NCRS to add " appearance judging "
#23
I'm not sure of the details of this either, but I don't think they are putting away the periscopes. Supposedly they are not getting rid of anything, just adding categories so the restomodders and modified cars can also claim some NCRS awards.
65hihp states this isn't movement away from their primary mission, but it has to be seen that way at least a little right? I guess I should look more closely at what they are actually adding before making assumptions. I did see the cars at Kissimmee, but the plan is to further expand this I think.
Probably time for NCRS to consider a name change.
65hihp states this isn't movement away from their primary mission, but it has to be seen that way at least a little right? I guess I should look more closely at what they are actually adding before making assumptions. I did see the cars at Kissimmee, but the plan is to further expand this I think.
Probably time for NCRS to consider a name change.
#24
Le Mans Master
They were in the tent at Lakeland. More will be in the tent at upcoming Regionals.
Come on out and have a look.
Come on out and have a look.
#25
Instructor
Member Since: Nov 2016
Posts: 209
Received 1,704 Likes
on
1,305 Posts
2023 C4 of the Year Finalist - Unmodified
I've been told that the Concourse Judging sheets are basically Flight sheets with the Originality side eliminated. The emphasis is on Condition and Operations. Cleanliness has never been a huge deal in NCRS. Each of the 4 areas has 20 points assigned to "Cleanliness"; 80 out of 4500 points. So there is Cleanliness in the new class, but it is probably low-impact like it is in Flight Judging.
#26
Safety Car
I think this is good news, and a good move by the NCRS... and one that I have been stating on their forum... oh, excuse me technical discussion area, for some time (and was generally shouted down for)
The NCRS is doing a good thing, by expanding at least the appearance of their tent to include more Vette enthusiast.... one day, it might be able to include ALL Vette enthusiast. Their core business can still be the preservation of factory like cars, but as the population ages, the new blood has to come from somewhere.
I know there are folks that haven't thought twice about the NCRS because their perception has been (rightly or wrongly) that they wouldn't be welcome with the kind of car that they have.
I had argued that they should welcome ALL kinds of Vettes, as once in the tent, folks might like the idea of taking their car the full restoration route...
Or not, but the benni is that you have more people in the tent, and more folks to share the cost of the beer kegs.
The NCRS is doing a good thing, by expanding at least the appearance of their tent to include more Vette enthusiast.... one day, it might be able to include ALL Vette enthusiast. Their core business can still be the preservation of factory like cars, but as the population ages, the new blood has to come from somewhere.
I know there are folks that haven't thought twice about the NCRS because their perception has been (rightly or wrongly) that they wouldn't be welcome with the kind of car that they have.
I had argued that they should welcome ALL kinds of Vettes, as once in the tent, folks might like the idea of taking their car the full restoration route...
Or not, but the benni is that you have more people in the tent, and more folks to share the cost of the beer kegs.
The following users liked this post:
Brian VH McHale (02-16-2017)
#29
Team Owner
I'm 48322, Ten year member.
Last edited by Frankie the Fink; 02-18-2017 at 09:40 AM.
#30
Safety Car
Here is a small excerpt from the rules of Concours 'd Elegance judging such as that at Pebble Beach and Amelia Island, etc:
" Each car must be correctly restored without blemishes, dents or marks on any part of the vehicle."
So the new Concours Division, or Class at NCRS brings Corvette restoration into the same category of the Big Boys..................i.e.: very expensive and truly collectable automobiles.The new class/division eliminates the ridiculous label "over restored" which allows Corvette owners to show their cars which have been restored to a very high level. So say goodby to such idiotic practices as oversprayed parts, partially painted parts, poor chrome finish, unpainted lower body panels, poor fit and finish, etc, etc.
" Each car must be correctly restored without blemishes, dents or marks on any part of the vehicle."
So the new Concours Division, or Class at NCRS brings Corvette restoration into the same category of the Big Boys..................i.e.: very expensive and truly collectable automobiles.The new class/division eliminates the ridiculous label "over restored" which allows Corvette owners to show their cars which have been restored to a very high level. So say goodby to such idiotic practices as oversprayed parts, partially painted parts, poor chrome finish, unpainted lower body panels, poor fit and finish, etc, etc.
