Evans Waterless Coolant
#81
Safety Car
20 years ago i got a brochure from EVANS. says u can run up to 12:1 on pump gas and 16.5:1 on 108 race gas!
Sounded too good to be true, but, i've kept a lookout for anyone doing that.
So far, 20 YEARS, i've not run across anyone with 12:1 on the street with evans. Do they still claim 12:1 ??
Sounded too good to be true, but, i've kept a lookout for anyone doing that.
So far, 20 YEARS, i've not run across anyone with 12:1 on the street with evans. Do they still claim 12:1 ??
By simply stating an engine's SCR, you're only showing part of the picture. Intake valve closing point is needed and that's a good reason to specify DCR, which, by definition, is the compression ratio obtained by using the REMAINING stroke after the intake closes, rather than the entire crank stroke.
For instance: a 12:1 SCR 327 whose intake valve closes at 80* ABDC can run 93 octane pump hi-test all day long without detonation.
#83
Drifting
I also agree that if everything is configured as OEM, then if there wasn't a problem in the day then there shouldn't be one now.
On this one car I cannot figure out why it pukes only after shutdown. I can hear it start boiling then it shoots out (very embarrassing).
The radiator cap was checked and two different ones used that matched the OEM spec. My understanding is the radiator cap only adds pressure in order to raise the antifreeze boiling point. I don't feel comfortable going with a higher pressure.
I had a Robert Shaw thermostat and went back to 100% OEM that improved the situation but still when its hot out the radiator pukes.
The vacuum advance uses full vacuum (ie not ported). The only setting outside of OEM is the timing advance is ~2 degrees higher.
I was thinking if this Evan PG antifreeze boiling point was higher then it wouldn't boil after the coolant stops circulating after shutdown and cause the pressure to build too high and puke coolant.
On this one car I cannot figure out why it pukes only after shutdown. I can hear it start boiling then it shoots out (very embarrassing).
The radiator cap was checked and two different ones used that matched the OEM spec. My understanding is the radiator cap only adds pressure in order to raise the antifreeze boiling point. I don't feel comfortable going with a higher pressure.
I had a Robert Shaw thermostat and went back to 100% OEM that improved the situation but still when its hot out the radiator pukes.
The vacuum advance uses full vacuum (ie not ported). The only setting outside of OEM is the timing advance is ~2 degrees higher.
I was thinking if this Evan PG antifreeze boiling point was higher then it wouldn't boil after the coolant stops circulating after shutdown and cause the pressure to build too high and puke coolant.
#85
Team Owner
Member Since: Oct 2000
Location: Washington Michigan
Posts: 38,899
Received 1,857 Likes
on
1,100 Posts
On this one car I cannot figure out why it pukes only after shutdown. I can hear it start boiling then it shoots out (very embarrassing).
The radiator cap was checked and two different ones used that matched the OEM spec. My understanding is the radiator cap only adds pressure in order to raise the antifreeze boiling point. I don't feel comfortable going with a higher pressure.
#87
Le Mans Master
I have thought about using this product and here's why I didn't. When talking with some of the guys about this, and the fact that Evans tells you to completely drain your cooling system and either let it air dry overnight or blow high pressure air thru the system before adding their product so that it doesn't mix with any of the old alchohol based coolant, the question arose...what happens if you have an overheating/leaking hose problem when out on the road?? Can you easily/readily find some Evans coolant to top off after making repairs. The consensus was "No" probably not...but antifreeze is available everywhere. Hence, I still use 50/50 blend of Zerex. JMO
#88
Pro
#89
Pro
Mike,
I have thought about using this product and here's why I didn't. When talking with some of the guys about this, and the fact that Evans tells you to completely drain your cooling system and either let it air dry overnight or blow high pressure air thru the system before adding their product so that it doesn't mix with any of the old alchohol based coolant, the question arose...what happens if you have an overheating/leaking hose problem when out on the road?? Can you easily/readily find some Evans coolant to top off after making repairs. The consensus was "No" probably not...but antifreeze is available everywhere. Hence, I still use 50/50 blend of Zerex. JMO
I have thought about using this product and here's why I didn't. When talking with some of the guys about this, and the fact that Evans tells you to completely drain your cooling system and either let it air dry overnight or blow high pressure air thru the system before adding their product so that it doesn't mix with any of the old alchohol based coolant, the question arose...what happens if you have an overheating/leaking hose problem when out on the road?? Can you easily/readily find some Evans coolant to top off after making repairs. The consensus was "No" probably not...but antifreeze is available everywhere. Hence, I still use 50/50 blend of Zerex. JMO
#90
Pro
No, they don't, and no "answer" is required when there's no question to begin with; you are fervently seeking a problem that doesn't exist in order to apply an expensive "solution" that's unnecessary.
