to determine if it is a power draw issue or an issue with that one fan and/or its wiring.
I could be wrong, I'll try again later.
#12
Originally Posted by 70BBvert
Are you running the stock 42 amp alternator? Maybe you're exceding the capacity of the system.
This is the most likely cause. Monitor the voltage at the alternator - if you notice a significant drop when both fans come on (maybe 3 volts or more) your alternator is not able to supply enough current.
This would explain your miss because the drop in voltage would be seen throughout the entire car including your ignition system. Either your alternator is worn out or it just doesn't have a high enough current generating capacity. Your battery may be contributing to the problem if it is weak.
Good Luck & thanks for keeping us posted this is an interesting problem.
#13
Instructor
Member Since: May 2004
Location: Santa Monica CA
Posts: 199
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I would be surprised if it's the alternator. A lot of racers take their alternator off completely without consequence to the engine... my understanding is that it's just to keep your battery charged.
I think it's a strange enough problem that your test is worth repeating. Make double-sure that it's the second temperature switch lead that causes the miss. If it is, then maybe the minimal current draw from the switched-on fans triggers a larger current draw from the battery (I assume the fans are directly hooked up to the positive battery terminal or starter?) and diminishes the voltage output from the distributor.
Try your temperature switch lead test while jumping the battery - that will tell you if it's a current output problem.
Good luck!
Dave
I think it's a strange enough problem that your test is worth repeating. Make double-sure that it's the second temperature switch lead that causes the miss. If it is, then maybe the minimal current draw from the switched-on fans triggers a larger current draw from the battery (I assume the fans are directly hooked up to the positive battery terminal or starter?) and diminishes the voltage output from the distributor.
Try your temperature switch lead test while jumping the battery - that will tell you if it's a current output problem.
Good luck!
Dave
#14
Senior Member since 1492
Thread Starter
Last week when I was trying to get the engine running I noticed that a few times, the engine just quit! I now think it was shutting off just when the fans kicked on?
#15
Burning Brakes
Member Since: Feb 2004
Location: In the Beautiful Shenandoah Valley of VA
Posts: 958
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Last week when I was trying to get the engine running I noticed that a few times, the engine just quit! I now think it was shutting off just when the fans kicked on?
Steve
#16
Safety Car
Alternator-
If you go to electric fans, you need to upgrade your electrical system also IMHO for longevity.
Your ignition has a voltage tolerance spec, and with the dual fans, you are going beyond the alternators power limit and going out of voltage regulation.
Get an 85Amp alternator, the 85Amp belt (its longer and you'll need it) and a good battery like an Optima. Check out Parts America.com for the belt and alternator part numbers.
My guess is troubles will be gone.
Wiring should direct to battery for fans power also so there is no pull from the circuit that provides power to your ignition. This would cause a drop in voltage to the ignition module and could even cause a fire if the wiring overheated.
Brent...
If you go to electric fans, you need to upgrade your electrical system also IMHO for longevity.
Your ignition has a voltage tolerance spec, and with the dual fans, you are going beyond the alternators power limit and going out of voltage regulation.
Get an 85Amp alternator, the 85Amp belt (its longer and you'll need it) and a good battery like an Optima. Check out Parts America.com for the belt and alternator part numbers.
My guess is troubles will be gone.
Wiring should direct to battery for fans power also so there is no pull from the circuit that provides power to your ignition. This would cause a drop in voltage to the ignition module and could even cause a fire if the wiring overheated.
Brent...
Last edited by MN-Brent; 10-07-2004 at 12:33 AM.
#17
Race Director
Member Since: Sep 2002
Location: San Diego - Deep Within The State of CONFUSION!
Posts: 10,362
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Originally Posted by Jughead
Here's my first post about my recent engine miss.
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/showthread.php?t=915441
Well I replaced the plug wires and the coil....no change. Then I noticed that the engine began to miss right after my spal fans "kicked-on."
I was baffeled. So I disconnected the fan wires leading to the temperature switch....miss is gone? Engine runs great. I connect one of the leads back to the sending unit....no miss! I connect the other wire to the same sending unit and I start getting a miss???
Any ideas? Should I have two separate sending units and have each fan have it's own sending unit?
http://forums.corvetteforum.com/showthread.php?t=915441
Well I replaced the plug wires and the coil....no change. Then I noticed that the engine began to miss right after my spal fans "kicked-on."
I was baffeled. So I disconnected the fan wires leading to the temperature switch....miss is gone? Engine runs great. I connect one of the leads back to the sending unit....no miss! I connect the other wire to the same sending unit and I start getting a miss???
Any ideas? Should I have two separate sending units and have each fan have it's own sending unit?
#18
Pro
Member Since: Oct 2003
Location: I'm bleeding, making me the victor!
Posts: 565
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
That stock alternator has got to go! Remember, that 42(or 62 or whatever it is) amps is at 2500 rpms and up, not at idle. If it is a low speed only miss, that is probably your problem. More power captain!
#20
Melting Slicks
Member Since: May 1999
Location: Moon Township PA
Posts: 2,897
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Jughead
Fans are running thru 2 realys.
The alternator is SB stock, don't know the amp.
This setup worked great when I had my SB in there. I think the SB put a voo-doo curse on the wiring and the BB before it left the car.
I have the red wires going directly to the fans.
The yellow wires are running to the 30A fuses and then the outer most starter terminal.
The orange wires I have running to a red wire which I believe runs off the winshield wipers.
Like I said this setup worked great 2 months ago.
What's that Italian curse....Scala-ma-gooch? Maybe I got some of that too.
It felt good though, going foward about 10 ft over and over again.
The alternator is SB stock, don't know the amp.
This setup worked great when I had my SB in there. I think the SB put a voo-doo curse on the wiring and the BB before it left the car.
I have the red wires going directly to the fans.
The yellow wires are running to the 30A fuses and then the outer most starter terminal.
The orange wires I have running to a red wire which I believe runs off the winshield wipers.
Like I said this setup worked great 2 months ago.
What's that Italian curse....Scala-ma-gooch? Maybe I got some of that too.
It felt good though, going foward about 10 ft over and over again.
Gary