Last edited by 65tripleblack; 02-16-2017 at 10:01 AM.
The following users liked this post:
Frankie the Fink (02-16-2017)
#32
Race Director
Member Since: Nov 2003
Location: Cottonwood AZ
Posts: 10,698
Received 3,051 Likes
on
1,935 Posts
C1 of Year Finalist (performance mods) 2019
I was a member of NCRS back in about 1977 and dropped out shortly after because I was not into sitting around talking about original part numbers day and night. I understood the need for it to create a judging manual but it just wasn't MY thing. I have owned some type of Corvette continually since 1969 and often more than one at a time. I see things from both sides and hope that we can all get along without comments like that.
The following users liked this post:
USMC 0802 (02-19-2017)
#33
Team Owner
Its worth the $40 to join to me for the NCRS Restorer magazine and Driveline - I've found some ultra-rare 63 parts via the Driveline!
#34
Safety Car
Member Since: Apr 2007
Location: PHOENIX AZ. WHAT A MAN WON"T SPEND TO GIVE HIS ASS A RIDE
Posts: 3,680
Received 306 Likes
on
220 Posts
PS my NCRS # is 7808
The following users liked this post:
USMC 0802 (02-19-2017)
#35
Race Director
The comment was made to "curb" those that don't belong to the CLUB, that continually open the mouths negatively towards the NCRS!
I'm still trying to decide if the new judging class is beneficial or a detrimate to the clubs original mission. The club is made up of a group of obsessive analytical men and women, me included! There are plenty more of these types out there to fill the roles....
I'm still a working smuck and have to leave, but I will return to this thread.
I'm still trying to decide if the new judging class is beneficial or a detrimate to the clubs original mission. The club is made up of a group of obsessive analytical men and women, me included! There are plenty more of these types out there to fill the roles....
I'm still a working smuck and have to leave, but I will return to this thread.
#36
Race Director
Member Since: Nov 2003
Location: Cottonwood AZ
Posts: 10,698
Received 3,051 Likes
on
1,935 Posts
C1 of Year Finalist (performance mods) 2019
The comment was made to "curb" those that don't belong to the CLUB, that continually open the mouths negatively towards the NCRS!
I'm still trying to decide if the new judging class is beneficial or a detrimate to the clubs original mission. The club is made up of a group of obsessive analytical men and women, me included! There are plenty more of these types out there to fill the roles....
I'm still a working smuck and have to leave, but I will return to this thread.
I'm still trying to decide if the new judging class is beneficial or a detrimate to the clubs original mission. The club is made up of a group of obsessive analytical men and women, me included! There are plenty more of these types out there to fill the roles....
I'm still a working smuck and have to leave, but I will return to this thread.
Of course it is detrimental to the original mission which is as the name implies a restorer's society. NCRS has done a wonderful job with that.
However, as stated there are only so many people today that can afford or want to re-condition a car to the standards of NCRS as it stood in the past. If the club wants to survive they will have to broaden their scope with some new classes to attract new members. There is no reason why it can't encompass both. It will not end the original mission and in fact as others have said here it may even find NEW members that decide they want to do a car to the standards of the original mission.
#37
Melting Slicks
Why so much worrying about restomods. If they are driven like mine has been for the last 5 1/2 years, they will flunk the inspection criteria used at Lakeland.
For me it's not how I fare in a judged competition, as I'm not one that will even spend the time to detail car for judging.
Would I enter my car anyway? The answer is yes. For me it's about meeting and talking with people about cars.
That's the enjoyment of the Hobby I have after my real enjoyment which is being involved in the Design/Building/Modifying of a car, as Subtle as I can make Outrageous exterior body modification using design features from other Generations of Corvettes look on a 2nd gen.
This class of Judging lets me go into the Lion's Den, of Corvette purist to get their reactions, Good or Bad body modification wise to a C2's body which is considered one of the Top 10 Automobile Body Designs in the world.