Here's all you need to know about Corvette cooling systems:
http://www.lbfun.com/warehouse/tech_...em/cooling.pdf
The cures for cooling system issues don't come in bottles - they come in boxes.
Here's all you need to know about Corvette cooling systems:
http://www.lbfun.com/warehouse/tech_...em/cooling.pdf
The cures for cooling system issues don't come in bottles - they come in boxes.
BTW big block corvettes do tend to run hot, and more so if horsepower is increased.
#91
Team Owner
Mike,
I have thought about using this product and here's why I didn't. When talking with some of the guys about this, and the fact that Evans tells you to completely drain your cooling system and either let it air dry overnight or blow high pressure air thru the system before adding their product so that it doesn't mix with any of the old alchohol based coolant, the question arose...what happens if you have an overheating/leaking hose problem when out on the road?? Can you easily/readily find some Evans coolant to top off after making repairs. The consensus was "No" probably not...but antifreeze is available everywhere. Hence, I still use 50/50 blend of Zerex. JMO
I have thought about using this product and here's why I didn't. When talking with some of the guys about this, and the fact that Evans tells you to completely drain your cooling system and either let it air dry overnight or blow high pressure air thru the system before adding their product so that it doesn't mix with any of the old alchohol based coolant, the question arose...what happens if you have an overheating/leaking hose problem when out on the road?? Can you easily/readily find some Evans coolant to top off after making repairs. The consensus was "No" probably not...but antifreeze is available everywhere. Hence, I still use 50/50 blend of Zerex. JMO
http://www.norosion.com/evanstest.htm
#92
Melting Slicks
GM uses Dex-cool in all their new vehicles. This product is readily available and better than the old green coolant. I thought about using the Evans coolant but I just couldn't see the value in it. If your car runs hot then you have other problems you need to deal with first.
#93
Pro
I wouldn't touch it with a 10' pole. I realize this research is done by a firm touting a competing product; even so it was enough to steer me far clear of this silver bullet:
http://www.norosion.com/evanstest.htm
http://www.norosion.com/evanstest.htm
Just because OEM is designed for a lighter viscosity doesn't mean it's a problem. It's the equivalent of saying we shouldn't increase hp in our engines because they were designed to be stock. I know of no water pump failures from running Evans, I've got it in 4 cars/trucks.
It's true heat transfer is superior for water, but Evans isn't "almost half" but closer to 2/3. An issue to be sure but let's not exaggerate. Also I'm having a hard time believing the super hot head temps because I've seen no increase in operating temps from my experience. If it sheads heat so poorly how can it cool off so quickly and not increase overall engine temps I've also seen graphs where the torque increased across the power band on a dyno after changing to Evans. Once again, "geographic" testing?
Evans can burn but it must be vaporized and sprayed on a hot manifold or turbo to ignite. I mean, we have pressurized fuel lines running under the hood, so we can't worry about everything. This must be also compared with all those serious steam burns that occur as a system component fails and superheated pressurized steam injures someone opening the hood.
#94
Team Owner
Member Since: Oct 2000
Location: Washington Michigan
Posts: 38,899
Received 1,857 Likes
on
1,100 Posts
See post #55.
#95
Pro
I've seen it and don't agree. Both Corvette shops I've had work on my car stated big blocks run hot. I've found a product that works for me, no corrosion due to acidic pH because of water present, and a lifetime coolant. It's not expensive if you keep your car for a long time, and 160 bucks for coolant isn't expensive in comparison to say fuel costs. If this seems expensive to you, I'm wondering why you don't drive a Honda.. remember I never flush and change the coolant in any of my vehicles any more. You will, many more times.
