Holley Carburetor Heat shield
#1
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
Holley Carburetor Heat shield
Spent most of the afternoon installing the Holley Carb heat shield. As usual, nothing fits a C3 Corvette "out of the box". I had to trim here & trim there to make it fit correctly. Thank God for Dremel tools. Also found out, if you put the aluminum shield to a polishing wheel, it polishes up quite nicely.
Anyway, my question is: do they really work? keeping the heat away from the carb?
.
.
.
.
.
Anyway, my question is: do they really work? keeping the heat away from the carb?
.
.
.
.
.
Last edited by vetteguy75; 09-03-2011 at 09:19 PM.
#4
Le Mans Master
Member Since: Mar 2008
Location: Oxford MA-----You just lost the game!!!!
Posts: 5,948
Likes: 0
Received 63 Likes
on
53 Posts
Spent most of the afternoon installing the Holley Carb heat shield. As usual, nothing fits a C3 Corvette "out of the box". I had to trim here & trim there to make it fit correctly. Thank God for Dremel tools. Also found out, if you put the aluminum shield to a polishing wheel, it polishes up quite nicely.
Anyway, my question is: do they really work? keeping the heat away from the carb?
Anyway, my question is: do they really work? keeping the heat away from the carb?
Does anybody know if polishing the aluminum makes it reflect heat any better?
Scott
#5
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
#7
Team Owner
Member Since: Oct 2004
Location: altered state
Posts: 81,242
Received 3,043 Likes
on
2,602 Posts
St. Jude Donor '05
Not sure about the 100 deg thing but sure it makes a noticeable difference.
#9
Melting Slicks
Simply put the heat 'shield' acts like fins on a motorcycle engine case or the heat sink in numerous electronic components. It absorbs engine heat from the engine that would otherwise be absorbed by the denser zinc in the carburetor and allows it to be dissipated. If anything, polishing it would have a negative effect on heat dissipation since the smoother surface would have less overall area with which to dissipate said heat, but the difference would be negligible.
#10
Safety Car
polishing would make almost no measureable differance,
I am assuming, along with the sheild you isolated your carb,
with a thicker composite gasket, just the isloation with a gasket,
will drop the carb almost 100 degrees I measured it.
with a running warmed up engine, you cannot hold your hand on a carb.
more than a few seconds, Isolate the same carb
it will actually get very cold, amazing differance.
I am assuming, along with the sheild you isolated your carb,
with a thicker composite gasket, just the isloation with a gasket,
will drop the carb almost 100 degrees I measured it.
with a running warmed up engine, you cannot hold your hand on a carb.
more than a few seconds, Isolate the same carb
it will actually get very cold, amazing differance.
#11
Le Mans Master
Simply put the heat 'shield' acts like fins on a motorcycle engine case or the heat sink in numerous electronic components. It absorbs engine heat from the engine that would otherwise be absorbed by the denser zinc in the carburetor and allows it to be dissipated. If anything, polishing it would have a negative effect on heat dissipation since the smoother surface would have less overall area with which to dissipate said heat, but the difference would be negligible.
Or does is serve as a reflector, reflecting the heat from the heat riser and manifolds back away from the carb? In that case, polishing would have a positive, though negligible impact.
I don't know know..., could go either way?
#12
Intermediate
Member Since: Aug 2009
Location: Eastern Shore Virginia
Posts: 31
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Simply put the heat 'shield' acts like fins on a motorcycle engine case or the heat sink in numerous electronic components. It absorbs engine heat from the engine that would otherwise be absorbed by the denser zinc in the carburetor and allows it to be dissipated. If anything, polishing it would have a negative effect on heat dissipation since the smoother surface would have less overall area with which to dissipate said heat, but the difference would be negligible.
#13
Race Director
First thing I took off when I bought mine 10 years ago. Buncha fluff, can you tell me what the heat shield will do for you ? But at least you have the skills and realize you have to modify aftermarket parts almost all the time opposed to those that think everything should just bolt right up, and start blaming a vendor. You could actually have done that, name the vendor and say the part didn't fit and have a hissy fit.
#15
Safety Car
#16
Melting Slicks
Thread Starter
I don't really see it working that way. Presumably the carb should be considerably cooler (than the rest of the engine) due to the constant flow of (hopefully) cooler fuel and intake air moving through it. It will be picking up heat from physical contact with the engine and radiant engine heat, plus convective contact with hot underhood air. Insulating the carb from direct conducted engine heat makes a big difference (the base insulator), and the heat shield should block some of the radiant engine heat. However, if the shield is in direct contact with the carb (especially one made of aluminum, which has VERY high thermal conductivity), the shield might be "sinking" radiant and maybe convective heat toward the carb. There is no such thing as cold-----"cold" is just a relative lack of heat, and heat tends to move from areas of higher heat to areas of lower heat, trying to reach equalibrium. Its been a long time since physics class and I feel like I'm maybe sticking my neck out with my analysis, but, hey, that's what these forums are all about, right? Healthy debate and thorough humiliation!
The I way installed mine, was(in order from the intake manifold to the carb)
1) card board gasket (top left in picture) 2) Aluminum Heat Shield 3) 1/4" thick composite gasket (bottom left) and 4) the carb itself