Some of you have to realize there are only so many C2's left out there that can be restored to a "Like Delivered from the Factory Condition". These cars in order to maintain there Value can not be driven, an are rarely driven or shown to the General Public.
Non original C2's can be brought to a reasonable sate of originality that are derivable that can be driven so younger generations can see them and learn to appreciate their classic design.
The NCRS might want to think about a Driver Class, Restomod Class that maintains a stock body, and a Modified Body Class where the originality of the body is not retain that is not just Restomods but all modified body C2's from over the years. Maybe a class for restored Drag cars and Track cars so their owners can show them off too, as they are a huge part of what made Corvettes popular.
For me it's not how I fare in a judged competition, as I'm not one that will even spend the time to detail car for judging.
Would I enter my car anyway? The answer is yes. For me it's about meeting and talking with people about cars.
That's the enjoyment of the Hobby I have after my real enjoyment which is being involved in the Design/Building/Modifying of a car, as Subtle as I can make Outrageous exterior body modification using design features from other Generations of Corvettes look on a 2nd gen.
This class of Judging lets me go into the Lion's Den, of Corvette purist to get their reactions, Good or Bad body modification wise to a C2's body which is considered one of the Top 10 Automobile Body Designs in the world.
Some of you have to realize there are only so many C2's left out there that can be restored to a "Like Delivered from the Factory Condition". These cars in order to maintain there Value can not be driven, an are rarely driven or shown to the General Public.
Non original C2's can be brought to a reasonable sate of originality that are derivable that can be driven so younger generations can see them and learn to appreciate their classic design.
The NCRS might want to think about a Driver Class, Restomod Class that maintains a stock body, and a Modified Body Class where the originality of the body is not retain that is not just Restomods but all modified body C2's from over the years. Maybe a class for restored Drag cars and Track cars so their owners can show them off too, as they are a huge part of what made Corvettes popular.
Last edited by Poorhousenext; 02-17-2017 at 08:43 PM.
The following users liked this post:
6T5RUSH (02-17-2017)
#38
Race Director
Of course it is detrimental to the original mission which is as the name implies a restorer's society. NCRS has done a wonderful job with that.
However, as stated there are only so many people today that can afford or want to re-condition a car to the standards of NCRS as it stood in the past. If the club wants to survive they will have to broaden their scope with some new classes to attract new members. There is no reason why it can't encompass both. It will not end the original mission and in fact as others have said here it may even find NEW members that decide they want to do a car to the standards of the original mission.
However, as stated there are only so many people today that can afford or want to re-condition a car to the standards of NCRS as it stood in the past. If the club wants to survive they will have to broaden their scope with some new classes to attract new members. There is no reason why it can't encompass both. It will not end the original mission and in fact as others have said here it may even find NEW members that decide they want to do a car to the standards of the original mission.
It may be argued that this may diminish the value of previous Top Flight Awards. I pose this question, in 20, 30, or more years from now, will a manual or an award be needed to teach future generations how to restore a car to it's "resto mod" condition or build?
It might also be said that these modders are simply in the wrong club? I think there are many, that have owned cars that they returned to an original state and others that have done the exact opposite. Each example, these folks have tired, and now search for more distractions from the trials and tribulations of life. This may fill the gap....
The NCRS is a great club, and it's original mission IMO should remain the same. If it dies, so be it. History will read that the club stood higher than most and was able to document, and retain the image it has had since it's conception.
I could never see Rolls Royce building an 35k economy car.....
Regards.
#39
C5 & C6 is the answer
I'm in the NCRS. I started on the "young" side at age 34. I'm not sure I agree with the new concourse judging. It's my belief that the cheaper corvettes that are NCRS "legal"are simply not that attractive. The C4s (84-96) just aren't that pretty. Now that the C5's are legal and eventually C6's, I think you'll see renewed interest from younger people again, without need to change the fundamental mission of the NCRS. 97-99 C5 is legal so market the hell out of that.
#4781
#4781
Last edited by igaston; 02-18-2017 at 11:11 AM.