#96
Team Owner
Member Since: Jan 2007
Location: cookeville tennessee
Posts: 28,846
Received 1,762 Likes
on
1,529 Posts
The article was interesting but I'm always wary of "geographic" testing, meaning the results of my competitors product tested at my facility proves mine is superior. Nevertheless it is something to consider. But...
Just because OEM is designed for a lighter viscosity doesn't mean it's a problem. It's the equivalent of saying we shouldn't increase hp in our engines because they were designed to be stock. I know of no water pump failures from running Evans, I've got it in 4 cars/trucks.
It's true heat transfer is superior for water, but Evans isn't "almost half" but closer to 2/3. An issue to be sure but let's not exaggerate. Also I'm having a hard time believing the super hot head temps because I've seen no increase in operating temps from my experience. If it sheads heat so poorly how can it cool off so quickly and not increase overall engine temps I've also seen graphs where the torque increased across the power band on a dyno after changing to Evans. Once again, "geographic" testing?
Evans can burn but it must be vaporized and sprayed on a hot manifold or turbo to ignite. I mean, we have pressurized fuel lines running under the hood, so we can't worry about everything. This must be also compared with all those serious steam burns that occur as a system component fails and superheated pressurized steam injures someone opening the hood.
Just because OEM is designed for a lighter viscosity doesn't mean it's a problem. It's the equivalent of saying we shouldn't increase hp in our engines because they were designed to be stock. I know of no water pump failures from running Evans, I've got it in 4 cars/trucks.
It's true heat transfer is superior for water, but Evans isn't "almost half" but closer to 2/3. An issue to be sure but let's not exaggerate. Also I'm having a hard time believing the super hot head temps because I've seen no increase in operating temps from my experience. If it sheads heat so poorly how can it cool off so quickly and not increase overall engine temps I've also seen graphs where the torque increased across the power band on a dyno after changing to Evans. Once again, "geographic" testing?
Evans can burn but it must be vaporized and sprayed on a hot manifold or turbo to ignite. I mean, we have pressurized fuel lines running under the hood, so we can't worry about everything. This must be also compared with all those serious steam burns that occur as a system component fails and superheated pressurized steam injures someone opening the hood.
#97
Le Mans Master
No, they don't, and no "answer" is required when there's no question to begin with; you are fervently seeking a problem that doesn't exist in order to apply an expensive "solution" that's unnecessary.
Here's all you need to know about Corvette cooling systems:
http://www.lbfun.com/warehouse/tech_...em/cooling.pdf
The cures for cooling system issues don't come in bottles - they come in boxes.
Here's all you need to know about Corvette cooling systems:
http://www.lbfun.com/warehouse/tech_...em/cooling.pdf
The cures for cooling system issues don't come in bottles - they come in boxes.
John Hinckley's article on Corvette cooling systems was the most logical article I have read on the subject. When I was having minor issues with my car, Joe Lucia was kind enough to forward me John's article and I was ultimately able to solve my overheating problems. His article covers all the bases and the basics. Thanks for re-posting. I had been looking for it to share with others, as well.
#98
Melting Slicks
Member Since: May 2004
Location: Willowbrook IL
Posts: 2,227
Received 287 Likes
on
162 Posts
St. Jude Donor '13-'14-'15-'16
John,
John Hinckley's article on Corvette cooling systems was the most logical article I have read on the subject. When I was having minor issues with my car, Joe Lucia was kind enough to forward me John's article and I was ultimately able to solve my overheating problems. His article covers all the bases and the basics. Thanks for re-posting. I had been looking for it to share with others, as well.
John Hinckley's article on Corvette cooling systems was the most logical article I have read on the subject. When I was having minor issues with my car, Joe Lucia was kind enough to forward me John's article and I was ultimately able to solve my overheating problems. His article covers all the bases and the basics. Thanks for re-posting. I had been looking for it to share with others, as well.
#99
Le Mans Master
#100
Pro
This stuff works really good in my street car c5 vette with is a 427 procharger car. Never put it in the 65 vette, put also have it in my 57 chev 540 ci car also works great in it. The stuff is not cheap but does work in the c5 great. Plus their water pump works good but also is not cheap. Robert